Paris Aeronautical Salon, October 1910 · 50 hp
Coandă-1910 how much thrust 50 hp could give
The brochure with which the Romanian engineer Henri Coandă presented his aircraft at the 1910 Paris Salon reported that trials had given "about 220 kg of thrust for 50 hp". For any jet of air made from a given power, physics sets an ideal limit, which depends on the size of the exit. For a 50 cm exit, the size of the propulsion unit, the ideal limit is 112 kgf. Adjust the exit diameter and the power to see which thrust figures are possible.
According to the brochure, the unit was 50 cm across and 1.10 m deep; the net exit area and the power reaching the compressor are not published.
The aircraft without a propeller
At the Paris Aeronautical Salon in October 1910, Henri Coandă showed a biplane without a propeller. In front, a 50 hp Clerget engine drove, through step-up gearing, a compressor mounted in a casing, which Coandă called a "turbo-propulseur": air was drawn in at the front and discharged at the rear through a conical diffuser. According to the brochure, the unit was 50 cm across and 1.10 m deep and the aircraft weighed 420 kg ready for flight; the brochure reported that trials had given "about 220 kg of thrust for 50 hp".
Other writers have discussed its thrust. Walter Boyne gave in 2006 an estimated thrust of 500 pounds-force, about 227 kgf. Gérard Hartmann, in his dossier on the Clément-Bayard works, gives a static thrust of 17 kgf at 4,000 turbine rpm and notes that Coandă hoped for 24 kgf in flight. Accounts differ on whether the aircraft flew in 1910; this page is only about static thrust.
The limit
Any device that makes a jet of air from a given power has a limit. To push harder it must throw more air or throw it faster; for a fixed exit area, the power required rises with the cube of the jet speed. At 50 hp, a 50 cm exit gives an ideal limit of 112 kgf. Using the peak figure of merit of 0.81 that NASA measured for a ducted propeller gives an estimated thrust of 98 kgf.
At an effective 50 cm exit, 220 kgf exceeds the ideal limit for 50 hp: it would have needed, even with no losses, about 137 hp. With 50 hp, the exit would have had to be at least 1.37 m across in the ideal case, or 1.69 m at a figure of merit of 0.81. The brochure, though, gives neither the net exit area nor the trial conditions, so the reported result for the machine remains unverified. Hartmann's 17 kgf fits under the limit: it corresponds to a figure of merit of about 0.06, that is 15% of the ideal thrust, assuming 50 hp at the compressor and a 50 cm exit.
The ducted propeller at Ames
The calculation was compared with a 7-foot (2.13 m) ducted propeller tested in the 40-by-80-foot wind tunnel at Ames and described in a 1967 NASA report, at 1,250 hp and with a net exit area of 44.08 square feet. With 90% of the power, as the report does, the formula gives a static thrust of 5,434 pounds-force; the report's theoretical curve gives about 5,390. The measured thrust, read from the report's chart to within about 50 pounds-force, is about 5,060, which means a figure of merit of 0.81, in line with NASA's reported peak of 81%.
The fan laws give an example, for a fixed geometry and similar flow: thrust rises with the square of the speed and the power needed with its cube. If at 4,000 rpm the compressor took all 50 hp and gave Hartmann's 17 kgf, at 7,000 rpm it would have given about 52 kgf but needed some 270 hp. The Coandă effect is on another page.
Sources and method
A steady, uniform jet leaving through a net area A at speed v, at the surrounding air pressure, gives a static thrust ρAv² and needs at least the power ρAv³/2; hence the ideal thrust is the cube root of 4ρAP², with P the shaft power reaching the propulsor. The figure of merit is the ratio of the theoretical minimum power to the actual power needed for the same thrust; NASA defines it exactly this way. The calculation uses sea-level air density, 1.225 kg/m³, and 1 hp = 745.7 W (with metric horsepower, 735.5 W, the results fall by about 1%). The figure of merit of 0.81 is the one measured on NASA's ducted propeller, used here only as a comparison: a centrifugal compressor is not a ducted propeller. The drawing of the machine is schematic.
- Coandă's brochure for the 1910 Salon, pp. 1, 6–7. jet100.com Clerget 50 hp; the 50 cm × 1.10 m unit with a conical diffuser; 420 kg; "Les essais ont donné... 220 k. environ de traction pour 50 HP".
- Gérard Hartmann, Clément-Bayard, sans peur et sans reproche, pp. 21–22. hydroretro.net Static thrust of 17 kgf at 4,000 rpm; Coandă hoped for 24 kgf in flight; Hartmann estimated the compressor would have needed over 7,000 rpm.
- K. W. Mort, B. Gamse, A Wind-Tunnel Investigation of a 7-Foot-Diameter Ducted Propeller, NASA TN D-4142, August 1967. ntrs.nasa.gov The definition of the figure of merit, the 81% peak, the net exit area, figure 11.
- Walter J. Boyne, Air Force Magazine, January 2006, p. 72. airandspaceforces.com An estimated thrust of 500 pounds-force.
- Flight, 29 October 1910, pp. 881–883. archive.org The turbine "of remarkably small proportions" for the size of the aircraft.