mariuscomper.ukRomână

They set off for the North Pole by balloon in 1897. Their film was developed in 1930

On 11 July 1897 three Swedes rose from Svalbard in a hydrogen balloon. After 65 hours they came down on the ice, 786 kilometres from the Pole, and walked for almost two months while the ice carried them south-east. They probably died in October, on a deserted island. Nobody knew where until the summer of 1930, when Norwegian sealers found their camp, their diaries and their film.

65 h 33 minin the air, from lift-off to the landing on the ice
786 kmto the Pole from where they landed
33 yearsbefore their camp was found
The half-deflated balloon lies on its side on the ice; beside the basket, two small figures. Everything is white and grey.
The balloon Örnen (the Eagle) on the ice after the landing of 14 July 1897. Photograph by Nils Strindberg, developed in 1930.Nils Strindberg, 1897 · public domain
  • the flight
  • the route on the ice
  • the course they set, as if the ice had not moved

Stockholm, 13 February 1895

An engineer plans to fly a balloon over the Pole

Salomon August Andrée was 40 and chief engineer at the Patent Office in Stockholm. On 13 February 1895 he put his plan to the Royal Academy of Sciences: a large balloon, filled with hydrogen in the Arctic itself, would leave northern Svalbard on a day of southerly wind and cross the Pole. At 16.5 miles an hour, he reckoned, the journey to the Pole would take about 43 hours.

So that it would not simply go where the wind went, the balloon trailed three long ropes that dragged on the ice or the water. The friction slowed it down, and a sail could turn it a little off the wind. Andrée reported that in a trial in 1894, with the balloon Svea, he had managed about 27 degrees.

The money came in four months. Alfred Nobel walked into Andrée's office and made the first gift; then he offered to pay half the cost if the rest was raised within two months. King Oscar II, Baron Oscar Dickson and, last, Professor Gustaf Retzius and his wife made up the rest. In London that July two well-known polar explorers, Admiral Markham and General Greely, spoke against the plan.

3,000 kgwhat the balloon had to lift: three men, instruments, food for four months and ballast

How long did Andrée require the balloon to be able to stay up?

Danskøya, Svalbard, June–August 1896

1896: the wind does not come, and the seams let the gas out

In June 1896 the ship Virgo carried the expedition to Danskøya, Danes Island, in the north-west corner of Svalbard. There they put up an eight-sided wooden balloon house four storeys high and made the hydrogen on the spot, pouring sulphuric acid over iron shavings. The balloon, sewn in Paris by Henri Lachambre from varnished Chinese silk, was more than 20 metres across. By 27 July it was full.

Then they waited for a southerly wind. It did not come. The ship's insurance did not allow a stay beyond 20 August, so on 17 August they let out the gas and went home. The 1930 book gives a short explanation: Andrée was ready too late, not before about 1 August.

That summer they learned something worse. The silk held the gas but the seams did not: "when these leaks were closed, new ones were formed". The expedition's meteorologist, Nils Ekholm, resigned after the return. The book says he withdrew "for the reasons already mentioned", and the only reasons mentioned before are the leaks and a balloon "not quite satisfactory". His place went to Knut Frænkel, an engineer and athlete.

21 daysof waiting for a good wind with the balloon full, in 1896

In 1897, after repairs, how much gas did the balloon lose in its house, compared with what Andrée's plan allowed?

The balloon house on Danskøya, with scaffolding still around it. A coloured photochrom of the time; whether it shows 1896 or 1897 is not certain.
The balloon house on Danskøya, with scaffolding still around it. A coloured photochrom of the time; whether it shows 1896 or 1897 is not certain.Detroit Publishing Co., photochrom · public domain

Danskøya, 11 July 1897

11 July 1897: they go, although Andrée hesitates

For the second attempt the expedition left Gothenburg on 18 May 1897 aboard the gunboat Svensksund. Over the winter the balloon had been enlarged with two bands of silk to about 4,800 cubic metres. On 11 July at three in the morning the water in the harbour, smooth until then, began to ruffle under a wind from the south-south-west.

735 kglost in the first minutes: 206 kg of sand thrown out and 529 kg of rope left on the shore

You are Andrée on the morning of 11 July. Do you go or wait?

  • The wind: from the south-south-west, which is to say towards the north and the Pole.
  • Its speed: 15 to 30 feet a second at the surface (5 to 9 m/s), in squalls; much stronger at 1,000 to 1,500 feet.
  • In the harbour: two Norwegian sealers have just come in to shelter from a storm that, they say, will last some days.
  • Last year: you waited in vain until 17 August.

They climbed into the basket at 1.43 p.m. Greenwich time; three minutes later the balloon rose and was named Örnen, the Eagle. Weighed down by its ropes it stayed under a hundred metres. A down-draught pushed it towards the sea, and the basket touched the water. They threw out eight bags of sand. On the shore a sailor shouted: "Look! the drag-lines are lying here on the shore!"

Each rope had a screw joint so that it could be released if it caught. Laid out on the shore, the ropes had kinked; as the balloon rose the kinks twisted and the joints unscrewed: two-thirds of every rope was left behind. Machuron thought they had caught on rocks. Andrée had once written that the joints were unnecessary and had accepted them only on others' advice. Without them the system Andrée meant to steer with was gone. The balloon now flew freely with the wind, and it soon climbed to nearly 600 metres, losing gas.

Örnen over Virgo harbour on 11 July 1897, minutes after lift-off.
Örnen over Virgo harbour on 11 July 1897, minutes after lift-off.G. V. E. Svedenborg, 1897; Grenna Museum · CC BY-SA 4.0

11–14 July 1897, over the ice

Sixty-five hours, ten and a half of them in free flight

The first ten hours went well. The balloon flew north-east, for a while above the clouds. At 10.55 p.m. they dropped a cork buoy with a note: "in about 82° latitude and 25° long. E. ... All well." Carried by the sea, two of the buoys with notes were found on the coasts of Iceland and Norway, in 1899 and 1900.

After midnight the balloon passed into the shadow of a cloud, cooled and sank. From 12.15 a.m. on 12 July what was left of the ropes touched the ice. The fog settled on the silk and froze; the basket struck the ice again and again. That evening a rope caught under a block of ice and held them for thirteen hours. The wind took them first west, then back east.

65 h 33 minin the air; free flight only 10 h 29 min, the rest dragging over the ice, with about 14 hours standing still

They carried dozens of carrier pigeons. How many pigeon messages reached anyone?

July 13 12.30 midday. Lat. 82° 2′ Long. 15° 5′ E. good speed to E. 10° S. All well on board. This is the third pigeon-post. Andrée.

The note found in the tube on the pigeon's tail, 15 July 1897

It was the latest news of them until 1930; the buoys, dropped earlier, reached people only in 1899 and 1900. On 14 July at 7.19 in the morning the three men jumped from the basket onto the ice. The 1930 technical analysis says the balloon could no longer float because it had been covered in ice in the damp, cold air; the loss of gas mattered less.

82° 56′ N, 29° 52′ E, 14–22 July 1897

On the ice, 786 kilometres from the Pole

They landed with food for several months, three sledges, a canvas boat that fitted over a wooden frame, guns, and Strindberg's camera. The nearest land was about 180 miles (290 km) away. For a week they stayed by the balloon: they loaded the sledges, shot a bear, and Strindberg took photographs.

Of the food depots laid in advance, two were within reach. The larger was at Cape Flora on Franz Josef Land, the archipelago where Fridtjof Nansen had wintered, so a winter there was known to be survivable. The smaller was on Sjuøyane, the Seven Islands, north of Svalbard.

8 daysbetween the landing and setting off, on 22 July

Which way would you set off?

Örnen on the ice, 14 July 1897. The balloon is deflating; the basket lies on its side.
Örnen on the ice, 14 July 1897. The balloon is deflating; the basket lies on its side.Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0

22 July – 13 September 1897

They walked south-west. The ice took them south-east

The sledges were heavy and the ice was full of ridges of piled-up ice and channels of open water, which they crossed in the boat. On 1 August Andrée reckoned the day's march at no less than 7 kilometres. The oceanographer Harald Sverdrup, who read the diaries in 1930, concluded that a day's march of 3.5 to 4.2 miles "was something very rare".

These values show that we have driven westwards quicker than we have walked eastwards.

Andrée, diary, 31 July 1897

130 kmsouth-south-east: how far they moved in 36 days of walking south-west

From 4 August to 9 September they walked south-west, towards the Seven Islands. Which way did they actually move, on ice that was itself moving?

On 10 August they crossed below 82° and held a feast. On 12 and 13 September a strong north-westerly wind kept them in place. Then they decided to winter on the ice: the current and the wind, Andrée wrote, were carrying them "irresistibly" towards the strait between Svalbard and Franz Josef Land.

Frænkel, Strindberg and Andrée push the sledge and boat over a pressure ridge. The camera seems to have been set off by a self-timer.
Frænkel, Strindberg and Andrée push the sledge and boat over a pressure ridge. The camera seems to have been set off by a self-timer.Nils Strindberg's camera, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0

Kvitøya, 17 September – October 1897

White Island, and a note written in advance

On 17 September they saw land for the first time since the start: Kvitøya, White Island, which seemed to them "one single block of ice", at the eastern end of Svalbard. Since 12 September the ice had carried them at least 45 miles to the south-south-east.

On their floe they built a hut of ice blocks and moved into it on 28 or 29 September (the diaries give different dates). On 2 October at half past five in the morning the floe split right beside the hut. That is where Andrée's large diary ends:

No one had lost courage; with such comrades one should be able to manage under, I may say, any circumstances.

Andrée, diary, written after 2 October 1897

On 5 October they moved onto the island. Strindberg wrote in his almanac: "Moved to land." On the 6th: "Snow-storm reconnoitring." On the 7th: "Moving." Andrée wrote a few more lines, hard to read, in the first days of October. Strindberg died first, and the other two buried him. The day of death is not known for any of them.

Strindberg's almanac has one more entry, for 17 October: "Home 7.05 a.m."

24 macross: the floe left to them after 2 October

What do you think "Home 7.05 a.m.", on 17 October, means?

Kvitøya, 6 August 1930

1930: a summer when the ice drew back

Kvitøya is usually locked in by ice, one of the hardest places in Svalbard to reach. In the summer of 1930 the sea around it was almost clear. The Norwegian ship Bratvaag, carrying a scientific expedition to Franz Josef Land and sealing on the way, put in at the island on 5 August. It was not looking for anyone.

The next day two sealers, Olav Salen, aged 17, and Karl Tusvik, 24, found an aluminium lid and then the canvas boat, half buried in snow. The first notebook taken from the camp had a title on its first page: "The Sledge Journey, 1897". In September a second ship, the Isbjørn, found the rest: more snow had melted, and among the objects were Strindberg's almanac, Frænkel's notebooks and metal tins of film.

On 5 October 1930, thirty-three years to the day after they had moved onto Kvitøya, the gunboat Svensksund, the ship that had carried them north, brought them home to Stockholm.

33 yearsbetween exposure and development

The film spent 33 years on the island, in metal tins partly filled with water. How many frames could be developed?

Strindberg's camera, photographed after 1930. It was built in Stockholm for the expedition, with a compass in its body.
Strindberg's camera, photographed after 1930. It was built in Stockholm for the expedition, with a compass in its body.John Hertzberg; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0

Nils Strindberg's film, July 1897, developed in 1930

The photographs, in the order they were taken

Strindberg took onto the ice a camera built for the expedition in Stockholm, with Kodak film on rolls of 48 frames. Below are ten of the photographs Hertzberg developed in 1930, from the landing to the sledge journey. Dates follow the museum's captions where they give one; the others are inferred from the diaries.

  1. The balloon soon after landing, with two of the men by the basket.
    14 July. The balloon soon after landing, with two of the men by the basket.Nils Strindberg, 1897 · public domain
  2. The basket and the fallen balloon, also on 14 July.
    14 July. The basket and the fallen balloon, also on 14 July.Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  3. The camp at the landing place: the basket on the left, the tent on the right, the boat between.
    14–22 July. The camp at the landing place: the basket on the left, the tent on the right, the boat between.Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  4. Fitting the boat's wooden frame.
    15–19 July. Fitting the boat's wooden frame.Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  5. Andrée, up on the basket, searches the horizon for land. Frænkel is in the middle of the picture.
    19 July. Andrée, up on the basket, searches the horizon for land. Frænkel is in the middle of the picture.Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  6. Andrée beside a polar bear they had shot. Bear meat went into their daily rations.
    probably 19 July. Andrée beside a polar bear they had shot. Bear meat went into their daily rations.Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  7. Two of the men with another bear. The museum names them as Frænkel and Strindberg; the 1930 book as Andrée and Frænkel.
    July. Two of the men with another bear. The museum names them as Frænkel and Strindberg; the 1930 book as Andrée and Frænkel.the Andrée expedition, 1897 · public domain
  8. All three push the sledge over a pressure ridge; the camera seems to have had a self-timer.
    after 22 July. All three push the sledge over a pressure ridge; the camera seems to have had a self-timer.Nils Strindberg's camera, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  9. Frænkel's sledge, with the boat on it, hauled between blocks of ice.
    after 22 July. Frænkel's sledge, with the boat on it, hauled between blocks of ice.Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  10. Strindberg hauls a loaded sledge; the only picture with snowshoes in use.
    after 22 July. Strindberg hauls a loaded sledge; the only picture with snowshoes in use.S. A. Andrée, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0

Kvitøya, October 1897

Why did they die? Nobody knows

What is certain: they moved onto the island on 5 October, the certain entries stop in the first days of October, and Strindberg died first and was buried by the other two. In the camp there was bear and seal meat, at least 135 ball cartridges and 120 shot cartridges, a hundred boxes of matches and a Primus stove that still held paraffin. The 1930 report judged their clothes and tent too poor for an Arctic winter; Bea Uusma thinks they had warm clothes.

In 1930 the bodies were examined at Tromsø, but no proper autopsy was done, and they were then cremated. They can no longer be studied; only objects and clothing kept in museums can be analysed. Below are the explanations put forward and what each one requires.

Before you read the hypotheses: what had they run out of when they died?

  • Cold and exhaustion

    The 1930 report; Per-Ola Granberg and the polar researcher Rolf Kjellström, Läkartidningen, 2001

    What it rests on
    Three months of hauling, one sleeping bag for three; cold makes the body lose water, and water meant melting snow.
    What it requires
    That they reached the island severely weakened and died within days.
    What weakens it
    Personne (2000) judged it unlikely: they had plenty of food and fuel, and the first entries on the island record men still moving camp and exploring.
  • Trichinosis, from bear meat

    The Danish physician Ernst Adam Tryde, De döda på Vitön, 1952

    What it rests on
    Tryde reported Trichinella larvae in pieces of dried meat from the bear found at the camp. The diarrhoea and pains in the diaries partly fit.
    What it requires
    An infection severe enough to kill all three, days apart.
    What weakens it
    The disease rarely kills, and death usually comes weeks after infection. The diaries record no fever or swollen eyelids. Other explorers, Nansen among them, ate bear meat in the same region and survived.
  • Botulism

    The toxicologist Mark Personne, Läkartidningen, 2000

    What it rests on
    Seal meat carried for days and a stove that did not always work; type E toxin, common in the region, usually leaves no sign of spoilage. Personne also cites the remains of a seal shot on 19 September, found at the camp, and Frænkel's sunglasses: light hurts early in the illness.
    What it requires
    Contaminated food, and three deaths close together but not at the same moment.
    What weakens it
    It cannot be tested, and part of the argument rests on absences: entries that stop, a hurried burial. Granberg and Kjellström called it "unusually far-fetched".
  • A polar bear

    The physician and author Bea Uusma, Expeditionen, 2013, and Vitön, 2025

    What it rests on
    Tears in Strindberg's clothes, found in museum storage; stains on Frænkel's jacket, tested at a laboratory in Rotterdam; a rifle beside Andrée that, she concludes, was unloaded.
    What it requires
    For Strindberg, that the tears were made by a bear. For Frænkel, that the stains are his blood, from 1897. For Andrée, Uusma tentatively suggests suicide with morphine.
    What weakens it
    In 2019 the test could not confirm blood in the degraded material. The newer results are set out in her 2025 book and in interviews; a scientific article was announced in 2019.
  • Carbon monoxide, from the stove

    The explorer Vilhjalmur Stefansson, 1939, printing letters from the oceanographer Harald Sverdrup (idea from 1930) and the physiologist Yandell Henderson (1938); taken up in Läkartidningen, 1983

    What it rests on
    Similar incidents with Primus stoves on other polar expeditions; a small tent. Sverdrup read the air valve found closed, and the paraffin left, as a sign the stove was burning when they died.
    What it requires
    The stove burning in a closed tent. It concerns only Andrée and Frænkel; Strindberg had died before.
    What weakens it
    Personne (2000) and Granberg and Kjellström (2001) read the same closed valve as a sign the stove was not burning when they died. A worn tent would have let air in.
  • Scurvy, vitamin A or lead poisoning, suicide

    Weighed by Mark Personne, 2000, as ruled out or unlikely

    What it rests on
    A diet low in vitamin C; bear liver; tins sealed with lead, and tests in 1997–98 on preserved samples showed excess lead; opium and morphine in the medicine chest.
    What it requires
    Months without vitamin C; bear liver eaten; a large dose of lead within days; a shared decision.
    What weakens it
    Personne: three months is too short for fatal scurvy. The diaries show they did not eat the bear liver. The highest lead reading dates from before the expedition, and lead acts slowly. Opium and morphine appear in the diaries as medicine, for diarrhoea and pain, and there is no farewell letter.

What the evidence supports. Trichinosis is the best-known hypothesis. Larvae found in the bear meat show where an infection could have come from, but not that the men were infected or that it killed them; a 2022 scientific review calls it unproven. Scurvy and vitamin A are treated as ruled out and lead as unlikely; Personne judged a shared suicide unlikely, while Uusma raises suicide for Andrée alone. The explanations most discussed today are cold and exhaustion, botulism and, for Strindberg at least, a bear.

The three men may have died of different causes; several authors examine each death separately. The Grenna Museum, which keeps their belongings, puts it plainly: "The cause of death still eludes us."

The story in numbers

Time in the air, lift-off to landing65 hours 33 minutes
Of which free flight, with no rope on the ice10 hours 29 minutes
Straight-line distance, Danskøya to the landing place473 kilometres (the 1930 report: about 300 miles, 483 km)
Distance from the landing place to the Pole786 kilometres
Lost in the first minutes735 kg: 206 kg of sand and 529 kg of rope
Pigeon messages recoveredone; at least ten pigeons were released
Days on the ice, landing to Kvitøya83
How far they moved, 4 August – 9 September, while walking south-west130 km south-south-east (81 miles)
Ages at lift-offAndrée 42, Frænkel 27, Strindberg 24
Frames on the four exposed rolls, per Hertzberg192; some 50 with traces, 20 clear
Years until the camp was found33

Quiz: 33 years of stories

Eight claims that have circulated between 1897 and today. Choose, then see what the sources say.

  1. The balloon flew for 65 hours without touching the ice.

  2. Four pigeon messages made it home.

  3. It was known before lift-off that the balloon leaked.

  4. It is certain that all three were still alive on 17 October 1897.

  5. The camp was found by an expedition sent to look for them.

  6. The film was developed 33 years after it was exposed.

  7. When they died they had run out of food.

  8. It is now known for certain why they died.

What is not known

  • What each of them died of, and on what day. It is not even known whether they died of the same cause.
  • Whether they were alive on 17 October. It depends on how the entry "Home 7.05 a.m." is read: a return to camp, as the 1930 editors thought, or the time of a train, entered in advance, as Hans Ahlmann argued in 1938.
  • The exact route on the ice. The line on the map joins only the positions printed in full; after 4 September there are only a few latitudes (12 and 15 September), not drawn. The 1930 book notes a mean difference of half a degree in longitude between Strindberg's own map and the recalculated one, from an error in his lunar distances.
  • How many photographs there are. Hertzberg counted 192 frames, some 50 with traces and 20 that might be printed; another chapter of the same book speaks of 12 successfully developed; a present-day source of close to a hundred. The sources do not explain the difference.
  • Who is in the photograph with the second bear: the museum names Frænkel and Strindberg, the 1930 book Andrée and Frænkel.
  • Where each buoy was found. The 1930 book contradicts itself: one chapter puts buoy no. 4 in Norway and no. 7 in Iceland, another the other way round.
  • How many pigeons they took: 36, by the 1930 report, or 32, by the balloon makers.
  • Why Nils Ekholm withdrew. The 1930 book links his withdrawal to the leaks only by where it mentions it; the story that he discovered secret top-ups of gas appears only in secondary sources.

Sources

Nearly everything known about the flight and the walk on the ice comes from one book: the 1930 edition of the diaries of Andrée, Strindberg and Frænkel, with the Swedish scientists' analyses. Times are Greenwich time, as the editors converted them. Distances on the map are computed on a sphere from the printed positions; the miles in the English edition are statute miles.

Photographs

  • Nils Strindberg, 1897 · public domain
  • Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • the Andrée expedition, 1897 · public domain
  • Nils Strindberg's camera, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • Nils Strindberg, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • S. A. Andrée, 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • G. V. E. Svedenborg, 1897; Grenna Museum · CC BY-SA 4.0
  • Detroit Publishing Co., photochrom · public domain
  • Gösta Florman studio, Stockholm, 3 May 1897; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • John Hertzberg; Tekniska museet · CC BY 2.0
  • Sjöfartsmuseet Akvariet, Göteborg · CC BY 4.0