Marius Comper RO

Danube · Iron Gates I · Two-stage lock

The Iron Gates I lock raises and lowers vessels by 20–35 metres

The Iron Gates I dam stands on the Danube, where the river forms the border between Romania and Serbia. Vessels rise or descend by 20–35 metres, depending on the river's flow, through two chambers, each 310 m long and 34 m wide. First the two chambers share their water, then one fills from the reservoir or empties into the river. At a total lift of 34 m, the calculation gives 10.8 minutes to empty the lower chamber: what the 1964 design estimated, and faster than the 15-minute average in the Serbian lock's operation. Choose a vessel, a direction and how long the valves take to open.

Vessel
Direction

The total change in level varies with the Danube's flow, from about 20 to 35 m. The default times, 6 and 4 minutes, are those published for the Serbian lock's valves before its refurbishment; the sources found give none for the Romanian lock.

Two chambers, one after the other

Romania and Yugoslavia, of which Serbia was then part, jointly built the hydroelectric and navigation complex at Iron Gates I, officially inaugurated on 16 May 1972. There is a two-stage lock on each bank. Each has two chambers in series, with a usable length of 310 m and a usable width of 34 m; the 1963 agreement requires at least 4.5 m of water over the sill.

The difference in level between the reservoir and the Danube downstream varies with the river's flow. Serbia's power utility EPS gives 21–34 m, the Romanian geographer Alexandra Ghenovici, in 1972, 20–34 m, and the Romanian builder Hidroconstrucția 20–35 m.

How the water moves

Water enters and leaves through culverts along the chamber floors, and valves at the ends and between the chambers control the flow. When a passage begins, the upper chamber stands at reservoir level and the lower one at river level. First the valves between the chambers open: water flows from the upper chamber into the lower until they stand at the same level. Two equal chambers meet half-way; starting from 69.5 and 35.5 m, the levels in the design handbook's example, at 52.5 m. The Serbian rehabilitation study also gives 52.5 m as the equalisation level.

Then the vessel moves from one chamber to the other. If it is going down, the lower chamber empties into the river; if it is going up, the upper chamber fills from the reservoir. In the calculation, at a total lift of 34 m, each operation moves about 179,000 cubic metres of water.

Ten minutes or fifteen

In 2020 Radmilović and co-authors published the opening and closing times of the Serbian lock's valves, from the operator's data: 6 minutes for the plate valves at the upper and lower ends, 4 minutes for the segment valves between the chambers. Used as opening times, with the handbook's valve area, they give, at a total lift of 34 m, 10.8 minutes to empty the lower chamber and 7.5 minutes to share the water between the chambers.

The sources give no single time to compare against. The design published in 1964 by B. Knežević estimated 9–10 minutes to fill the upper chamber and 11 for the lower; Alexandra Ghenovici reported about 10 minutes to fill a chamber in 1972, and EPS gives about 10 minutes to empty the lower chamber into the Danube. The operating charts published by Radmilović, though, show an average of 15 minutes to empty each chamber. The calculation sits beside the design and below the operating average; the sources do not say at what lift, or from what moment, the 15 minutes were timed.

With the valves fully open at once, emptying the lower chamber would take 7.8 minutes. Engineers control how fast the valves open, to limit currents, water oscillations and the strain on mooring lines.

A full passage also includes manoeuvring the vessels and working the gates. The technical specification of the Romanian builder Hidroconstrucția gives 62 minutes; in October 2012 the judicial administrator of Hidroelectrica, Romania's hydropower company, reported that the average on the Romanian side had fallen from 145 to 75 minutes after the navigation works. For the Serbian lock, Radmilović's table gives 126–165 minutes, from the vessel's approach to its departure.

1964 design estimates: 9–11 minSerbian operating average: 15 min246810121416024681012time used: 6 min10.0 m13.5 m17.0 mvertical: minutes to fill or empty · horizontal: minutes for the valves to open
Each line shows the calculated time to empty one chamber into the river, or fill it from the reservoir, from an initial difference of 10, 13.5 or 17 m (a total lift of 20, 27 or 34 m), with the reservoir or river at a fixed level. Filled circle: 17 m with the valves opening over 6 minutes, 10.8 minutes. Open circle: the same stage with the valves fully open at once, 7.8 minutes. The band: the 1964 design estimates; the dotted line: the average of the two emptyings in the Serbian operating charts.

Share your result

The link saves the change in level, the valve opening times, the vessel and the direction of travel.

Sources and method

As a chamber fills or empties, the difference between the water levels falls. The flow is the discharge coefficient multiplied by the open area of the valves and by √(2gh), where h is the difference in level and g the acceleration due to gravity; divided by the chamber area, 10,540 m², it gives the rate at which the water rises or falls. When the two chambers share their water, one level falls as much as the other rises, so at the same flow the difference falls twice as fast; when a chamber is open to the reservoir or the river, their level is taken as fixed. Olimpia Blăgoi's Romanian lock design handbook gives Iron Gates I a cross-section of 72 m² for the emptying culverts at the valves and an emptying-system discharge coefficient of 0.57; here the same values are used for every path the water takes, a simplification. The open area of the valves grows steadily over the chosen time; at 0 min they open fully at once. Equalisation counts as complete at a 1 cm difference. The inertia of the water and the water displaced by vessels are not calculated. The times exclude the vessels entering and leaving and the gates being worked.

  1. Olimpia Blăgoi, Căi navigabile. Ecluze. Îndrumar de proiectare (Navigable waterways. Locks. A design handbook), p. 7 and pp. 23–24 (§III.1.a.4, eq. III.13). scribd.com Example water levels of 69.5 m and 35.5 m. The emptying culverts have a total cross-section of 72 m² at the valves; the discharge coefficient is 0.57.
  2. Z. Radmilović, N. Tomić-Petrović, D. Ambruš, “The Danube waterway transport as extended leg of maritime transport across ship locks – case study: ship lock Iron Gate 1”, table 3. upcommons.upc.edu Valve opening times at the Serbian lock: 6 minutes at the ends, 4 minutes between the chambers; the total lockage time.
  3. Environmental impact study for the rehabilitation of the Đerdap I lock, pp. 63–73. apepaduri.gov.ro The 52.5 m equalisation level; the culverts and the valves between the chambers.
  4. Alexandra Ghenovici, Revue roumaine de géographie 16 (1972), no. 2, p. 207. biblioteca-digitala.ro The change in level ranges from 20 to 34 m. A chamber takes about 10 minutes to fill.
  5. B. Knežević, La Houille Blanche 1964, no. 2, p. 288. shf-lhb.org The design estimated 9–10 minutes to fill the upper chamber and 11 minutes to fill the lower one.
  6. EPS, “HE Đerdap 1”, navigation locks, and the HE Đerdap monograph, pp. 43–44. eps.rs · eps.rs (pdf) The 21–34 m change in level; the lower chamber emptied in about 10 minutes.
  7. Agreement between Romania and Yugoslavia of 30 November 1963, art. 3 and the design annex. treaties.un.org The 310 × 34 m chambers, 4.5 m of water over the sill.
  8. Hidroconstrucția, Revista Construcțiilor no. 86 (2012), pp. 4–5. revistaconstructiilor.eu The inauguration on 16 May 1972, the floor culverts, the 62-minute lockage, the 20–35 m difference.
  9. Hidroelectrica, judicial administrator's report, October 2012, pp. 24–25. fondulproprietatea.ro Average lockage on the Romanian side: 145 minutes before the works, 75 after.