Why one open window makes no draught
Air comes into a room only if it has a way out. With a single window open, the wind presses equally on all the air in the flat and has nowhere to push it: in the model, the speed stays close to zero in every room.
Real life is not quite that calm. Gusts and the temperature difference between inside and out still swap some air through a single window, but far more slowly than when a window on the other side of the block is open too. The model leaves them out.
When the draught starts: two windows on opposite sides
The wind presses on the side of the block it blows against and pulls on the opposite side. A forecast wind of 6 m/s (measured at 10 metres, in open country) is about 4.0 m/s at a 4th-floor flat in town. Among lower blocks, the pressure difference between the two facades comes to 6.9 pascals: tens of thousands of times less than the pressure in a car tyre.
It is still enough to push 1.7 cubic metres of air a second through the kitchen window, both casements open, at 1.0 m/s. The kitchen replaces all its air in 12 seconds, the bedroom in 23.
The air does not spread through the flat. It takes the shortest path: from the kitchen window through the door, along the hall, through the bedroom door to the window on the far side. On that path the speed is 0.51 m/s at the kitchen table and 0.92 m/s in the middle of the hall; in the bedroom doorway it reaches 1.7 m/s. The living room and the small bedroom, off the path, barely notice.
Who sleeps on the side nearer the door
In the same scene, the jet that comes through the bedroom door runs to the window past the bed, not over it. On the pillow nearer the door the speed is 0.10 m/s, on the one nearer the wall 0.07 m/s: 9% and 4% of people would complain, which is almost nobody.
With the bed a metre closer to the door, between the door and the window, the head would lie right in the jet. Move the target on the plan to see where the air is strongest.
Why the door slams
When the bedroom door shuts, the air’s path breaks and the whole pressure difference sits on the door: 7.9 pascals. On a 0.8 by 2 metre door that is a push of 13 newtons, the weight of 1.3 kilograms.
A door left ajar lets the air through the gap, and the same pressure difference swings it shut hard. The arrows on the plan show which way the air pushes on each closed door.
The tilted window: fresh air without the draught
Tilted, a window leaves a slit of a few hundred square centimetres instead of more than a square metre. With the same doors open and the same wind, the kitchen replaces its air in 3.8 minutes instead of 12 seconds, and the bedroom in 7.2 minutes.
At the kitchen table the speed falls to 0.09 m/s and 7% of people would complain of a draught. The air is still replaced, only more slowly.
The front door, open
The stairwell has windows of its own, open or broken, and its pressure sits somewhere between the two facades. The model puts it halfway.
With one window open, in the small bedroom, and the front door open, the air again has two ends: it runs through the room and along the hall, where it reaches 0.79 m/s. The small bedroom replaces its air in 18 seconds.
How much air is too much? The formula in the standard
The draught has a definition. The international thermal comfort standard, ISO 7730, works out how many people in a hundred would complain of a draught at the neck from three numbers: the air temperature, its speed and how much it fluctuates. The formula comes from experiments by P. O. Fanger and colleagues at the Technical University of Denmark, published in 1986 and 1988; the 1994 edition of the standard counts 150 subjects in all.
DR = (34 − t) · (v − 0.05)0.62 · (0.37 · v · Tu + 3.14)
Here t is the air temperature in degrees, v the speed in m/s, and Tu how much the speed fluctuates, in per cent; when it is not measured, the standard allows 40%. At 21 °C, air at 0.2 m/s, which you barely feel on your hand, already means 24% dissatisfied. The European standard EN 16798-1 accepts at most 10% where expectations are high, 20% for a normal level and 30% for a moderate one.
The standard applies the formula to people sitting down, feeling neither warm nor cold, at 20 to 26 °C and speeds under 0.5 m/s. At the arms and feet, the standard itself says, it may overestimate.
Does a draught make you ill?
Colds are caused by viruses, not by air. Two studies show why the idea is not absurd, though.
In 2005, at Cardiff University, Claire Johnson and Ronald Eccles split 180 volunteers into two groups: 90 had their feet chilled, the other 90 went through a control procedure. Over the next four to five days, 13 in the first group reported cold symptoms, against 5 in the second. The symptoms were self-reported; the authors say the link to an actual infection still needs study.
In 2015, at Yale University, Ellen Foxman and colleagues showed on mouse airway cells that rhinovirus, the most common cause of colds, multiplies better at 33 °C, the temperature inside the nose, than at 37 °C, because the cells defend themselves less well in the cold. The authors write that it is not yet known whether the same happens in human cells.
What can be said for certain is that moving air cools the head faster. Thermal-manikin measurements by Richard de Dear and colleagues (1997) give the seated head a convective cooling coefficient 3.2 times higher at 1 m/s than at 0.2 m/s.
Not only Romanians fear the draught
German-speaking Swiss call it Durchzug; the public broadcaster SRF took apart the idea that it makes you ill in 2014. Italians fear the colpo d’aria, the “blow of air”, and Russians the skvoznyak. In South Korea, many older people believe it is dangerous to fall asleep with an electric fan running in the room.
How it is calculated
The plan is schematic: a three-room “decomandat” flat (every room opens off the hall), typical of 1970s Romanian blocks, not a specific design. The air is worked out in two steps.
The first is a network of openings. Each room has a pressure; each window and door is an orifice with flow Q = Cd·A·√(2Δp/ρ), Cd = 0.6. Wind pressure on the two facades comes from the coefficients published by the AIVC (Orme, Liddament and Wilson, 1994) for a building twice as long as it is wide, at three levels of shelter. The forecast wind is brought to the height of a 4th floor in town with the power law from the same tables. This gives the flows, the air-change times and the pressure on closed doors.
The second shows where the air goes inside: a two-dimensional Lattice-Boltzmann model of the plan, with 7.5 cm cells (10 cm on phones). Its speeds are scaled so that the flow through the main window matches the network, then divided by the open height of each opening. The value shown is the speed averaged over the room height.
The flow model reproduces the theoretical profile between two parallel walls (Poiseuille flow) within 0.12% and the theoretical speed within 0.3%; the network gives the hand-calculated flow for four openings in series within 0.01%.
- In plan, each door is a slot the full height of the room. In the core of the jet, at window height, the air can be faster than the average shown.
- Air temperature, gusts and the stack effect (warm air rising) are not in the model. In winter the incoming air is colder still, so the standard’s formula underestimates.
- The pressure coefficients were measured on low-rise buildings and refer to the wind at building height; the model uses the wind at a 4th floor (13.5 m), close to the roof of a five-storey block but low for a ten-storey one, where the real values also change from floor to floor.
- The opening of a tilted window (0.06 m² for a 1.2 m casement), of a door left ajar (a quarter) and the leaks around closed doors and windows are estimates.