mariuscomper.uk
English

A life between Istanbul, Iași and Moscow · 1673–1723

The prince who wrote down the Turks' music

Two decades at Tsargrad, prince a single year at Iași, beaten on the Prut and exiled in Russia: Dimitrie Cantemir wrote the books from which Europe learned the Turks' music, the history of the Ottoman Empire, and the geography of Moldavia.

A motif after his notation: eight letter-notes right to left, with the durations beneath; the total, 28 beats, is the treatise's Devr-i kebir usul.
The map of Cantemir's life, 1673–1723

Twenty to one

201

So many years at Tsargrad for each year of rule at Iași: 1688 – 1691 and 1693 – 1710 against 1710 – 1711.

The map of the life and the books SilișteniConstantinopleConstantinopleIașiStănileștiStănileștiMoscowSt PetersburgDmitrovkaIașiBerlinLondonDmitrovka LutskAzovParis

his roadthe road of the books and the bones

From Silișteni to Dmitrovka, from Iași to London

From Silișteni to Tsargrad, from Iași to Stănilești and on to Moscow: a life that crossed three empires, and after death carried its books and bones once more through Europe, to London and back to Iași.

The solid line is his road; the dashed line, the books' and the bones'. Distances are great-circle arcs between approximate waypoints, rounded to the hundred.

Chapter I

The hostage who learned

1688 – 1710 · the making

Years
1688 – 1710
Road on the map
600 kmgreat-circle, rounded
Signature work
The Divan (Iași, 1698)

On 26 October 1673, at Silișteni, in Moldavia's Lower Country, Dimitrie Cantemir was born, son of Constantin Cantemir, who could not read but would be enthroned in 1685, and of Ana Bantăș. His father schooled his sons thoroughly: from childhood Dimitrie learned Greek and Latin.

His home at Constantinople was the family palace in the Phanar, its windows on the Golden Horn. He lived in the city from 1688 to 1691 and again from 1693 to 1710, hostage and envoy of his father, then of his brother Antioch. At the Patriarchate's Greek Academy he learned Turkish and Ottoman history; meanwhile, he composed music.

Dimitrie Cantemir in armour, with mace and books: engraving from the Descriptio Moldaviae, 1716. Engraving from the Descriptio Moldaviae, 1716 · Wikimedia Commons

Between one embassy and the next, he wrote: the Divan (Iași, 1698), in Romanian and Greek, and the Istoria ieroglifică (1705), a coded political satire counted as the first novel in Romanian. And in March 1693, on his father's death, he took the throne for three weeks, until the Porte deposed him for Constantin Duca.

Meanwhile: In 1697 he was in the Ottoman camp, with the Moldavian troops, when Eugene of Savoy destroyed the sultan's army at Senta.

Chapter II

A year on the throne

1710 – 1711 · the reign

Years
1710 – 1711
Road on the map
800 kmgreat-circle, rounded
Signature work
Treaty of Lutsk (13 Apr 1711)

On 13 April 1711, at Lutsk, far from the Porte's eyes, the treaty putting Moldavia under Russia's protection was signed in secret. He had written the 17-article text himself, from end to end; for Moldavia, Metropolitan Ghedeon signed. A year earlier the Porte had named him prince of Moldavia, and he believed the Ottoman Empire was collapsing and gambled everything on Peter the Great.

In early summer the armies joined near Iași: Peter had entered Moldavia and united his army with Cantemir's, and together they marched down toward the Prut. That same spring, at Satu Mare, the peace of 29 April ending Rákóczi's uprising had been sealed: eastern Europe was reshuffling every alliance at once.

Iași, the capital of Moldavia: a period view of the city where Cantemir reigned a single year. Period view, unknown artist · Wikimedia Commons

At Stănilești, on 18–22 July 1711, the Christian army was encircled on the bank of the Prut, without supplies and without a way out. The Peace of the Prut humiliated Peter: Russia abandoned Azov, and Cantemir lost his throne for good, fleeing into exile with his boyars and troops, the chronicler Ion Neculce among them.

What Lutsk said, in 17 articles

In short: Moldavia stayed the Cantemirs', under Russia's shield, behind its old borders.

  • a hereditary throne for the Cantemirs and no Russian meddling inside the country: all power stays with the lord, after the old custom
  • Moldavia's old borders: Dniester, Kamianets, Bender, Budjak, Danube
  • protection kept even after peace: Peter will not leave Moldavia under the Porte
  • all of it secret, under oath, until the Russian armies enter the country

Meanwhile: Two years earlier, Peter had crushed Charles XII at Poltava (1709), the victory that convinced Cantemir he was betting on the winning horse.

Chapter III

The exile who wrote

1711 – 1723 · exile

Years
1711 – 1723
Road on the map
2,700 kmgreat-circle, rounded
Signature work
Descriptio Moldaviae (1714)

At Dmitrovka, near Oryol, the exile was given an estate with a name that said everything: Bogorodskoye, “Black Mud”. In 1712 Peter gave it to him together with the title of knyaz, and Emperor Charles VI made him a prince of the Empire: Peter had refused to hand his ally to the victorious Turks. He settled there with a train of boyars and wrote for twelve years almost without pause.

In 1714 the Berlin Academy admitted him among its members and asked him for a description of Moldavia: thus were born the Descriptio Moldaviae and the country's first true map. In exile too he wrote the History of the Growth and Decay of the Othman Empire and, between 1719 and 1722, the Hronicul, the first critical history of the Romanians as a whole.

St Petersburg in the exile years: Alexei Zubov's panorama. Cantemir lived between Moscow and the new capital. Alexei Zubov, panorama · Wikimedia Commons
Another period portrait, anonymous engraving: Cantemir in a fur mantle, with cuirass. Anonymous engraving (CC BY-SA 4.0) · Wikimedia Commons

In 1722, at St Petersburg, his Systema of the Turkish religion came off the press, in Russian; and the manifesto with which Peter opened the Persian war, on 15 July 1722, was drafted by him too. He died at Dmitrovka on 21 August 1723.

Meanwhile: In the year of his death, in Scotland, Adam Smith was born.

Chapter IV

The book of music

c.1700 – 1705 · the notation

Years
c.1700 – 1705
Road on the map
no road on the map
Signature work
The Edvar (c.1700)

A page of the Edvar, the Book of the Science of Music in Letters, reads right to left: letter-notes on the first line, rhythm signs on the second. It is Ottoman music theory written by a practitioner: an alphabet in which the letters are notes and the durations signs beneath. Written at Tsargrad around 1700, it was dedicated later to Sultan Ahmed III, who came to the throne in 1703.

Between its covers stand over 350 instrumental pieces (318 peshrevs and 36 saz semais), gathered and notated by him, not composed; his own compositions, a few dozen, are still played in the Turkish classical repertoire. The autograph original is kept at the Turcology Institute in Istanbul.

The Ottoman tanbur with its fret correspondences, after Cantemir's drawing in the treatise: the instrument for which he invented the notation. Drawing from the music treatise, c.1700 · Wikimedia Commons

The instrument he invented the notation for is the long-necked tanbur: the eight principal frets, from the bottom of the neck up, under the names he gave them, each with its duration sign beneath. The sounds are illustrative, after the standard modern correspondences.

The tanbur neck

The eight principal frets, from the bottom of the neck up, under the names from his drawing. Below them, the whole scale played through.

  1. Yegâh
  2. Irâk
  3. Dügâh
  4. Çargâh
  5. Hüseynî
  6. Gerdâniye
  7. Tiz Segâh
  8. Tiz Nevâ

Pitches are illustrative, after the standard modern correspondences (the Arel-Ezgi system).

The rhythm numerals

Under each letter, the duration is written in the signs 1–4: 1 is the time unit, 2 its double, 3 its triple, 4 its quadruple. Three tempo marks (slow, moderate, fast) match Andante, Moderato and Allegro. The treatise's example peshrev is in makam Zengûle, on usul Devr-i kebir, at 28 beats to the cycle.

1 = ♪

Meanwhile: In 1703, the year Ahmed III came to the throne and Peter laid the first stone of St Petersburg.

Chapter V

The books Europe read

1714 – 1935 · posterity

Years
1714 – 1935
Road on the map
2,900 kmgreat-circle, rounded
Signature work
History of the Othman Empire (London, 1734)

The commission came from Berlin: a description of Moldavia, in Latin. The Descriptio Moldaviae, written in 1714, circulated in manuscript for decades: first in German, in a geography magazine (1769) and in book form (1771). The manuscript map of c.1714, the first true map of Moldavia, was printed in the Netherlands in 1737, with the cartouche “Principatus Moldaviae nova & accurata descriptio, delineante Principe Demetrio Cantemirio”.

His son Antioch took the manuscript to London: the History of the Growth and Decay of the Othman Empire was printed first in English (1734–1735), then in French and German, and remained into the mid-nineteenth century the book of record on the Ottoman Empire.

Principatus Moldaviae nova & accurata descriptio: the map of Moldavia after Cantemir's manuscript (c.1714), printed in the Netherlands in 1737. The first true map of the country. After Dimitrie Cantemir, manuscript c.1714, printed 1737 · BnF Gallica · Wikimedia Commons
The map's cartouche: “Principatus Moldaviae nova & accurata descriptio, delineante Principe Demetrio Cantemirio”, that is, “a new and accurate description of the Principality of Moldavia, delineated by Prince Demetrius Cantemir”. Detail from the scan above. Detail from the map above · BnF Gallica · Wikimedia Commons

At Dmitrovka, between 1719 and 1722, he wrote the Hronicul, which argued the Latin origin of the language and the Roman origin of the people. His son Antioch (1708–1744), ambassador in London and Paris, friend of Voltaire and Montesquieu, would be called the father of Russian poetry. And in the autumn of 1935, the prince's bones returned to Iași, to the Three Hierarchs church, after more than two centuries.

The noblest wine grows at Cotnari, on a great hill[...] we dare affirm it finer and nobler than all the other wines of Europe, Tokay itself not excepted[...] if it be kept shut three years[...] it catches fire like spirits[...] it is green, and the older it grows, the greener.

Descriptio Moldaviae, our translation from the Latin

The history of the Growth and Decay of the Othman empire was translated into English from the Latin MS. of Demetrius Cantemir, prince of Moldavia (London, 1734, in folio). The author is guilty of strange blunders in Oriental history; but he was conversant with the language, the annals, and institutions of the Turks.

Edward Gibbon, Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, ch. 64, n. 41

Meanwhile: As Gibbon wrote The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, he cited Cantemir in the notes.

1711: what would you have done?

Four crossroads from the year that decided his life. Choose, then learn what he chose.

The campaign tent, summer 1711

  1. 1

    April 1711: do you sign?

    April 1711. Peter's envoys lay Russia's protection on the table: a hereditary throne for your house, no meddling in the country, the old borders. The price: war with the Porte, now.

    What happened

    He signed: at Lutsk, on 13 April 1711, in secret and under oath. He had written the 17-article text himself; for Moldavia, Metropolitan Ghedeon signed.

  2. 2

    Summer: the tsar at the gates

    In early summer 1711 Peter enters Moldavia and camps near Iași. The treaty is secret; the Porte still thinks you loyal. What do you do?

    What happened

    He received him: Peter joined his army with Cantemir's near Iași, in early summer 1711, and together they marched down toward the Prut.

  3. 3

    July: encircled on the Prut

    18–22 July, Stănilești: encircled on the Prut, no supplies, the vizier ahead. Peter wants to treat. What do you choose?

    What happened

    A peace humiliating for Russia: on the Prut, Peter abandoned Azov to get his army out of the encirclement. Cantemir lost his throne for good.

  4. 4

    After peace: pardon or exile?

    Peace is signed without you. The Porte has set another prince in Iași. Do you take your boyars and remaining troops and ride north, or kneel at Tsargrad?

    What happened

    He left. Peter had given him the Bogorodskoye estate and the title of knyaz, Charles VI had made him a prince of the Empire. Twelve years of writing followed, with Ion Neculce among his companions.

The life in numbers

Six numbers hold the whole life together: the years, the weeks, the articles, the pieces, the languages, the return.

354

pieces notated: 318 peshrevs + 36 saz semais

  • 318 peshrevs
  • 36 saz semais

About nine pieces saved for each one he composed himself.

49
years of life, 1673–1723
3
weeks of the first reign, 1693
17
articles at Lutsk, written by him
354
pieces notated: 318 peshrevs + 36 saz semais
11
languages spoken and written
1935
the bones return to Iași
The arms, 1734. Dimitrie Cantemir's arms, 1734 · Wikimedia Commons

What didn't happen

  1. He composed 350 pieces.

    He gathered and notated over 350 (318 peshrevs and 36 saz semais), but composed a few dozen himself. The gathering is the feat: over 350 pieces saved in his letters.

  2. Istoria ieroglifică is the first Romanian novel.

    Written at Tsargrad in 1705, it is a coded political satire: Călinescu called it “a Romanian Roman de Renard with polemical aims” (our translation), fed by the Cantemir–Brâncoveanu rivalry. The first novel, yes; a story for the story's sake, no.

  3. He was a failed prince.

    His reign lasted, all told, a year and three weeks. But the Stănilești defeat took his throne and gave him posterity: without exile there would have been no Descriptio, no London History, no Gibbon footnote. He matters not for what he reigned but for what he wrote after losing.

Sources and method

Every date and figure on this page is checked against at least one open source, cited below; Latin passages are the editors' translations, with the original in view.

Distances measure great-circle arcs between approximate waypoints and round to the hundred: the order of magnitude, not the topography. The sounds in the music section are illustrative.

Quotations in old Romanian keep the spelling of the cited edition; the editors' omissions are marked with square brackets.

Images