Flicker and motion are different
A screen’s refresh rate, its luminance flicker and a film’s frame rate describe different properties. A dog’s CFF value alone cannot establish whether every 60 Hz television produces smooth motion for it.
How quickly can a light flash before it looks steady? The threshold differs among animals and depends on light and measurement method. Critical flicker fusion frequency, or CFF, describes this limit. Vision is not a sequence of camera frames.
Change the frequency to compare the positions retained by the model. The animation runs ten times slower: one model second takes ten screen seconds. The dot stays lit. This is a sampling diagram, without vision calibration or reproduction of rapid flicker.
Choose a published value to change the mathematical sampling interval. CFF is an illustrative parameter here; the result does not reproduce a species’ visual experience.
The selected published value is ≥129 Hz. Conditions and methods differ among studies; this number does not establish how many images the animal sees each second.
Ten references come from Healy and colleagues’ table (2013); the falcon value comes from Potier and colleagues (2020). Light and methods differ. Comparing rows is not a controlled experiment between species.
| Species | Scientific name | Conditions | Published value | Period 1000/f | Ratio to 60 Hz |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peregrine falcon | Falco peregrinus | Behavioural test · behavioural test | ≥129 Hz | 7.75 ms | 2.15× |
| Rock pigeon | Columba livia | High light · ERG | 100 Hz | 10.00 ms | 1.67× |
| Domestic chicken | Gallus gallus domesticus | High light · behavioural test | 87 Hz | 11.49 ms | 1.45× |
| Dog | Canis lupus familiaris | High light · behavioural test | 80 Hz | 12.50 ms | 1.33× |
| Goldfish | Carassius auratus | High light · ERG | 67.2 Hz | 14.88 ms | 1.12× |
| Human | Homo sapiens | High light · behavioural test | 60 Hz | 16.67 ms | 1.00× |
| Cat | Felis catus | Low light · ERG | 55 Hz | 18.18 ms | 0.92× |
| Loggerhead turtle | Caretta caretta | High light · ERG | 40 Hz | 25.00 ms | 0.67× |
| Tiger salamander | Ambystoma tigrinum | Low light · ERG | 30 Hz | 33.33 ms | 0.50× |
| Leatherback turtle | Dermochelys coriacea | High light · ERG | 15 Hz | 66.67 ms | 0.25× |
| European eel | Anguilla anguilla | Low light · behavioural test | 14 Hz | 71.43 ms | 0.23× |
The limits of the comparison matter as much as the difference between the numbers.
A screen’s refresh rate, its luminance flicker and a film’s frame rate describe different properties. A dog’s CFF value alone cannot establish whether every 60 Hz television produces smooth motion for it.
In a chosen 4 m/s example, an object travels about 6.67 cm in 1/60 s and 3.10 cm in 1/129 s. These distances follow from speed × time. They do not imply that the object appears to move more slowly to an animal.
Lisney’s chicken study measured thresholds at different light intensities. That is why the table retains the compilation’s lighting conditions and 60 Hz remains only a calculation reference.
Flicker fusion is the frequency at which an alternating light can no longer be distinguished from steady light under the test conditions. The threshold depends on illumination, stimulus, method and individual. Electroretinography (ERG) measures the retina’s electrical response; behavioural tests measure stimulus discrimination.
The human 60 Hz reference comes from Healy’s compilation, rather than being a universal limit. The falcon study demonstrated at least 129 Hz; the animation uses 129 Hz as its selected value. Differences between these values do not measure how slowly the world appears to move.
The period 1000/f and ratio to 60 Hz are calculations about a periodic signal. They are not retinal frame durations, reaction times or perceived speeds. The model stops at that analogy; the screen and browser constrain its rendering.
Healy’s comparative analysis found associations between temporal resolution, body mass and metabolism while accounting for light and relatedness. This is not a strict rule for every animal pair. Niven and colleagues’ experiments in four fly species show that photoreceptor performance and information-transmission costs differ among species and with illumination.