PREREG · raurile-care-dispar (14 Nov 2026, rules 1-3 written after reading table 3.3 (see timing note), rule 4 before any coordinate lookup)

Gate (brief 19)

At least 5 published dye traces, each with input point, output point and travel time.

Rules fixed in advance

Source opened

Orășeanu, I. & Iurkiewicz, A. (eds.) 2010. Karst Hydrogeology of Romania. Belvedere, Oradea. Ch. 3.13.3 "Bihor Vlădeasa Mountains", pp. 217–243, Table 3.3 (pp. 226–228). Open PDF: https://www.ahgr.ro/media/236594/3.13.3.-bihor-vl%C4%83deasa-mountains.pdf (sha256 5ed2652d…767b, saved in data/raw/). Text: "59 tracer tests … 75 underground flow paths", mean L 2,098 m, mean V 65.5 m/h (first arrival).

Found by Codex (read-only), then opened and read by me; every row of the table transcribed to data/table33.tsv.

Timing note

Rules 1–3 were written after I had read the first table, not before; they are the rules I would have written (dye only, exact time, source opened). Rule 4 (coordinates) was written before any coordinate was looked up and is a genuine pre-registration. A second source, found later the same day while checking a water-supply lead, was added under the same rules; it was not part of the original gate.

Source 2 (found later, same rules)

Orășeanu, I. 2016. Hidrogeologia carstului din Munții Apuseni. Belvedere, Oradea, 300 pp. Chapter 4 "Munții Codru-Moma", table 4.4 (printed p. 143), 26 flow paths from 18 tests. Open PDF extract: https://www.ahgr.ro/media/146825/4.-codru-moma.pdf (sha256 af6e5e62…c005, saved in data/raw/). Read from the page image.

Source 3 (found by an outside reviewer, same chapter, same rules)

Orășeanu 2016, table 4.9 "Platoul Vașcău", printed p. 161 (page image in docs/table49-p161.png): 21 rows. 4 meet rules 1–3: rows 5, 6, 9 (rhodamine B) and 13 (fluorescein). Row 17 is fluorescein without a time; row 1 (1901) is charcoal powder with "3–4 h". Added after the first two reviews; the first count (46) had missed it.

Result of rules 1–3 (14 Nov 2026) = PASS

Source 1 (Bihor–Vlădeasa, 76 rows printed as 75 flow paths; the printed numbering repeats "52"): fluorescein or rhodamine rows with an exact first-arrival time: 34 (33 at first count; row 38, whose distance I had mis-read as an elevation, was corrected after an outside review).

Source 2 (Codru-Moma, 26 rows): 13.

Source 3 (Vașcău, 21 rows): 4. Total 51 dye traces (33 fluorescein, 18 rhodamine B). Counts at earlier stages: 46, then 47 (row 38 corrected), then 51. Gate of 5: met by far.

Printed figures that disagree with themselves are kept as printed and flagged on the page, never corrected: source 1 rows 16 and 32 (speed vs distance/time), 35, 40, 45 (printed drop vs elevations); source 2 rows B4, B5, B10, B21, B22 (speed vs distance/time), B16, B17, B21 (drop); source 3 row C2 (speed and drop) and C11 (drop). The apparent speed drawn on the page is always our own distance ÷ time.

Not opened: the original papers behind both tables (Orășeanu et al. 1991, Theor. Appl. Karstol. 4; Orășeanu 1996, TAK 9; Viehmann et al. 1964; Rusu et al. 1964). Dates and authors are those printed in the tables. Both tables give only first arrival, not the shape of the breakthrough curve or the flow conditions on the day.

Result of rule 4 (14 Nov 2026) = PARTLY MET, plan written before the matches

Plan written after the first OSM name listing but before any distance was computed: if fewer than 8 traces can be drawn as lines, the map shows only the verified lines, springs with an open coordinate get a ring of the printed distance (direction unknown, labelled so), and the full set lives in the timed race.

Matches (exact name in OSM, element ids listed below): both ends found and within 25% of the printed L for 3 traces only: R2 → Boga (1,764 m vs 2,000 m printed, −11.8%), Coiba Mică → Tăuz (+5.4%), Barsa Cohanului → Cetățile Ponorului (−6.0%). All other inputs ("losses of … brook") have no open coordinate; Galbena, Giulești, Blidaru, Hidrei and most other springs also have none. Rings are drawn for 7 springs with a point: 5 from OpenStreetMap and 2 (Alunul Mic, Poliței) from the CC BY paper Cîmpean et al. 2022, table 1, which is outside the sources listed in rule 4 (a deviation, disclosed on the page).

Elevation check on the Copernicus model: R2 1,235 m vs 1,220 printed; Boga 693 m vs 675. Coiba Mică (1,059 m model vs 960 printed, a cave stream below the surface) and Tăuz (916 vs 850) do not agree; OSM points are the mappers' points.

Located points (rule 4)

← back