Chapter 5 · Atmosphere and climateLesson 5.4
Climate change: the greenhouse effect, the evidence and what can be done
If this winter was freezing in your town, how do you know the planet is warming?
Before you read: what do you think?
Romania’s national average temperature has been calculated since 1961. What is the earliest of its ten warmest years?
See the answer
2007. The other nine are 2014, 2015, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025. If the climate had stayed the same, the warmest years would be scattered throughout the record; here they are all at its end.
NASA’s global temperature record begins in 1880. Its 11 warmest years are the last 11, from 2015 to 2025, with 2024 holding the record at 1.28 °C above the 1951–1980 average. In Romania, too, 2024 is the warmest year ever measured.
Four records of measurements tell the same story
A freezing winter in one city is weather. Warming only becomes visible when you put thousands of thermometers and decades of readings together: in the NASA record, every year since 2015 has been warmer than any year before 2015.
The first record is temperature. Thousands of weather stations, ships and buoys measure air and water temperatures every day. These readings are used to calculate the temperature anomaly: the difference between a year’s temperature and the average for a reference period. In the NASA GISTEMP record, the reference is the 1951–1980 average. The anomaly was +1.28 °C in 2024 and +1.19 °C in 2025.
The second record is carbon dioxide. At the Mauna Loa observatory in Hawaii, the annual average rose from 315.98 ppm in 1959 to 427.35 ppm in 2025.
The third is sea level, which rose by an average of 20 cm between 1901 and 2018. Water expands as it warms, and melting glaciers and ice sheets add water to the ocean.
The fourth is ice. Almost all the world’s glaciers have been retreating at the same time since the 1950s.
For the curious
Since the start of the industrial age, the concentration of carbon dioxide has risen by more than 50%.
Sea level is rising faster: by 3.7 mm a year between 2006 and 2018.
In the decade 2011–2020, Arctic sea ice had its smallest average extent since 1850.
The natural greenhouse effect keeps Earth warm; its amplification heats it further
Sunlight passes through the atmosphere and warms the land and ocean. The warmed surface sends energy back as heat, in the form of infrared radiation. Water vapour, carbon dioxide and methane absorb some of this heat and send it back towards the ground. This is the natural greenhouse effect. Without it, Earth’s surface would be about 33 °C colder and water would freeze almost everywhere.
As the amount of greenhouse gases increases, more heat stays near the ground. This is the enhanced greenhouse effect, the cause of global warming. Climate change includes warming and all its consequences: changed rainfall patterns, melting ice, rising sea levels and more frequent extreme events.
Human activity is the cause
The climate also changed in the distant past, for natural reasons: variations in Earth’s orbit, volcanic eruptions and changes in the Sun’s activity. Today’s warming has a different cause. Burning coal, oil and natural gas, cutting down forests and farming add carbon dioxide and methane to the atmosphere faster than the ocean and forests can absorb them.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which periodically summarises research from around the world, wrote in its 2023 report that human activities have unequivocally caused global warming. The average temperature of 2011–2020 was 1.09 °C higher than in 1850–1900.
For the curious
In 2019, the concentration of carbon dioxide was higher than at any time in at least the past two million years.
Effects, mitigation and adaptation
The effects are already visible: more frequent and intense heatwaves, torrential rain, droughts, retreating glaciers and low-lying coasts threatened by the sea. Since the 1980s, Europe has warmed twice as fast as the global average.
The response has two parts. Mitigation means reducing the cause: cutting greenhouse gas emissions through renewable energy, saving energy, public transport and preserving forests. The IPCC says human-caused warming stops only if net carbon dioxide emissions reach zero and emissions of other greenhouse gases, especially methane, also fall sharply. Adaptation means preparing for effects that can no longer be avoided: irrigation and drought-resistant crop varieties, trees and shade in cities, flood defences and timely weather warnings.
Worked example
A cooler year does not stop warming
NASA GISTEMP global anomalies for the past ten years, relative to the 1951–1980 average, are: 2016: 1.01 °C; 2017: 0.91; 2018: 0.85; 2019: 0.98; 2020: 1.01; 2021: 0.85; 2022: 0.89; 2023: 1.17; 2024: 1.28; 2025: 1.19.
From 2020 to 2021 the anomaly fell by 0.16 °C, and 2025 was cooler than 2024. Such dips occur from year to year for natural reasons. The trend emerges over long periods. The sum of the ten values is 10.14, so the average for 2016–2025 is 10.14 ÷ 10 = 1.01 °C above the 1951–1980 average.
Every year in this decade, including the coolest (0.85 °C), was warmer than any year before 2015. To compare with the 1850–1900 period used by the IPCC, NASA recommends adding about 0.19 °C: 2024 was therefore about 1.47 °C warmer than the late nineteenth century.
In Romania
The ten warmest years are all after 2006
Romania’s National Meteorological Administration (ANM) calculates the country’s average temperature from 129 stations with uninterrupted measurements since 1961. In 2024 it was 11.6 °C, 1.8 °C above the 1991–2020 reference value, making it the warmest year in the record. Next come 2023, 2019 and 2025, which had an average of 10.9 °C.
Of the ten warmest years since 1961, the earliest is 2007. The other nine are 2014, 2015, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025.
The year 2025 was also dry. Average precipitation across the country was 13.4% below the reference value, and ANM described the year as extremely warm, with less rain than usual across most of the country.
In brief
- The natural greenhouse effect is the trapping of heat by water vapour, carbon dioxide and methane; without it, Earth would be about 33 °C colder.
- The greenhouse effect, enhanced by gases emitted by humans, produces global warming; climate change includes warming and its consequences.
- The measured evidence: global temperature (2024, the warmest year in the NASA record starting in 1880), carbon dioxide (427 ppm in 2025 at Mauna Loa), sea level (+20 cm between 1901 and 2018) and retreating glaciers.
- The causes are burning fossil fuels, deforestation and agriculture; the IPCC has established that warming is unequivocally caused by human activities.
- Mitigation means cutting greenhouse gas emissions; adaptation means preparing for effects that can no longer be avoided.
- In Romania, 2024 is the warmest year measured: a national average of 11.6 °C, 1.8 °C above the 1991–2020 reference.
Common mistakes
WrongIt was freezing in my town yesterday, so global warming does not exist.
RightA freezing day in one town is weather. Global warming is a trend in the average for the whole planet over decades; cold days and winters still occur.
WrongThe greenhouse effect is a harmful phenomenon caused by pollution.
RightThe natural greenhouse effect makes Earth habitable. The problem is its amplification by gases added by humans.
WrongThe climate has always changed, so humans cannot be causing it now.
RightPast changes had natural causes. For today’s warming, measurements show an increase in greenhouse gases from human activities, and the IPCC attributes it unequivocally to humans.
Test yourself
Six questions. For the first five you see the explanation at once, with the paragraph of the lesson that supports it; for the ones with a written answer you compare with a good answer.
What is the natural greenhouse effect?
Answer
d) Some gases trapping heat emitted by the ground. Water vapour, carbon dioxide and methane absorb infrared radiation emitted by the ground and send some back.
In the NASA GISTEMP record, the anomaly for 2024 is +1.28 °C. What does that mean?
Answer
b) 2024 was 1.28 °C warmer than the 1951–1980 average. The anomaly is measured against the average for a reference period, which is 1951–1980 in the NASA record.
Which of these is an adaptation measure?
Answer
a) Planting trees for shade in a city with increasingly hot summers. Shade reduces the effect of heat on people without changing the cause. The other three cut emissions, so they are mitigation measures.
Why does sea level rise as the planet warms?
Answer
c) Because water expands and land ice melts. The expansion of water and the melting of glaciers and ice sheets are the two main causes.
The reference average annual temperature at a station is 9.8 °C. In one year, the average was 11.6 °C. What was that year’s anomaly? Give your answer in degrees Celsius.
°CAnswer
1.8 °C. The anomaly is the difference between the year’s value and the reference: 11.6 − 9.8 = +1.8 °C.
A mayor decides to plant 2,000 trees along city streets and says, “This will stop global warming.” Which part of the claim is right, and which part needs correcting?
A good answer
Trees provide shade and cool streets, so they are a good way to adapt to hotter summers. They also absorb a little carbon dioxide, but 2,000 trees cannot stop global warming, which depends on emissions from the whole world. Tackling the cause requires mitigation: cutting emissions from energy, transport and industry until net carbon dioxide emissions reach zero.
A complete answer distinguishes adaptation from mitigation, shows the scale at which each works and names emissions cuts as a way to tackle the cause.
Terms
- greenhouse effect
- The trapping near the ground of some of the heat emitted by Earth’s surface by water vapour, carbon dioxide and methane.
- global warming
- The rise in the average temperature of Earth’s surface caused by the enhanced greenhouse effect.
- climate change
- A lasting change in climate: global warming and its effects on rainfall, ice, sea level and extreme events.
- temperature anomaly
- The difference between the temperature of a year (or month) and the average for a reference period.
- IPCC
- The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a UN body that periodically summarises climate research.
- mitigation
- Reducing the cause of climate change, namely greenhouse gas emissions.
- adaptation
- Preparing people, cities and agriculture for the effects of climate change that can no longer be avoided.
Sources and link to the programme
- NASA GISS – GISTEMP v4, tabelul mediilor globale (GLB.Ts+dSST.csv) – annual anomalies for 1880–2025 relative to 1951–1980 (2024: 1.28 °C; 2025: 1.19 °C) and the ranking of years
- NASA GISS – GISTEMP, întrebări frecvente – the 1951–1980 reference period and the adjustment of about 0.19 °C for the 1850–1900 reference
- NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory – Mauna Loa CO2 annual mean data – carbon dioxide: 315.98 ppm in 1959 and 427.35 ppm in 2025
- NASA – Carbon dioxide (Vital signs) – the rise in carbon dioxide of more than 50% since the start of the industrial age
- NASA – What is the greenhouse effect? – the greenhouse effect mechanism and the approximately 33 °C
- IPCC – AR6 Synthesis Report (2023), Summary for Policymakers – A.1: human activities unequivocally caused warming; 1.09 °C in 2011–2020 relative to 1850–1900; 410 ppm in 2019, highest in at least 2 million years; sea level +0.20 m (1901–2018) and 3.7 mm/year (2006–2018); B.5: net zero CO2 emissions
- IPCC – AR6 Working Group I (2021), Summary for Policymakers – A.2.3: the almost simultaneous retreat of glaciers since the 1950s and the Arctic sea ice minimum in 2011–2020
- Copernicus Climate Change Service – European State of the Climate 2024 – Europe has warmed twice as fast as the global average since the 1980s
- ANM – Caracterizarea climatică a anului 2024 – 2024, Romania’s warmest year: 11.6 °C (129 stations, 1961–2024); the annual text gives +2.0 °C, the table +1.99 °C relative to the 1991–2020 median
- ANM – Caracterizarea climatică a anului 2025 – table 2 (129 stations, 1961–2025): 2024 at 11.62 °C and +1.79 °C relative to the 1991–2020 median, followed by 2023, 2019 and 2025 (10.88 °C)
- IPCC AR6 WG1 – Summary for Policymakers, secțiunea D.1 – limiting warming requires net zero CO₂ emissions and sharp reductions in other greenhouse gases, especially methane
- ANM – Caracterizarea climatică a anului 2025 – 2025 in 4th place (10.9 °C); ranking of the ten warmest years in 1961–2025; precipitation 13.4% below the 1991–2020 median
From the programme: “Climate change” (common core). Programme competences covered: 1.3, 2.3, 3.3.