Marius Comper RO

Banat, south-western Romania · 22 watermills

The mills of Rudăria how much wheat a mill can grind with a three-metre drop

Eftimie Murgu, formerly called Rudăria, is a village in the Banat region of south-western Romania. Twenty-two watermills with horizontal wheels still stand along its stream, and local families take turns using them. Reports give very different figures: up to 140 kg of grain an hour, around 30 kg an hour, or 130 kg of flour in 24 hours. The physics of the jet shows which scale fits. Change the drop, the outlet diameter and the wheel: how much wheat could the mill grind?

Waterwheel
Millstone

At Roșoanea mill the drop measured in 1983 was 3 m. At Topleț, another Banat village, Dumitru Țeicu records 10 cm outlet pipes at two mills. For Rudăria the sources found give no outlet diameter, and the unit of the 1983 flow entry is unclear. All 25 mills in Radu Trifan's inventory have metal wheels.

Twenty-two mills on one stream

The village is in Caraș-Severin county. The Rudăria stream runs down from the Almăj Mountains into the river Nera. Along it, in the village and in the gorge, 22 watermills with horizontal wheels survive; they are listed as a group on Romania's register of historic monuments (CS-II-a-A-11112).

The Habsburg military survey of 1769–1772 recorded eight mills within the village bounds. In the 1874 land register, as rechecked by Radu Trifan, there are 29 mills and 22 mill channels; adding the two gave rise to the often-quoted figure of 51 mills.

Several families own a mill together, an arrangement called devălmășie. A customary rota, the rânduială, sets when each family may grind: traditionally a full turn, or rând, lasted 24 hours and came round weekly, fortnightly or monthly. Families can split a turn into day and night or share it by the hour, and the right to a turn can be inherited or sold.

The wheel

A log weir, known locally as an iaz, raises the water and diverts some of it towards the mill. The water runs down a steep chute, the jgheab, sloping at up to 60 degrees and occasionally more, and the jet from its narrow outlet strikes the cups of the ciutură, the mill's horizontal waterwheel. A vertical shaft passes through the mill floor and turns the upper millstone directly: wheel and stone turn at the same speed. In August 1983 Carol Lupșiasca and Ioan Bejan measured a 3 m drop at Roșoanea, one of the mills in the gorge, a wheel 1.20 m across and 120 revolutions a minute.

With a 3 m drop the jet travels at about 7.4 m/s. If it strikes the cups 50–60 cm from the shaft, the wheel can reach at most 118–142 rpm running free, when the cups move as fast as the jet. The measured 120 rpm sits right at that limit: the wheel was turning almost without load, though the 1983 table does not say whether the stone was grinding. Had the water dropped only 1.5 m at the chute, the limit would have been 84–101 rpm, and 120 would have been impossible. The 1983 readings are consistent with each other. While grinding, an ideal wheel runs at half the jet's speed, around 65 rpm.

How much it grinds

In 2014 the Romanian news agency Mediafax reported that a mill could grind up to 140 kg of grain an hour, without saying how this was measured. In her 2011 study Ana Bârcă gives 80–100 kg of grain in three hours, about 27–33 kg an hour. The 1983 survey records 30 kg an hour at a mill downstream owned by families from the nearby village of Bănia. Another account gives 130 kg of flour in 24 hours.

With a 3 m drop and a 10 cm outlet like those at Topleț, 58 L/s would flow and the water would bring 1.7 kW. With an iron wheel the mill could grind about 31 kg of wheat an hour, within Bârcă's range; with a wooden one, about 19. At the same drop, 140 kg an hour would need an outlet 21–27 cm across, depending on the wheel, more than twice the Topleț pipes. To grind 130 kg of wheat in 24 hours of continuous running, a 4–5 cm outlet would do; a wider one would grind the same in fewer hours.

The physics does not prove which report is right: the outlet, flow and efficiency at Rudăria have never been measured. It does show the scale. With the 10 cm pipes documented in the Banat and the measured drop, a mill grinds tens of kilograms an hour, as Bârcă and the 1983 survey say; 140 kg an hour would need a much thicker jet or a much greater drop. The wheel's efficiency and the grinding energy come from studies of other mills, and the cited sources give no trial at Rudăria with the flow, the drop and the grain weighed together.

408012016051015202530Topleț: 10 cmiron wheelwooden wheel140 kg of grain/h (Mediafax)27–33 kg/h (Bârcă) · 30 kg/h (1983 survey)130 kg of flour in 24 hourswheat milled (kg/h) · outlet diameter (cm) · 3 m drop
The lines show how much wheat a mill could grind at the 3 m drop measured at Roșoanea, for a wooden wheel (peak 22% of the water's power) and an iron one (36%). The dot marks about 31 kg an hour with an iron wheel and a 10 cm outlet like those at Topleț: within Bârcă's 27–33 kg of grain an hour. At the same drop, 140 kg an hour would need an outlet over 20 cm across. The bottom line is the hourly average of the 130 kg of flour reported in 24 hours.

Share a link to the mill

Anyone who opens the link sees the mill as you set it up.

Sources and method

The jet speed is √(2gH) multiplied by 0.97, an assumed coefficient for losses at the outlet; H is the drop from the water level to the chute outlet. The flow is the outlet's area, taken as running full, times that speed, and the water's power referred to the drop is ρgQH. Efficiency is the share of that power that reaches the millstone. For an ideal wheel struck by a jet, power is greatest when the cups move at half the jet's speed and falls to zero when the wheel stands still or runs freely; the model uses that curve, with its peak set by two examples: 22% for a traditional wooden wheel tested with a dynamometer in Uttarakhand, India (2.8 m, 35.7 L/s, 120 rpm), and 36% for an iron wheel (37% calculated for the mill at Besalú, Spain; 35% used by H. Wittenberg for the Das Fontes mill, Portugal). Grinding takes about 20 kWh per tonne of wheat, rounded from Wittenberg's estimate for Das Fontes. The free-running speed in the drawing is illustrative.

  1. Carol Ludovic Lupșiasca, Ioan Ovidiu Bejan, “Morile de apă de la Rudăria” (The water mills of Rudăria), survey of 5 August 1983, table on p. 34. scribd.com A 3 m drop, a wheel 1.20 m across and 120 rpm at Roșoanea mill; 80 rpm at Trăiloanea; 30 kg/h at a mill downstream owned by families from Bănia.
  2. Dumitru Țeicu, Moara de apă din Banat (The water mill in the Banat), Reșița, 2012, pp. 154–190. biblioteca-digitala.ro The 10 cm outlet pipes at two mills in Topleț, another Banat village (p. 190); the 1.5–2.5 m level differences made by the weirs; the 1 m upper millstone at Moara de la Tunel (the Tunnel Mill).
  3. Ana Bârcă, Buletinul Comisiunii Monumentelor Istorice, 2011, pp. 136–141. biblioteca-digitala.ro How a turn is split into day and night or by the hour; 80–100 kg of grain milled in three hours.
  4. Corneliu Bucur, Analele Banatului, ethnography, I (1981), pp. 208–216. biblioteca-digitala.ro The 12-cup wheel; chutes sloping at up to 60 degrees, occasionally more; the full 24-hour turn.
  5. Radu Trifan, Morile de la Rudăria (2025), preview, and his check of the 1874 land register. stiridetimisoara.ro · expressdebanat.ro The 22 surviving mills, all with metal wheels; in the 1874 land register, 29 mills and 22 mill channels.
  6. O. Răuț, “Mori medievale din Banat” (Medieval mills of the Banat), Banatica 12/II (1993), p. 31. biblioteca-digitala.ro Eight mills in the 1769–1772 survey.
  7. Doctoral thesis, University of Petroleum and Energy Studies, India, chapter 3, pp. 59–60, table 3.2. upes.ac.in The traditional wooden runner on a dynamometer: 214 W from 35.7 L/s at 2.8 m, 21.8%.
  8. Toni Pujol et al., “Hydraulic performance of an ancient Spanish watermill”, 2010, p. 394. academia.edu The 37% efficiency calculated for the cast-iron wheel at Besalú.
  9. H. Wittenberg, Historic Tide Mills of Portugal, 2016. researchgate.net The 35% efficiency and about 20 kWh per tonne of wheat at the Das Fontes mill.
  10. Mediafax, report, 27 August 2014. mediafax.ro Up to 140 kg of grain an hour, at full capacity.
  11. Universul Olteniei, 25 September 2019; Vatra MCP, the ensemble's entry. universulolteniei.ro · vatra-mcp.ro 130 kg of flour in 24 hours (130–140 kg in Vatra MCP).
  12. Ministry of Culture, List of historic monuments 2015, Caraș-Severin. cimec.ro Code CS-II-a-A-11112.