Animals from memoryROEN

Interactive test ยท three minutes

How many animals can you name in three minutes?

Type an animal and press Enter, then the next, as fast as you can. The animals do not come at random: they come in groups, like bushes of berries, and the mind moves on at about the moment a new animal starts to cost too much time. At the end you see the path your memory took, next to the 527 adults of a study published in 2023.

3:00

Any animal: pets, wild ones, birds, fish, insects. One at a time, then Enter. The word fades after Enter, as in the study, so it does not prompt the next one.

What you type stays in this tab. The page sends nothing anywhere.

Your path

The map of your path appears here after the three minutes.

Memory searches in groups

When people name animals, they come in bursts: dog, cat, hamster, parrot; then a pause, then lion, zebra, giraffe. In the study, the second animal in a group came 3.3 seconds after the first, on average. The jump to a new group cost 5.9 seconds.

Hills and colleagues showed that groups run dry: the longer you stay in one, the harder each new animal comes, because the handiest ones are already said. The question is when it pays to leave.

The rule animals leave by

In 1976 the ecologist Eric Charnov worked out when an animal should leave a feeding patch that is running out, to gather the most food per hour: when the rate at which the patch still yields food falls to the average rate for the whole environment, counting the travel between patches. It is called the marginal value theorem. Studies of birds and bumblebees have found them leaving patches roughly when the rule predicts.

The curve shows how many animals a group yields on average after a given time in it. The dotted line starts from the cost of jumping to a new group; where it touches the curve is the leaving moment that brings the most animals per minute. The dot is the best leaving moment; the red vertical line is how long people actually stayed.

In 2012 Thomas Hills, Michael Jones and Peter Todd showed that people naming animals seem to follow the same rule inside memory. In 2023 Jeffrey Zemla, Diane Gooding and Joseph Austerweil repeated the test with 527 adults in the United States, aged 25 to 69, who typed animals for three minutes, three times. The younger three quarters stayed in a group for 7.03 seconds on average; for their curve, the rule puts the best moment to leave at 6.96 seconds. The oldest quarter, aged 44 and over, stayed 8.09 seconds, and their best moment was 7.96. The calculation here, rebuilt from their files, gives the same figures.

Which animals people name

The first animal named was the dog in 32% of first lists and the cat in 29%. In three minutes, on the first try, half the people named at least 32 animals, and 15 in the first minute. Together they named 488 different animals, 128 of them by a single person.

The animals named most often on the first try, out of 527 listscat96%dog96%lion84%tiger77%elephant70%bear66%horse63%cow62%giraffe60%pig57%monkey55%snake53%deer52%mouse50%zebra50%
The animals named most often on the first try, out of 527 lists.

What the page cannot tell

Method

Sources