mariuscomper.uk Română

Egeria, 381–384

We aren't sure of her name. We know what hour she reached the top of Sinai

The fourth hour, about ten in the morning, on a Sunday, most likely in December 383. So writes a woman from the far western edge of the Roman Empire to her friends at home, whom she calls “ladies, reverend sisters”. Her text, the oldest surviving travel account by a woman, survives in a single incomplete copy, found in Arezzo in 1884. The map below follows her route chapter by chapter and says what still stands of what she saw.

Map of the seven journeys, drawn one after another
Map of the route in the chapter on screen ConstantinopleChalcedonTarsusAntiochJerusalemPelusiumClysma (Suez)FaranMount SinaiThe Bush (St Catherine's)PithomHeroRameses“the city of Arabia”TathnisPelusiumJerusalemAlexandriaJerusalemJerichoLiviasthe spring of MosesMount NeboJerusalemJerichoSedima (Salem)Thesbethe brook CherithCarneasJerusalemAntiochHierapolisthe Euphrates crossingBatanisEdessaCharrae (Harran)Jacob's wellAntiochTarsusPompeiopolisCorycusSeleucia (St Thecla)MansocrenaeChalcedonConstantinopleEphesus (planned)

route described in the texttext lost, or road not described

From Constantinople to Sinai, to Edessa and back

The text begins in the middle of a sentence, with Sinai in view, and stops in the middle of another, halfway through a festival in Jerusalem. What survives is three journeys out of Jerusalem, where she lived for three years, with the way back from Sinai through Egypt, then the road home through Mesopotamia and Asia Minor to Constantinople, from where she sends the letter, and an hour-by-hour guide to the services of Jerusalem.

The map follows the route as you read. The solid line runs through the places she names, in the order she names them. The dashed line marks the stretches where the text is lost, or where she only says where she went, without saying which way. Distances are measured through the same places, so the real journey was longer.

The years come from Pierre Devos's reckoning (1967): the only year in which Easter falls early enough for someone leaving Jerusalem after Easter to reach Carrhae on the eve of the feast of 23 April, as she did, is 384. Her three years in Jerusalem put her arrival in 381. She writes no year herself.

Chapter I

From the edge of the world to Jerusalem

to 381

When
to 381
Distance on the map
2,100 kmat least, through the places named, of which 2,100 km dashed
By way of
Constantinople, Chalcedon, Tarsus, Antioch, Jerusalem

Dashed: the whole way. Its text is lost. Two points are certain, because she mentions them on the way back: at Tarsus she “had already been, on my way to Jerusalem”, and the shrine of Saint Euphemia at Chalcedon “was already known to me from a former time”. The line enters the map from the west, where she came from, without saying by which road.

She does not say where she set out from. A monk from Galicia, Valerius of Bierzo, who read her letter three centuries later, calls her “sprung from the farthest shore of the western sea, the Ocean”, which for him meant Galicia. Karl Meister argued in 1909, from her language and from the way she compares the Euphrates with the Rhône, as if the sisters knew it, that she came from southern Gaul. Both readings still stand.

Of the road to Jerusalem nothing survives. What we know comes from the return: she had been at Tarsus, had passed through Chalcedon, where she knew the shrine of Saint Euphemia, and had travelled the great road of Asia Minor through Cappadocia, Galatia and Bithynia, which she calls “already known to me” when she takes it the second time. Her English editors of 1919 supposed she came out from the west by land, like the anonymous Bordeaux pilgrim fifty years earlier, across northern Italy and the Balkans. It is a supposition.

An old photograph: a rotunda with galleries of columns and, in the middle, the shrine over the tomb.
The Anastasis rotunda of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, photographed in the late nineteenth century. Egeria uses the name for the church built over the tomb; the round plan has survived, the building has been rebuilt more than once. Late 19th-century photograph, Nationaal Archief; public domain · Wikimedia Commons

She travelled with a party: she writes “we” almost as often as “I”. Bishops come out to meet her, monks receive her in their cells, soldiers escort her through unsafe districts. On Nebo she rides part of the way on a donkey; on Sinai, she says, the ascent was “impossible in the saddle”. Valerius calls her “most blessed nun”; the thirteenth-century catalogues of the abbey of Saint-Martial at Limoges call her an abbess.

In Jerusalem she stayed three full years, as she says herself when she leaves. On the map her arrival is put in 381, by Devos's reckoning. What she did in those years, apart from the journeys below, is in the second half of the letter: she followed the services of the city, festival by festival, and noted their hours.

In her words

But do you, ladies, light of my eyes, deign to remember me, whether I am in the body or out of the body.

The end of the travel narrative, written at Constantinople

Chapter II

Sinai

December 383

When
December 383
Distance on the map
850 kmat least, through the places named, of which 400 km dashed
By way of
Pelusium, Clysma (Suez), Faran, Mount Sinai, The Bush (St Catherine's)

Dashed: the road to Clysma, that is Suez, which falls in the lost part of the text. The line starts from Jerusalem; her editors of 1919 thought it more likely that she came to Sinai from Egypt, where she had been at Alexandria and in the Thebaid. From Clysma to the mountain the line is solid, because on the way back she says she went “by the same route and the same stations by which we had come out”.

The surviving text opens here, with a valley “infinitely great, quite flat and extraordinarily beautiful”, and Sinai across it. The guides tell her the custom is to pray at the spot from which the mountain is first seen. They reached its foot late on the Saturday, at a monastery, and on Sunday morning began the climb.

The mountains, she writes, are not climbed “gently by a spiral track, as we say snail-shell wise”: you go straight up, “as if up a wall”. She went on foot, since it could not be done in the saddle, and did not feel the toil: “I realized that the desire which I had was being fulfilled.” At the fourth hour they reached the summit, where there was a church “not great in size, for the place itself is not very great”, and an old priest, a monk from early life, came out of his cell to meet them. The passage from the book of Moses was read, the oblation made, they communicated, and the priests gave them eulogiae, fruit from the gardens at the foot of the mountain.

An old photograph: a wide sandy valley between bare mountains, with a clump of palm trees.
Wadi Feiran, the valley Egeria calls Faran, photographed in the 1930s. Here she rested two days on the way down. Photo: Matson Collection, 1934–1939, Library of Congress; public domain · Wikimedia Commons

From the top they were shown Egypt, Palestine, the Red Sea and the sea that leads to Alexandria. Her editors of 1919 note drily that none of this can be seen from Jebel Musa: “like so many tourists she was misinformed.” They came down by Horeb, to Elijah's cave, and at about the tenth hour reached the head of the valley and the bush, “which same bush is alive to this day and throws out shoots”. It stands in a garden with good water, in front of a church. Next morning they asked for the oblation to be made there.

The way back took longer than the climb. At Faran, thirty-five miles from the mountain, they rested two days. Then the road dropped to the sea and kept to the shore, “at one time the waves touch the feet of the animals, while at another the course is through the desert, a hundred, two hundred, and sometimes even more than five hundred paces from the sea”, with no road at all. The people of Faran set up signs and travel by night with their camels, more quickly and safely than others do where there is a clear road. At Clysma they stopped again, “because we had travelled hard along the sandy way of the desert”.

Ridges of reddish granite at sunrise, with mist in the valleys between them and an orange sky on the horizon.
The ridges of Sinai at sunrise. She reached the summit at the fourth hour, three to four hours after dawn. Photo: Grand Parc, Bordeaux, CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons
A dense green bramble spilling over a stone wall in a monastery courtyard.
The bush shown today in the courtyard of Saint Catherine's Monastery, a Rubus sanctus. Justinian built the monastery between 548 and 565, more than a century and a half after her visit, around the church she describes. Photo: Florian Prischl, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In her words

Thus the toil was great, for I had to go up on foot, the ascent being impossible in the saddle, and yet I did not feel the toil, because I realized that the desire which I had was being fulfilled at God's bidding.

The ascent of Sinai

Chapter III

Egypt: the road of the Exodus

January 384

When
January 384
Distance on the map
1,020 kmat least, through the places named, of which 530 km dashed
By way of
Pithom, Hero, Rameses, “the city of Arabia”, Tathnis, Pelusium, Jerusalem, Alexandria

Dashed: an earlier stay in Alexandria and the Thebaid, which she mentions three times, “when I was in Egypt for the first time”, without a word about it. The line stops at Alexandria: she names the Thebaid but no place in it.

She already knew the land of Goshen, but wanted to see in order “all the places which the children of Israel touched” from Rameses to the Red Sea. From Clysma there are four stations through the desert, each with a garrison, and the soldiers “escorted us from fort to fort”, as Roman discipline required. From Migdol, a fort, she was shown Epauleum across the way, then, on either side of the road, Baal-zephon, Etham, Succoth, Pithom, which “is now a fort”, and Hero, a large village with a church, martyr-memorials and cells, at the sixteenth milestone from the land of Goshen, on an arm of the Nile.

Of Rameses “not a single habitation” was left, only ruins “just as they fell”, one great stone carved with two huge statues, which she was told were Moses and Aaron, and an old, small sycamore “planted by the patriarchs”, from which the sick plucked twigs. The bishop of the city of Arabia, an elderly man, a monk brought up from childhood in a cell, “very learned in the Scriptures”, told her its Greek name, “the tree of truth”. The editors of 1919 set beside this passage a photograph of a red granite group published by Flinders Petrie in 1906, found at Tell er-Retabeh, Rameses II with the god Atum, guessing that these were the statues she saw. It is their guess, and they do not settle where Rameses was: their introduction puts it at Saft el-Henneh, some 30 km away.

She reached the city of Arabia on the very eve of the Epiphany, “by a very happy chance”, and the bishop, whom she knew from the Thebaid, kept her two days for the services. From here she sent the soldiers back: the public road from the Thebaid to Pelusium passed that way, and in Egypt there was “no need to trouble the soldiers further”. For two days she went through Goshen, “among vines that yield wine and vines that yield balsam, among orchards, highly cultivated fields and very pleasant gardens”, along the Nile, and writes that she had never seen a more beautiful country.

By way of Tathnis, the city “where holy Moses was born”, she came down to Pelusium, and from there, through the stations she knew, entered Palestine and returned to “Aelia, that is Jerusalem”. The city's Roman name, given by Hadrian, is one of the signs the editors took as evidence of an early date.

In her words

And why should I say more? for I think that I have never seen a more beautiful country than the land of Goshen.

The road through Goshen

Chapter IV

Mount Nebo

early 384

When
early 384
Distance on the map
110 kmat least, through the places named
By way of
Jerusalem, Jericho, Livias, the spring of Moses, Mount Nebo

She wanted to see the mountain from which Moses looked at Canaan and on which he died. She left Jerusalem with a priest, deacons and monks, crossed the Jordan “where the children of Israel had crossed” and came to Livias, in the plain where, she was told, the foundations of their camp can still be seen. There she read from Deuteronomy and the song of Moses, then prayer, then onward.

Her rule of the road is spelled out here: at every place she wished to see, first prayer, then the reading from the book, then one psalm suited to the place, then prayer again. “At God's bidding we always kept to this custom, whenever we were able to come to the places we desired.”

The interior of a modern basilica with a timber roof, over old mosaics and stone columns.
The interior of the basilica on Mount Nebo, reopened in 2016. The fourth-century church Egeria describes was found by the Franciscans in 1933; its mosaics and foundations are inside. Photo: Bashar Tabbah, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The priest of Livias offered a detour of about six miles to see the water Moses drew from the rock. Between a little church and the cells of monks, “whom they call here ascetics”, a stream ran out of the rock, “very beautiful and limpid, and excellent to the taste”. From there, with those monks who could manage the labour, they went up Nebo: most of the way on donkeys, one steeper stretch on foot.

On the summit stood a church “of no great size”, and inside it, where the pulpit was, a slightly raised place the size of a tomb. The monks told her that the angels laid Moses there: “as it was shown to us by our ancestors who dwelt here, so do we show it to you.” From the church door she was shown the Jordan running into the Dead Sea, Jericho, Livias, “the greatest part of Palestine” and the place of Lot's wife. The pillar itself could not be seen, “I cannot therefore deceive you in this”: the bishop of Segor told them the water had covered it some years before.

In her words

But believe me, reverend ladies, the pillar itself cannot be seen, only the place is shown, the pillar is said to have been covered by the Dead Sea. Certainly when we saw the place we saw no pillar, I cannot therefore deceive you in this.

From the summit of Nebo

Chapter V

The tomb of Job

early 384

When
early 384
Distance on the map
330 kmat least, through the places named, of which 140 km dashed
By way of
Jerusalem, Jericho, Sedima (Salem), Thesbe, the brook Cherith, Carneas

Dashed: after the brook Cherith a leaf is missing from the manuscript, and the text resumes at Carneas. The road between them is a guess; the way back, “through each of the stations through which we had passed”, is drawn back along the same line.

The idea came from the monks who used to come to Jerusalem from Ausitis, the land of Job, and told her about their country. It was eight stations to Carneas. On the way, on the bank of the Jordan, in a valley full of vines, trees and water, she saw a large village with a mound in the middle, “shaped as large tombs are”, and a church on top. She asked what it was. It was Salem, the city of Melchizedek, which “now, through the corruption of the language, the village is called Sedima”.

The priest of the place, an elderly man well taught in the Scriptures, showed her the foundations around the mound, “those of the palace of king Melchizedek”: anyone who digs there still finds “little fragments of silver and bronze”. She remembers that John baptized at Aenon near Salim and asks how far it is. “Two hundred paces off, and, if you wish, I will now lead you there on foot.” In the middle of an orchard was a spring with a pool in front of it; the garden, she was told, is called “the garden of Saint John”, and the village's baptisms are still done there at Easter.

Further up the Jordan valley they came on Thesbe, the city of Elijah the Tishbite, with his cave, and on a wide valley opening to the left, with a great torrent, where a monk had made himself a cell. “Then I, as I am very inquisitive, began to ask what was this valley.” It was the brook Cherith, where the raven brought Elijah food. Then, on the left, “whence on the opposite side we saw parts of Phoenicia, there suddenly appeared a great and high mountain which extended in length”, and here the text breaks off: a leaf is missing from the manuscript.

When it resumes, a monk and ascetic had come down to Carneas to tell the bishop and clergy to dig where it had been shown him. They found a cave, followed it for about a hundred paces, and “suddenly, as they dug, a stone tomb came to light” with the name Job carved on its lid. The church built over it, “by some tribune”, was unfinished. Next morning the bishop made the oblation at her request and they set out back to Jerusalem.

In her words

Then I, as I am very inquisitive, began to ask what was this valley where the holy monk had now made himself a cell, for I did not think it was without reason.

At the brook Cherith

Chapter VI

Mesopotamia: Edessa and Carrhae

April 384

When
April 384
Distance on the map
1,280 kmat least, through the places named, of which 630 km dashed
By way of
Jerusalem, Antioch, Hierapolis, the Euphrates crossing, Batanis, Edessa, Charrae (Harran), Jacob's well

Dashed: from Jerusalem to Antioch, a road she mentions only in passing, “my way lying through Antioch”. From Antioch on, the line is solid there and back, because she says at the end that she returned “by the route and by the stations through which we had come from Antioch”.

After three full years in Jerusalem “my mind was to return to my country”, but first she wanted to see the monks of Mesopotamia and the shrine of the apostle Thomas at Edessa, which is, she writes, at the twenty-fifth station from Jerusalem. From Antioch she went through Hierapolis, “very beautiful and rich”, and at the fifteenth milestone reached the Euphrates. The river “is huge and, as it were, terrible, for it flows down with a current like the river Rhone, only the Euphrates is still greater”. She crossed in large ships, after waiting more than half a day.

At Edessa she went straight to the church and shrine of Thomas, “very great, very beautiful and of new construction”. The bishop, “both monk and confessor”, said to her: “As I see, daughter, that for the sake of devotion you have undertaken so great a labour in coming to these places from far-distant lands.” He took her to the palace of King Abgar, to his marble statue “having a sheen as if made of pearl”, and to the pools “full of fish such as I never saw before, of so great size, so bright and of so good a flavour”. The city, she writes, has no water at all but what comes out of the palace, “like a great silver river”.

A wide blue-green river between rocky banks, with a town on the far shore.
The Euphrates at Birecik, upstream of where she crossed. “It flows down with a current like the river Rhone, only the Euphrates is still greater.” Photo: Dosseman, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The bishop told her the city's legend: King Abgar had written to Jesus, and Jesus had answered by a courier, Ananias, promising that no enemy would enter the city. When the Persians besieged it and cut off its water, the springs burst out in the palace and the Persians' water dried up. At the gate the bishop read her the letters and gave her copies. “For although I have copies at home, yet it seemed to me more pleasant to receive them from him, lest perhaps something less might have reached us at home, and indeed that which I received here is fuller.” She promises the sisters they will read them.

She reached Carrhae, Abraham's Haran, “on the day before the martyr's feast of saint Helpidius, which is on the twenty-third of April”, the day on which all the monks of Mesopotamia, even the hermits, come down into the city. She saw the men she had thought she would never see; the second night they went back to the desert. In the city she found scarcely a Christian, “all are heathen”. She asked the bishop where Ur of the Chaldees was: at the tenth station, towards Persia, “but there is now no access for Romans, for the Persians hold the whole country”. She settled for the well at which Jacob watered Rachel's flock, six miles away, where the stone he rolled aside still lies.

Dozens of large grey carp crowding the surface of a stone-lined pool.
The carp of Balıklıgöl in Şanlıurfa, the old Edessa. The city shows these pools today as Abraham's; Egeria saw the pools “full of fish” in Abgar's palace. Photo: Volker Höhfeld, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Mud-brick houses with conical roofs like beehives under a clear sky.
The beehive houses of Harran, the city she calls Charrae. She found it almost without Christians. Photo: Dosseman, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In her words

As I see, daughter, that for the sake of devotion you have undertaken so great a labour in coming to these places from far-distant lands, if you are willing, we will show you all the places that are pleasant to the sight of Christians.

The bishop of Edessa, as she reports him

Chapter VII

Homeward, by Tarsus and Chalcedon

after April 384

When
after April 384
Distance on the map
1,470 kmat least, through the places named, of which 1,060 km dashed
By way of
Antioch, Tarsus, Pompeiopolis, Corycus, Seleucia (St Thecla), Mansocrenae, Chalcedon, Constantinople, Ephesus (planned)

Dashed: from Mansocrenae to Chalcedon, where she names only the provinces, “Cappadocia, Galatia, and Bithynia”; the line follows the Roman road through Tyana, Ancyra and Nicomedia. Dashed too is the road to Ephesus, which she was only planning when she closed the letter.

At Antioch she stayed a week while the things needed for the journey were prepared. At Tarsus she had been before, but the shrine of Saint Thecla was three stations away, in Isauria, and “it was very pleasant for me to go there, especially as it was so very near at hand”. The road kept to the coast, through Pompeiopolis and Corycus, to Seleucia.

The shrine is on a low hill, about fifteen hundred paces from the city, among “numberless cells of men and of women”, guarded by a high wall against the Isaurians, “who are very malicious and who frequently commit acts of robbery”. There she found Marthana, a deaconess she had known in Jerusalem, who was ruling the cells of the apotactitae and virgins: “how can I describe the extent of her joy or of mine?” The whole of the acts of Saint Thecla was read, and after two days she went back to Tarsus.

A ruined stone gallery with arches cut into the rock, grass growing on its floor.
The cave church at Meryemlik near Silifke, the old Seleucia in Isauria, where Egeria found Marthana. The great basilica above it was built by the emperor Zeno a century after her; one apse of it remains. Photo: Dosseman, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

From Tarsus, after three days, she climbed to Mansocrenae under Mount Taurus, then took the road “already known to me” through Cappadocia, Galatia and Bithynia to Chalcedon, where she stopped for the shrine of Saint Euphemia. Next day she crossed the sea to Constantinople and went through all the churches, “that of the Apostles and all the martyr-memorials, of which there are very many”.

From there she sends the letter. She already has another plan, Ephesus, for the shrine of the apostle John, and promises the sisters that if she is still “in the body” she will tell them the rest in person or in another letter. Whether she got home, we do not know. Valerius, who read her whole text, does not say.

In her words

And when she had seen me, how can I describe the extent of her joy or of mine?

Meeting Marthana at Seleucia

Holy Week in Jerusalem, hour by hour

The second half of the letter is no longer a journey. It is a guide to the services of Jerusalem, written for the sisters so that they would know “what is the order of service day by day in the holy places”. The most detailed part is Holy Week, with its hours. The hours are Roman: the sixth is noon, the twelfth is sunset, and the hours of the night are counted from sunset. What follows are, in the words of her editors of 1919, probably the oldest surviving descriptions of rites still kept today.

  1. Saturday, the day before Palm Sunday

    the seventh hour, early afternoon

    Everyone goes to the Lazarium, that is Bethany, two miles from the city. The crowd is so great “that not only the place itself, but also the fields around, are full of people”. The Gospel is read where Jesus comes to Bethany six days before the Passover, and Easter is announced.

  2. Palm Sunday

    from the seventh hour until evening

    At the seventh hour everyone goes up the Mount of Olives to the church of Eleona; at the ninth, to the Imbomon, the place of the Ascension; as the eleventh hour approaches, the passage is read where the children meet the Lord with branches. Then the bishop rises and everyone walks down into the city, children on their parents' shoulders, “some of palms and some of olives”, answering “Blessed is He that cometh in the Name of the Lord”. They go very slowly, “lest the people should be wearied”, and reach the Anastasis late.

  3. Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday

    from the ninth hour into the night

    Each day, from the ninth hour, everyone sits in the great church at Golgotha, the martyrium, with hymns and lessons, until the first hour of the night. On Tuesday night they go up to Eleona, where the bishop himself reads, in the cave, the discourse “Take heed that no man deceive you”. On Wednesday night, at the Anastasis, the priest reads how Judas went to the Jews, “and there is such a moaning and groaning of all the people that no one can help being moved to tears at that hour”.

  4. Maundy Thursday

    from the eighth hour until the next dawn

    The assembly is at the eighth hour, earlier than usual. The oblation is made at the martyrium and then, once only in the year, “behind the Cross”. The archdeacon announces: “Let us all assemble at the first hour of the night in the church which is in Eleona, for great toil awaits us to-day, in this very night.” Everyone hurries home to eat. On the Mount of Olives they stay until about the fifth hour of the night, at the sixth they go up to the Imbomon, at cockcrow they come down to the place where Jesus prayed and then, with more than two hundred church candles, to Gethsemane. At the reading of the arrest, “their lamentation may be heard perhaps as far as the city”. They enter the city “about the time when one man begins to be able to recognize another”.

  5. Good Friday

    from dawn into the night

    Before the Cross the trial before Pilate is read. The bishop sends them home to “sit down awhile”, with orders to be back just before the second hour. From the second hour to the sixth everyone passes, one by one, a table on which lies the wood of the Cross, taken out of a silver-gilt casket: they touch it with their foreheads and their eyes, kiss it and pass on, without laying a hand on it. The bishop holds its ends firmly, and the deacons guard it, “because, I know not when, some one is said to have bitten off and stolen a portion of the sacred wood”. From the sixth hour to the ninth, in the court between the Cross and the Anastasis, “whether it be in rain or in heat”, the psalms, the apostles, the prophets and the gospels of the Passion are read. At the ninth hour, “He gave up the ghost”, from John.

  6. Holy Saturday and Easter

    the night, and then Easter evening

    The Paschal vigil “is kept as with us”, with one addition: the newly baptized, “when they issue from the font”, are led with the bishop first to the Anastasis, to the tomb, and only then into the great church where all the people are keeping watch. On Easter evening, at Sion, the reading is how Jesus came in to the disciples through shut doors, when Thomas was away. All year round, she writes, the hymns, lessons and prayers are always “suitable and fitting references, both to the day that is being celebrated and also to the place”; that struck her as the most admirable thing of all.

A mosaic detail: an oval walled city with a colonnaded street and a large church with a red roof.
Jerusalem on the mosaic map of Madaba, some two hundred years after Egeria. In the middle of the colonnaded street stands the Holy Sepulchre complex, with the great basilica, the martyrium, towards the street and the rotunda behind. Sixth-century mosaic, church of Saint George, Madaba; public domain · Wikimedia Commons
An old photograph: the low stone entrance to a tomb, with a man standing beside it.
The entrance to the tomb of Lazarus at Bethany, photographed in the nineteenth century. Here, “at the Lazarium”, her Holy Week began. Photo: Félix Bonfils, 19th century; public domain · Wikimedia Commons
A small octagonal stone chapel in a courtyard, with blind arches on its sides.
The Chapel of the Ascension on the Mount of Olives, the twelfth-century Crusader octagon. The Imbomon Egeria describes was an unroofed enclosure with seats, without today's building. Photo: Bukvoed, CC BY 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Does what she saw still stand?

Ten things she describes. For each, guess whether a traveller today still finds something to see at that spot or whether it has gone entirely. Rebuilt or restored counts as “still there”.

  1. 1

    The fish pools in Abgar's palace, Edessa

    “There were fountains full of fish such as I never saw before, of so great size, so bright and of so good a flavour were they.”

    The answer

    Still there. The pools Şanlıurfa shows today as Balıklıgöl are full of carp that no one may catch; Islamic tradition ties them to Abraham, Egeria's to King Abgar. The identification is the city's, not hers.

  2. 2

    The great church at Golgotha, “built by Constantine”

    The martyrium, the basilica where the people gather in Holy Week, “in Golgotha behind the Cross”.

    The answer

    Gone. The caliph al-Hakim had the whole complex demolished in 1009. The Byzantine rebuilding of 1048 was confined to the rotunda; the great basilica was never raised again, and the Crusader church of 1149 covers only the tomb and Golgotha.

  3. 3

    The Anastasis, the church over the tomb

    Where the bishop enters “the cave” and reads the Resurrection every Sunday after the first cockcrow.

    The answer

    Still there. The rotunda was rebuilt in 1048 and in the twelfth century, but stands on the same round plan, and the restoration of 2016–2017 found the limestone burial bed of the tomb intact.

  4. 4

    The bush at the head of the valley

    “Which same bush is alive to this day and throws out shoots”, in a garden with good water, in front of a church.

    The answer

    Still there. In the courtyard of Saint Catherine's Monastery, which Justinian built around the site between 548 and 565, a bush is still shown, a Rubus sanctus. Whether it is the same plant, no one can say.

  5. 5

    The church on the summit of Sinai

    “A church, not great in size, for the place itself, that is the summit of the mountain, is not very great.”

    The answer

    Still there, rebuilt. A Greek Orthodox chapel built in 1934 on the ruins of a sixteenth-century church stands on the summit, beside a small mosque. Her church has not survived.

  6. 6

    The church on Mount Nebo

    “A church of no great size, on the very top of mount Nebo”, with the raised place the size of a tomb where the pulpit is.

    The answer

    Still there. In 1933 the Franciscans found the fourth-century church, enlarged in the fifth and sixth centuries; today's basilica, reopened in 2016, covers it, mosaics and all.

  7. 7

    Eleona, the church on the Mount of Olives

    “The very beautiful church” with the cave in which Jesus taught the disciples, where the Palm Sunday procession starts.

    The answer

    Gone. The Persians destroyed it in 614; the foundations were found in 1910 under the Pater Noster convent, and the reconstruction begun in 1915 stopped in 1927. The ruins and the cave can be seen.

  8. 8

    The Church of the Apostles, Constantinople

    On arriving “I went through all the churches, that of the Apostles and all the martyr-memorials”.

    The answer

    Gone. Constantine's church, rebuilt by Justinian in 550, was demolished by the Ottomans in 1461–1462; the Fatih Mosque stands on its site.

  9. 9

    The Lazarium, the tomb of Lazarus at Bethany

    “About the second milestone from the city”, where the crowd gathers on the Saturday before Palm Sunday.

    The answer

    Still there. The rock-cut tomb can still be visited, down a flight of steps; the churches above it have been rebuilt several times, most recently in the 1950s.

  10. 10

    The sycamore “planted by the patriarchs” at Rameses

    “Very old, and therefore very small, though it still bears fruit”; the sick pluck off twigs, and it benefits them.

    The answer

    Gone. A tree of the fourth century cannot still be standing, and where Rameses was, Saft el-Henneh or Tell er-Retabeh, her editors do not settle. Nor are the two statues she was shown as Moses and Aaron to be found there.

Who she was: three things we only half know

  1. The name

    The text has no title and does not name its author. The name comes from a letter by Valerius of Bierzo, a monk from Galicia who read her account in the second half of the seventh century and praised her courage to his brethren. The copies of his letter call her Aetheria, Echeria, Etheria, Heteria, Eiheria or Egeria. Gamurrini, who found the manuscript, thought she was Silvia of Aquitaine, sister of a minister of Theodosius; Marius Férotin showed in 1903 that she is the woman in Valerius's letter. The editors of 1919 wrote Etheria; since then Egeria has prevailed.

  2. Her home

    Valerius calls her “sprung from the farthest shore of the western sea, the Ocean” and “from the farthest part of this western coast”, that is, from his own region, Galicia. Karl Meister proposed southern Gaul in 1909, perhaps Arles or Marseille, from her language and from the Rhône, the only European landmark in the text, which she uses to describe the Euphrates as if the sisters knew it. The English editors held to Galicia: the Rhône, they write, “can hardly outweigh” Valerius's words, and she may simply have crossed it on her way.

  3. The years

    She writes no year. Gamurrini and Férotin put the journey in the reign of Theodosius; Meister, from her language, around 534. Against him stand the things she sees or does not see: in Jerusalem she knows only three churches and never mentions those built in the sixth century; the bishop of Carrhae tells her of Nisibis that “the Persians hold the whole country”, as they had since 363. Pierre Devos fixed the years in 1967 from a simple sum: Easter 384 fell on 24 March, and from there to 22 April, the eve of the feast at Carrhae, is 29 days, the least her own figures add up to: 25 stations to Edessa, three days there and one to Carrhae. In the neighbouring years Easter fell too late for the sum to fit. It is a fit, not a proof, but no other year fits. Three years back gives an arrival in 381.

One manuscript, with no beginning and no end

A page of a medieval manuscript in small brown script on yellowed parchment.
A page of manuscript 405 at Arezzo, the only surviving copy of the text. Biblioteca Città di Arezzo, ms. 405; public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The text survives in a single copy, made at Monte Cassino in the second half of the eleventh century and bound with writings of Hilary of Poitiers. How it came to Arezzo, to the library of the lay confraternity, is not known. Gian Francesco Gamurrini found it there in 1884 and published it in 1887; today it is manuscript 405 of the city library.

The beginning, the end and two leaves from the middle are missing: one between the brook Cherith and Carneas, another between the Sunday services and the feast of the Epiphany. Something of the lost part is known through Peter the Deacon, librarian of Monte Cassino in the twelfth century, who copied passages from it into a description of the holy places, and through a few sentences copied in a ninth-century manuscript from Toledo. In 2005 Jesús Alturo identified two more fragments from around the year 900.

Her Latin is the spoken kind, with Greek words correctly transcribed, eulogiae, monazontes, apotactitae, and with formulas she repeats as in a long letter: “believe me”, “why should I say more”, “that your affection may know”. Her English editors found it “very slipshod” but “always lively and entertaining”. She describes herself in one place only: “as I am very inquisitive”.

How far she went

Distances are measured on the map, along great circles, through the places she names and a few road points. Beside them are her own measures: stations, that is days of travel, and Roman miles of about a kilometre and a half.

ChapterKm on the mapWhenWhat she counts
From the edge of the world to Jerusalem 2,100to 381Tarsus and Chalcedon, “known from a former time”
Sinai 850December 383Faran 35 miles from the mountain; two days' rest there
Egypt: the road of the Exodus 1,020January 384four stations through the desert; Hero at the 16th milestone; Rameses 4 miles from Arabia
Mount Nebo 110early 384a detour of 6 miles to the spring
The tomb of Job 330early 384eight stations from Jerusalem; Aenon 200 paces from Salem
Mesopotamia: Edessa and Carrhae 1,280April 384Edessa at the 25th station; the Euphrates 15 miles from Hierapolis; Jacob's well 6 miles from Carrhae
Homeward, by Tarsus and Chalcedon 1,470after April 384Thecla three stations from Tarsus; a week at Antioch, three days at Tarsus

The seven journeys add up to 7,160 kilometres on the map, of which 2,300 kilometres run through places the text names one after another. The rest is dashed. The figure leaves out her road from the west to Constantinople and whatever she travelled, if anything, after sending the letter.

Sources and method

The text is read in the English translation by M. L. McClure and C. L. Feltoe (1919) and in W. Heraeus's Latin text (1908), both in the public domain; Gamurrini's edition (1887) is the first and is consulted where the other two part company. The quotations on the English page are McClure and Feltoe's; the Romanian ones are translated from the Latin. The identifications of places follow the notes of the 1919 edition and C. W. Wilson's topographical appendix to J. H. Bernard's translation (1891).

The route runs through the places she names, in the text's order, at their modern positions. Where a place cannot be identified with confidence, the map follows the editors' identification and says so in the chapter. Unnamed points keep the lines on known Roman roads or on water. Distances are sums of great-circle arcs, rounded to tens of kilometres.

The years follow Pierre Devos's dating (1967), which the sum in the section “Who she was” reproduces. What still stands of her places is taken from encyclopaedias and from the pages of the institutions that keep them, with the date read; each answer in the game says what exactly has survived and what is rebuilt.

Who she was and when she travelled

Images