Kiliia (Ukraine), Кілія
Preoteasa and colleagues (2023) argue for the medieval settlement at present-day Kiliia on the Ukrainian bank, using archaeological material and critical reading of texts and maps. This is not a measured fortress outline.
Change banks and compare the evidence for the port captured in January 1465. Names, finds and plans do not all locate the same thing.
Stephen the Great, ruler of medieval Moldavia, captured Chilia in January 1465. The port passed to Ottoman rule in 1484. Medieval Moldavia was a historical principality, distinct from today’s Republic of Moldova.
The port is under Stephen’s rule. Locating it means comparing two candidate zones, without drawing walls, quays or cargo that the sources do not document.
1470 is an editorial viewpoint date, within the period of Moldavian control.
Maxim (2002) describes an old fortress on the south bank, replaced by one on the north bank. The name Chilia Veche alone does not establish the site of the port captured in 1465.
Preoteasa and colleagues (2023) argue for the medieval settlement at present-day Kiliia on the Ukrainian bank, using archaeological material and critical reading of texts and maps. This is not a measured fortress outline.
Eșanu · 2013Mihai Maxim · 2002Preoteasa et al. · 2023


Chilia passed to Ottoman rule in 1484. The consulted sources support the year; the early location still requires attribution of each interpretation.
Maxim associates 1479 with repairs and the replacement of a southern fortress by a northern one. That reading does not establish a certain relocation here.
Preoteasa and colleagues’ north-bank argument concerns the medieval settlement. The change of control in 1484 does not turn that argument into a fortification plan.
Mihai Maxim · 2002Encyclopedia of UkrainePreoteasa et al. · 2023
Channel evolution and the disappearance of buildings have different evidence. A modern map alone cannot recover medieval banks.
Preoteasa and colleagues (2021) study northern Delta landscape change through dated sediment cores and historical and archaeological evidence. The research does not establish that erosion destroyed the fortress.
According to Sapozhnikov (2020), the old enclosure was replaced in 1795–1796 and the later fortress was destroyed in 1856. Primary demolition records remain to be verified.
Preoteasa et al. · 2021Ihor Sapozhnikov · 2020

The sheet from the Atlas of the Fortresses of the Russian Empire is catalogued to the 1830s. It depicts a later phase; it is not overlaid on the banks or used as an image of the fortress in 1484.
Chilia Veche remains the southern reference point of the comparison. This later plan does not demonstrate a medieval enclosure here.
Sapozhnikov compares north-bank fortress records and warns about incompatible scales. The exact date of the 1830s map sheet and the reference points for georeferencing have not been established.
The 1830s plan concerns the north bank; it is not overlaid on the map.

Chilia Veche is on the Romanian bank; Kiliia is on the Ukrainian bank. The two photographs show the modern towns.
Micu, Ailincăi and Stănică (2012) report medieval material south of Chilia Veche, between Săliște and Câșla-Chiliei, through archaeological inventory and surface research. Burial excavation at Ciorticut is a separate evidence category. This research does not demonstrate a fortress enclosure.
Preoteasa and colleagues (2023) favour Kiliia for the medieval settlement. Sapozhnikov recorded an absence of scientific fortress excavation in 2020; this does not establish the state of research today.
Micu, Ailincăi, Stănică · 2012Preoteasa et al. · 2023Ihor Sapozhnikov · 2020



The photographs show modern places; the camera position does not locate the fortress.
A name identifies a present-day town. Field research reports medieval material. Texts and plans support location interpretations for different periods. Together, they allow a comparison of the banks; the medieval fortress outline remains unproven.
We lack a verified medieval plan, a reliably established location of the former banks, and a current measured inventory of remains on both banks. Chilia and Licostomo are not treated here as automatically equivalent names in every period.
Each date has its own source; attributed dates stay attributed.
The interpretations have different foundations: the older two-fortress account and the 2023 interdisciplinary argument are compared with their limits visible.