mariuscomper.uk RO

Apuseni Mountains, Romania

The rivers that disappear

In the Apuseni Mountains streams run into holes in the limestone and are gone. Here is how anyone knows where they come out: someone pours in dye and waits.

What we checked

The network, and what a map of it would need

The plan was to light up the whole hidden network. The tracing records exist; the map coordinates mostly do not.

We read three tables in two open book chapters by Iancu Orășeanu. Together they print 123 tracer results. 51 of them used a visible dye (fluorescein or rhodamine B) and name a sink and a spring and give an exact first-arrival time: 34 in the Bihor–Vlădeasa table (2010), 13 in the Codru-Moma table and 4 in the Vașcău plateau table (both 2016). Another 13 fluorescein or rhodamine rows print no exact time (blank, or “under 300 h”) and are not counted. The remaining 59 rows used other tracers (iodine-131, bromine-82, indium or dysprosium chelates, Stralex, KI, tritiated water) or print none; we do not treat those as visible dye. All 123 rows are in the table below; only the 51 are in the race.

Gate 1 · at least 5 published dye traces: met, 51. Rules 1–3 of the pre-registration were written after we had read the first table; rule 4, the map rule, before any coordinate was looked up. The three tables are the source; we did not open the older papers behind them.
Gate 2 · both ends on the map: partly met, 3 of 51. A trace is drawn as a line only when its sink and its spring both exist in open map data (OpenStreetMap) and the straight distance agrees with the printed one to within 25%. Three did: R2 → Boga, Coiba Mică → Tăuz and Barsa Cohanului → Cetățile Ponorului. Most sinks are “losses of a brook” with no point in OpenStreetMap, so the rest could not be placed. For 7 springs that do have a point (5 from OpenStreetMap, 2 from a CC BY paper, Cîmpean et al. 2022), the page draws rings of the printed distance (18 traces, of every tracer): the sink is on the ring somewhere, which way is not known. We never draw a path that a trace did not prove.

Three limits to keep in mind. The time is the first arrival of the tracer, not how long the water takes. The speed is the straight distance divided by that time: the first dye, along its real and longer path, went at least that fast, and most of the water is slower by an amount the tables do not give. And the tables do not say how much water was flowing on the day of each test.

Your turn

How long did the dye take?

Pick one of the streams that sank. You get its hours, a walker for scale, and a picture to send.

Where does the water you drink come from?

Two springs take water from sinking streams

We wanted to ask this for any town. We could answer it for only two springs. In the Codru-Moma chapter Orășeanu writes that he proposed the Feredeu spring in 2013 for the drinking water of Beiuș, with the intake built in 2015 (printed p. 146), and that the Finiș spring is partly tapped for the water of the commune of Finiș (printed p. 141). Dye poured into sinks reached both:

So at least part of the water of those streams is shown to come out at these springs. We did not check that either intake works today, which sinks make up the whole catchment, or whether any other town in these mountains drinks from a karst spring: the same chapter names other drinking-water intakes, for example the spring in the Luncii valley for Dumbrăvița de Codru (p. 145), which we did not follow up. The “Fredeu spring” in the Bihor table (758 m, near Ordâncușa) is a different place with a similar name; we do not link it to Beiuș.

Every row

All printed tracer results

Table 1 is Orășeanu & Iurkiewicz (eds.) 2010, table 3.3 (Bihor–Vlădeasa). Its row numbers are the printed drainage numbers; the source prints “52” twice, so the first is shown as 52a. Table 2 is Orășeanu 2016, table 4.4 (Codru-Moma). Table 3 is the same book, table 4.9 (Platoul Vașcău, printed p. 161). Their row numbers are the printed ones. A dot marks the 51 dye traces in the race; grey rows are the rest. “T” is the first arrival; a dash means the book prints none. English labels of table 1 are as printed in English; the Romanian page translates them. Names in table 2 are as printed in Romanian. In table 1, “Fântâna Roșie” (row 41), printed without diacritics, is normalised. A printed speed is flagged when it differs from distance ÷ time by more than 3%, a printed drop when it differs from the printed elevations by more than 5 m.

Table·rowSinkmSpringmL (m)TracerT (h)V (m/h)PouredPrinted numbers that disagree
1·1Ponor of Groapa Budeștilor875Cerbasca spring570750In-EDTA1923.906.10.1985
1·2Course of Fagului cave865Giulești spring5051,900rhodamine B8522.307.10.1984
1·3Losses of Pietrele Roșii brook800Pișolca cave5001,600In-EDTA10016.023.09.1987
1·4Losses of Pietrele Roșii brook800Coliboaia spring5131,240In-EDTA10012.423.09.1987
1·5Losses of Pietrele Roșii brook800Blidaru spring4352,330In-EDTA10023.323.09.1987
1·6Losses of Pietrele Roșii brook800Hidrei spring3903,950In-EDTA10039.523.09.1987
1·7Losses of Secătura brook925Coliboaia spring5132,150rhodamine B––1984
1·8Losses of Secătura brook925Coliboaia spring5151,700rhodamine B16810.121.09.1984
1·9Losses of Secătura brook925Blidaru spring4353,070rhodamine B24012.821.09.1984
1·10Course of Muncelu cave1100Blidaru spring4353,880iodine-13114726.317.05.1985
1·11Losses of Preluca Neșului brook815Blidaru spring4352,770fluorescein9628.921.09.1984
1·12Losses of Sodolul Tomeștilor550Hidrei spring3901,350fluorescein7019.328.09.1984
1·13Losses of Crăciune brook880Hidrei spring3902,550In-EDTA3108.224.09.1989
1·14Losses of Hoanca Codreanu850Poarta Bihorului spring640600bromine-824812.517.05.1984
1·15Losses of Coșuri brook750Molibden mine––288–04.11.1983
1·16Elena ponor845Poarta Bihorului spring640850iodine-1319614.118.05.1984printed speed differs from distance ÷ time (8.9 m/h)
1·17Losses of Corlatu brook1040Izvorul Crișului spring7001,750In-EDTA2087.503.11.1983
1·18Losses of Valea Seacă brook1100Izvorul Crișului spring7003,600In-EDTA1,3402.707.08.1984
1·19Losses of Fleșcuța brook1150Izvorul Crișului spring7002,150fluorescein2887.523.11.1983
1·20Losses of Hoanca Moțului brook925Izvorul Crișului spring7001,300iodine-1313043.319.09.1985
1·21Losses of Hoanca Moțului brook925"Trei Izvoare" source775550iodine-1311055.019.09.1985
1·22Losses of Sebișelul Sec brook1345Valea Rea spring9201,130fluorescein2056.522.06.2004
1·23Losses of Țiganu brook820Păuleasa spring5702,000In-EDTA2483.321.05.1985
1·24Losses of Crișanu brook975Păuleasa spring5703,075printed “B” (bromine-82?)9532.427.05.1985
1·25Hoanca Urzicarului pothole1165Păuleasa spring5704,600In-EDTA30015.317.12.1984
1·26Losses of Luncșoara stream700Păuleasa spring5701,900Stralex2479.127.05.1985
1·27Vărășoaia ponor1290Boga spring6752,170printed “B” (bromine-82?)15144.613.06.1985
1·28Ponor of Cuților brook1260Boga spring6752,560Stralex20128.013.06.1985
1·29Ponor of Renghii brook1235Boga spring6752,500In-EDTA24104.114.06.1985
1·30Ponor of Arsurii brook1245Spring of Poiana Ponor11002,100rhodamine B15140.022.09.1985
1·31Ponor of Arsurii brook1245Galbenei spring8155,120rhodamine B30171.022.09.1985
1·32Ponor of Trânghești brook1270Spring of Poiana Ponor11002,000fluorescein6638.01958printed speed differs from distance ÷ time (30.3 m/h)
1·33Ponor of Poiana Ponor1060Galbenei spring8153,000fluorescein6645.01961
1·34Ponor of Trânghești brook1260Spring of Poiana Ponor11001,950Dy-EDTA12162.522.09.1985
1·35Ponor of Trânghești brook1260Galbenei spring8155,320Dy-EDTA24221.622.09.1985printed drop 145 m vs 445 m from the printed elevations
1·36Ghețarul de la Barsa cave1100Galbenei spring8152,775In-EDTA19014.610.07.1987
1·37Ștevia Lupii ponor1125Galbenei spring8151,925KI4048.106.09.1986
1·38Losses of Valea Seacă brook–Gemănata pothole–650rhodamine B4016.210.08.1986
1·39Losses of Valea Seacă brook–Cetățile Ponorului9502,950rhodamine B7042.110.08.1986
1·40Losses of Barsa Cohanului950Cetățile Ponorului950900fluorescein1464.310.08.1986printed drop 145 m vs 0 m from the printed elevations
1·41Course of Fântâna Roșie cave–Bulbuci spring––––12.1974
1·42Course of Coiba Mică cave960Tăuz spring8502,650rhodamine B3228.219.10.1985
1·43Course of Șesuri pothole1134Poliței spring920880fluorescein––1957
1·44Losses of Ocoale brook1160Cotețul Dobreștilor spring7702,800fluorescein3873.704.1964
1·45Losses of Ocoale brook1160Izbucul Morii7602,880fluorescein3875.004.1964printed drop 300 m vs 400 m from the printed elevations
1·46Vuiaga Veche ponor1145Poliței spring9201,360rhodamine B1013612.08.2001
1·47Losses of Troaca Hănășești1110Cotețul Dobreștilor7702,430fluorescein4257.929.10.2002
1·48Losses of Ordâncușa stream745Izvorul Mic spring7301,000In-EDTA3627.826.08.1985
1·49Losses of Ordâncușa stream at Moara lui Ivan960Cotețul Dobreștilor spring7702,900fluorescein9032.229.06.2003
1·50Losses of Ordâncușa stream at Moara lui Ivan960Morii spring760–fluorescein––29.06.2003
1·51Losses of Ordâncușa stream at Moara lui Ivan960Spring at Hoanca Morii761–fluorescein––29.06.2003
1·52aLosses of Ordâncușa stream at Moara lui Ivan960Fredeu spring758–fluorescein––29.06.2003
1·52Trei Cărări (Aprozar) ponor1300Iapa spring1230840fluorescein10.58023.03.2002
1·53Losses of Pleșii brook875Izvorul Mare spring7252,620rhodamine B6540.326.08.1985
1·54Losses of Ponorul brook1130Alunul Mic spring11001,400rhodamine B10813.027.10.1985
1·55Course of Diaclază cave1230Alunul Mic spring11001,200In-EDTA2305.227.10.1985
1·56Course of Lucii pothole1160Alunul Mic spring11001,100fluorescein4425.027.10.1985
1·57Ponor of Poiana Vârtopului1322Șurile din Firea springs10702,610In-EDTA12021.712.06.1988
1·58Ponorul cu Pod ponor1315Șurile din Firea springs10702,920rhodamine B9032.412.06.1988
1·59Course of Cuciulata cave1335Moloh spring1210700fluorescein352022.11.1994
1·60Course of Fisura Neagră cave1210Izbucul cu Cascadă spring1200450fluorescein1237.521.03.1995
1·61Pothole in Cuciulata1258Izbucul cu Cascadă spring1200580fluorescein2.25256.628.04.1995
1·62Brebu's ponor1200Păstrăvăriei spring11001,000fluorescein1190.924.09.1997
1·63Losses of Rampei brook1200Rampei spring1140370fluorescein137016.06.1999
1·64Avenul cu Spinare pothole1370Vârfurașul spring11751,900fluorescein15.5122.619.06.1997
1·65Tăul Rogojanului ponor1140Spring of Sărcerului brook10701,450fluorescein4362.519.06.1997
1·66Tăul Rogojanului ponor1140Spring of Preluca din Vale10402,180fluorescein10218.019.06.1997
1·67Ponor of Cetățuia brook1450Spring of Preluca din Vale10403,540rhodamine B< 300> 10.420.08.1997
1·68Ponor of Cetățuia brook1450Spring of Sărcerului brook10703,130rhodamine B< 300> 10.420.08.1997
1·69Tăul Negru ponor1330Vârfurașul spring11751,200fluorescein< 11> 10918.07.1998
1·70Tăul Rogojanului ponor1140Spring of Sărcerului brook10701,450fluorescein< 4> 36219.07.1998
1·71Tăul Rogojanului ponor1140Spring of Preluca din Vale10402,180fluorescein< 13> 16819.07.1998
1·72Dârnini cave–Mătișești spring––––1984
1·73Bălileasa1150Oșelu spring9101,250fluorescein––2005
1·74Miron pothole1275Ursului spring10951,850fluorescein––2007
1·75R2 pothole1220Boga spring6752,000fluorescein1513310.10.2009
2·1Ponorul Izoi680Izbucul Grota Ursului3202,110tritiated water6355.01970
2·2Ponorul Izoi680Izvorul hipotermal „a”2952,180tritiated water6363.01970
2·3Ponorul din Secăriște685Izbucul Grota Ursului3201,840tritiated water5368.01970
2·4Avenul Teia400Izvorul Piatra cu Lapte310650iodine-1312541.01972printed speed differs from distance ÷ time (26.0 m/h)
2·5Ponorul Tinoasa657Izvorul Răchitarul5251,075fluorescein4322.01973printed speed differs from distance ÷ time (25.0 m/h)
2·6Pierderea p. Hăiuga Veche669Izv. din p. Megheșul Sec4401,200iodine-13111,2001974
2·7Ponorul Tăul Bivolilor294Peștera cu Apă de la Moară250630fluorescein880.01974
2·8Ponorul Dosul Varului720Izbucul Feredeu4156,000iodine-13158103.01977
2·9Ponorul Dosul Varului720Izbucul Grota Ursului3205,800iodine-13148120.01977
2·10Ponorul Călcăturii630Izbucul Finișului4902,100fluorescein8725.01977printed speed differs from distance ÷ time (24.1 m/h)
2·11Ponorul Călcăturii630Izbucul Feredeu4154,250fluorescein15028.01977
2·12Ponorul Dosul Varului720Izbucul Finișului4902,100In-EDTA16812.51986
2·13Ponorul Dosul Varului720Izbucul Feredeu4156,000In-EDTA9662.51986
2·14Ponorul Dosul Varului720Izv. termal nr. 1, Moneasa2945,900In-EDTA6009.81986
2·15Ponorul Dosul Varului720Izv. termal nr. 4, Moneasa2976,250In-EDTA48013.01986
2·16Ponorul Dosul Varului720Izv. termal nr. 2, Moneasa3036,150In-EDTA46013.41986printed drop 427 m vs 417 m from the printed elevations
2·17Pierderea Pârâului dintre Pietre560Izvorul Piatra cu Lapte3102,680rhodamine B7038.31987printed drop 350 m vs 250 m from the printed elevations
2·18Pierderea p. Scărița540Izvorul Piatra cu Lapte3101,700fluorescein4835.41987
2·19Pierderea p. Blidărița630Izvorul Piatra cu Lapte3103,100In-EDTA7243.01987
2·20Prd. p. Ursului, av. p. Grohot540Izbucul Finișului490800fluorescein6013.52004
2·21Prd. p. Ursului, av. p. Grohot540Izbucul Feredeu4152,900fluorescein14427.62004printed speed differs from distance ÷ time (20.1 m/h); printed drop 105 m vs 125 m from the printed elevations
2·22Pierderea din p. Sterp540Izvorul Vidrei470800rhodamine B86102004printed speed differs from distance ÷ time (9.3 m/h)
2·23Pierderea p. Osoaie420Izvorul Morii de la Borz2112,950rhodamine B6545.42004
2·24Pierderea p. Valea Seacă452Izvorul Morii de la Borz2114,300fluorescein8053.72004
2·25Ponorul Văii Seci450Izbucul Feredeu415770fluorescein3025.72005
2·26Ponorul din p. Șușii580Izvorul Vidrei4701,000fluorescein3528.62006
3·1Peștera Câmpeneasca406Izbucul Boiu3001,700charcoal powder3-4500.014.08.1901
3·2Prd. p. Fântâna Lotrilor613Izbucul Boiu3007,600iodine-13121626.028.07.1978printed speed differs from distance ÷ time (35.2 m/h); printed drop 331 m vs 313 m from the printed elevations
3·3Prd. p. Ponoare579Izbucul Boiu3005,900bromine-8222526.228.07.1978
3·4Prd. p. Hăiuga lui Șandor675Izbucul Tisei4502,150iodine-13115014.329.07.1978
3·5Peștera Câmpeneasca406Izbucul Boiu3001,700rhodamine B10170.030.07.1978
3·6Ponorul p. Ponorul499Izb. Pepineaua4001,250rhodamine B2062.522.08.1978
3·7Ponorul din Arânda720Izbucul Tisei4503,200In-EDTA19216.615.10.1984
3·8Ponorul p. Dănești601Izbucul Tisei4501,500Stralex15100.026.05.1985
3·9Prd. p. Cohuri635Izbucul Tisei4502,000rhodamine B15133.326.05.1985
3·10Ponorul Peșterelii––5,940iodine-131124951985
3·11Ponorul Tăul Ponorului633Izb. Șopoteasa3554,280In-EDTA14429.704.07.1986printed drop 272 m vs 278 m from the printed elevations
3·12Prd. p. Târsa520Izv. Peștera Popii4001,200KI6020.004.07.1986
3·13Prd. Coșul de la Căldare440Izb. Căsoaia3751,040fluorescein1761.125.07.1986
3·14Ponorul Sfăraș667Izbucul Boiu3008,150In-EDTA1,6325.01987
3·14bPonorul Sfăraș667Izv. cald Sfărășele2958,100In-EDTA1,7044.71987
3·15Ponorul p. Priga640Izbucul Boiu3007,960KI9682.91987
3·15bPonorul p. Priga640Izv. cald Sfărășele2958,600KI16850.61987
3·16Ponorul Doboș565Izbucul Colești4001,200Dy-EDTA––1988
3·16bPonorul Doboș565Izv. de la Coșul de la Chietroc3901,500Dy-EDTA––1988
3·17Ponorul p. Scărița610Izb. din Valea Seacă565650fluorescein––25.07.1994
3·18Pierderea p. Căptălanu–Izb. din Valea Seacă565650In-EDTA513025.07.1994

How it was made

Method, limits and sources

Sources