Marius Comper

New York · 1910 – 1966

Penn StationThe trains stayed. The rooms came down.

On 29 October 1963 the New York Times reported that the wrecking had begun at Pennsylvania Station. It went on into 1966, and the trains kept running underneath.

Section drawing of Pennsylvania Station's main waiting room, 1915, above the railway level.

The night it opened

Saturday 26 November 1910

Half past nine, a Saturday night

At 9:30 p.m. the doors opened to a crowd of about 2,000. The first regular train through the Hudson River tunnel was not due until 12:02 a.m., already Sunday. On 28 November the Times gave an official estimate: 100,000 visitors, plus perhaps 25,000 passengers.

The drawing

One cut through the room

This is the architects' own drawing: McKim, Mead & White's 1915 section through the main waiting room, 33rd Street at the left edge and 31st at the right, as the plate is lettered. By the railroad's figures the room was 277 by 103 feet (about 84 by 31 metres) and rose 150 feet from floor to roof (46 metres). It stood one level below the street. The platforms lay beneath the concourse.

A room above a railway

A day in the room

Light from above

By day, the railroad's booklet says, light came through “huge semi-circular windows” and skylights. After dark it came from bracket lights, electroliers and incandescent bulbs. A waiting room: a room built for the hours between trains.

The sun, the lamps and the tiny figures are illustration, not a record of any hour.

The illustration in the 1910 booklet, captioned “Main waiting room”. PRR booklet, leaf 26.
The illustration in the 1910 booklet, captioned “Main waiting room”. PRR booklet, leaf 26. Pennsylvania Railroad (1910), Library of Congress / Internet Archive · US public domain. Cropped and compressed.

Below the floor

The railway was already underground

Beneath the waiting room lay the trains: 21 tracks and 11 platforms, the platforms level with the car floors, so passengers boarded without steps. The trains were electric. “Smoke is entirely eliminated,” the booklet promised. Keep your eye on the amber line. It is the one thing here that does not go out.

1963 – 1966

1963

A forecast, a headline, a verdict

In May the critic Ada Louise Huxtable warned in the Times that “the crash of 90-foot columns will be heard this summer.” On 29 October the paper's headline read: “Demolition Starts At Penn Station; Architects Picket.” The next day an unsigned editorial, “Farewell to Penn Station”, closed its lead with this sentence.

Any city gets what it admires, will pay for, and, ultimately, deserves.

The New York Times, 30 October 1963, unsigned editorial

The stone comes down in random order. That is illustration: the dissolve does not reconstruct the order of the work.

1964 – 1965

Where the stone went

On 9 October 1964 the Times reported that pieces of the station's granite columns had been dumped in the Secaucus Meadows, in New Jersey. One granite eagle, from the Long Island Rail Road entrance, got a better end. A Latin teacher, Samuel A. Goldberg, had written to the railroad to ask for it. On 15 May 1965 the three-ton bird was dedicated in Hicksville, before residents, schoolchildren and a 40-member band. Some wore sheets as togas.

1966

Above and below

On 14 July 1966 the Times found two men at the Seventh Avenue entrance. Crane operator John Tarallo sat in a cab 60 feet up, lifting statuary. Below him, in the new station, baggage handler Frederick C. MacFadden pushed a cart of suitcases and golf bags through the crowd. The last wall had yet to come down.

On 29 August, at 11:50 in the morning, a 1½-ton slab of granite fell 35 feet while being taken off the façade. It killed Ralph De Rosa, a construction worker of 32, the paper reported, citing police and witnesses.

The railway kept working beneath them. The amber line did not go out.

Penn Station demolition, June 1966.
Penn Station demolition, June 1966. Hikki Nagasaki / USA Rail Guide · Public domain, by author’s release. Resized and compressed.

What is down there now

Spring 1968 – now

What the stone made room for

Amtrak's history of the station says it was demolished to make way for Madison Square Garden. Then it says this:

While the new buildings rose above the underground concourses, the trains continued to run, and the present passenger areas were largely completed by spring 1968.

Amtrak, Great American Stations, New York Penn Station, read 5 October 2026
Penn Station interior, 20 May 2024.
Penn Station interior, 20 May 2024. Famartin · CC BY-SA 4.0. Resized and compressed. Adapted image retains this licence.

2 March 2023

Eighteen feet

The Long Island Rail Road's 33rd Street concourse was widened from 30 to 57 feet and its ceiling raised to 18 feet; the MTA called the work substantially complete on 2 March 2023. The old waiting room rose 150 feet. The drawing sets the two heights side by side and nothing more: they are different spaces, and no source used here places one floor against the other.

Two heights, drawn to each other. They do not mark where either space stood.

Renovated LIRR concourse, 13 June 2023.
Renovated LIRR concourse, 13 June 2023. MTA · CC BY 2.0. Resized and compressed.

1 January 2021

A new hall across Eighth Avenue

Moynihan Train Hall began serving trains on 1 January 2021. It fills the old Farley Post Office, between Eighth and Ninth Avenues, across Eighth Avenue from Penn Station. It is a separate building and does not appear in this drawing.

Moynihan Train Hall, 30 June 2022, across Eighth Avenue.
Moynihan Train Hall, 30 June 2022, across Eighth Avenue. Zheng Zhou · CC BY-SA 4.0. Resized and compressed. Adapted image retains this licence.

What a law could do

1962 – 1965

A commission, then a law

On 21 April 1962 Mayor Wagner appointed a 12-member Landmarks Preservation Commission, with the station still standing. The Times reported it the next day, in a headline that also noted architects' opposition to the razing of Penn Station. Demolition was reported under way by October 1963, with architects picketing. On 19 April 1965, with the wrecking in its second year, Wagner signed the city's landmarks bill.

The law did not save Penn Station.

1967 – 1978

A different terminal

Grand Central Terminal was designated a landmark on 2 August 1967, and the Board of Estimate confirmed it on 21 September. When its owner, Penn Central, proposed a tower above the terminal, the dispute reached the Supreme Court. On 26 June 1978 the Court upheld the city's law as applied to Grand Central. The ruling concerns one terminal, not every old building. In that dispute the law held; at Penn Station, the picket line had not stopped the wrecking.

Four different events: a protest, a law, a designation, a judgment.

Today

21 tracks

In 1910 the railroad's booklet counted 21 tracks under the waiting room. Amtrak's page on Penn Station lists 21 today; the counts are not like for like. Take a Long Island train from Penn now and you may wait in the widened concourse, under an 18-foot ceiling. Above these platforms once stood a room 150 feet high. The rooms could be taken away. The trains kept running.

Share

The record

The story in seven lines, then the drawings, then the sources.

  1. 26 November 1910. Doors open at 9:30 p.m.; the first regular tunnel train is timed for 12:02 a.m. on Sunday, 27 November.
  2. 1910. The main waiting room is 277 by 103 feet and 150 feet to the roof, by the railroad's figures; the platforms lie below, level with the car floors.
  3. 29 October 1963. The Times: demolition starts, architects picket.
  4. 1964 – 1965. Granite columns in the Secaucus Meadows; one eagle dedicated at Hicksville.
  5. July – August 1966. Last façade stripped; a baggage cart in the new station below; a worker killed by a falling slab.
  6. 1968 – 2023. Present passenger areas largely complete by spring 1968; Moynihan Train Hall opens on 1 January 2021; LIRR concourse substantially complete on 2 March 2023.
  7. 1962 – 1978. Commission, landmarks law, Grand Central designated, Supreme Court judgment.

The drawings

Original block plan, plate 300.
Original block plan, plate 300. McKim, Mead & White (1915), University of Notre Dame · US public domain. Resized and compressed.
Section through the waiting room, plate 302.
Section through the waiting room, plate 302. McKim, Mead & White (1915), University of Notre Dame · US public domain. Resized and compressed.

The stage is plate 302 of McKim, Mead & White’s 1915 monograph, a section through the main waiting room, redrawn here as ink on paper. Dimensions come from the 1910 railroad booklet; none is measured off the drawing. The overlays are illustrations, not records: the light in the windows and its movement through the day, the tiny figures, the order in which the stone dissolves, the sliding lamps on the railway line (they show a railway at work, not a timetable), and the two bars of the height comparison, which are drawn to each other and not to the plate. The photographs are dated evidence, not exact overlays.