Chapter 6 · WatersLesson 6.6Humanities track
People and the hydrosphere: how fertilisers, plastic and dams on land change the sea
How could fertilisers spread on fields in Germany, Hungary or Romania suffocate life on the floor of the Black Sea?
Before you read: what do you think?
Suppose each litre of Danube water contains just 2 milligrams of nitrogen. How much nitrogen would the river carry into the sea in a single day?
See the answer
About 1,100 tonnes. At the entrance to the Delta, the Danube carries 6,437,000 litres of water every second. A concentration that seems tiny becomes a huge quantity at the flow rate of a great river.
In the summer of 1973, researchers found an area of 3,500 square kilometres in the north-western Black Sea where the water near the bottom had run out of oxygen. Five years later, in 1978, the dead zone had reached 30,000 square kilometres. By 1989, thousands of tonnes of shellfish and other bottom-dwelling creatures had died there. The cause lay on land, sometimes more than a thousand kilometres from the coast.
A river carries to the sea everything it receives from the land
What is thrown into a stream in the Black Forest or the Carpathians can reach the Black Sea. A river collects water from its entire drainage basin, along with everything the water washes away or picks up on its journey: soil, salts, fertilisers, wastewater and rubbish. That is why what happens on land largely determines the health of a sea.
For the curious
The Danube basin covers 801,463 square kilometres across 19 countries.
Too much food: eutrophication
In fields, fertilisers feed crops. Washed into rivers by rain, they feed algae. Nitrogen and phosphorus are nutrients: food for plants. They enter rivers in fertilisers washed from fields by rain, in wastewater from towns and farms, and in detergents. In small amounts they support aquatic life. In large amounts they cause eutrophication: microscopic algae multiply explosively and the water turns green and cloudy.
Algae are short-lived. When they die, they sink to the bottom, where bacteria break them down and consume oxygen from the water. In summer, warm surface water sits above the colder water and does not mix with it, so oxygen no longer reaches the bottom. A lack of oxygen is called hypoxia. Creatures that cannot escape, such as shellfish, die, and the place becomes a dead zone.
For the curious
Between 1960 and 1990, the amount of nitrogen from human activities entering the waters of the Danube basin rose from about 444,000 to 844,000 tonnes per year, and phosphorus from 50,000 to 113,000 tonnes per year.
Plastic does not break down on the way
Plastic thrown onto riverbanks or released from factories floats downstream and breaks into ever smaller pieces, called microplastics. In a study on the Danube in Austria in 2010 and 2012, nets caught more pieces of plastic than fish larvae on average. From these samples, the authors estimated that the river would carry 4.2 tonnes of plastic into the Black Sea each day.
For the curious
Over a year, the estimate comes to more than 1,500 tonnes of plastic. The figure is extrapolated from samples taken in Austria, not measured at the river mouth.
Dams trap sediment, leaving beaches short of sand
A river also carries sediment towards the sea: silt, sand and gravel. Deltas and beaches form from it. In a reservoir, water slows down and sediment settles on the bottom. Before the large dams and embankments, the Danube brought about 60 million tonnes of suspended sediment into the Delta each year and carried about 40 million tonnes into the sea. Today around 20 million tonnes reach the Delta, and 15 million reach the sea.
Waves and currents still take sand from the shore, but the river replaces less of it. The shoreline retreats: the process is called coastal erosion.
Worked example
From concentration to tonnes per day
Concentration shows how much of a substance is in a litre of water. Load shows how much of that substance a river carries in one second. It is found by multiplying flow rate by concentration.
At the entrance to the Delta, the Danube has an average flow rate of 6,437 m³/s, or 6,437,000 litres per second. At a concentration of 2 milligrams of nitrogen per litre (a value chosen for the calculation), the load is 6,437,000 × 2 = 12,874,000 milligrams per second, or nearly 12.9 kg of nitrogen every second.
In one day, with 86,400 seconds, the result is 12.9 × 86,400 ≈ 1,110,000 kg, or about 1,100 tonnes of nitrogen. A concentration that seems tiny becomes a huge quantity at the flow rate of a great river.
In Romania
The dead zone off the Delta and shrinking beaches
The north-western Black Sea, off the mouths of the Danube, Dniester and Dnipro, is a shallow shelf of about 50,000 square kilometres. The dead zone appeared here in the 1970s and 1980s. At the same time, an 11,000-square-kilometre field of red algae, home to more than a hundred invertebrate species, almost entirely disappeared. After 1990, agriculture and industry in the region used far less fertiliser, and the sea began to recover. Recovery is partial: hypoxia still occurs in some summers because organic matter accumulated in the mud on the bottom continues to consume oxygen for many years.
After the Iron Gates I and II dams were built, the amount of sediment carried into the sea by the Danube fell by roughly half. Beaches on the southern Romanian coast have narrowed; another cause is ports, which block the sand carried along the shore by currents. The Dobrogea-Litoral Water Basin Administration restores the beaches by adding sand and reinforcing cliffs.
In brief
- A river carries to the sea everything it receives from its drainage basin, so the state of the sea depends on what happens on land.
- Eutrophication is the enrichment of water with nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus), followed by an explosive growth of algae.
- The breakdown of dead algae consumes oxygen near the bottom; a lack of oxygen is called hypoxia and produces dead zones.
- The dead zone in the north-western Black Sea grew from 3,500 square kilometres in 1973 to 30,000 in 1978; after 1990 the sea partially recovered.
- Dams trap sediment: the Danube carries around 15 million tonnes into the sea each year, compared with about 40 million before, and beaches are eroding.
- Plastic reaches the sea through rivers: a 2014 estimate puts the Danube figure at 4.2 tonnes per day.
Common mistakes
WrongThe oxygen-free water in the depths of the Black Sea is a result of pollution.
RightThe oxygen-free layer below 100–200 m is natural and thousands of years old: it exists because the waters of the sea do not mix. Nutrient pollution caused a separate problem, summer hypoxia on the shallow north-western shelf.
WrongNutrients are poisons.
RightNitrogen and phosphorus are food for plants and are essential to life. It is the excess that causes harm, leading to eutrophication.
WrongA low concentration means a small quantity of pollutant.
RightThe quantity carried is the flow rate multiplied by the concentration. At the Danube’s flow rate, 2 mg per litre means more than a thousand tonnes per day.
Test yourself
Six questions. For the first five you see the explanation at once, with the paragraph of the lesson that supports it; for the ones with a written answer you compare with a good answer.
What is eutrophication?
Answer
c) The enrichment of water with nutrients and explosive growth of algae. Eutrophication starts with too much nitrogen and phosphorus. Nutrients are food for algae.
Why does oxygen disappear from near the bottom in eutrophic water?
Answer
a) Because bacteria breaking down dead algae consume it. Living algae produce oxygen at the surface. Oxygen is consumed at the bottom as dead algae break down, and the layered water does not bring oxygen down from above.
How large was the dead zone in the north-western Black Sea in 1978?
Answer
d) 30,000 square kilometres. It covered 3,500 square kilometres in 1973, when it first appeared. The whole north-western shelf covers 50,000 square kilometres, and the red algae field covered 11,000.
Why do beaches erode after dams are built on a river?
Answer
b) Because sediment remains in reservoirs. The sea takes sand from the shore as before, but the river replaces less of it because sediment has settled in reservoirs.
A river has a flow rate of 10 m³/s and its water contains 2 mg of nitrogen per litre. How many grams of nitrogen does the river carry each second?
g/sAnswer
20 g/s. 10 m³/s means 10,000 litres per second. 10,000 × 2 mg = 20,000 mg = 20 g every second.
A lowland lake, surrounded by farmland and a village without a sewer system, turns green every summer, and dead fish appear in August. Explain the chain of causes and propose two measures.
A good answer
Rain washes fertilisers off the fields, and wastewater from the village enters the lake: the water receives too much nitrogen and phosphorus. Algae multiply explosively and the water turns green, so the lake is eutrophic. Bacteria break down the dead algae and consume oxygen; in summer, hypoxia develops in the warm, still water and fish die. Measures: a sewer system and wastewater treatment plant for the village; less fertiliser and a strip of grass or reeds between the field and the lake to trap nutrients.
A complete answer follows the chain from nutrients to algae to decomposition to oxygen shortage and proposes measures that stop nutrients at their source.
Terms
- nutrients
- Substances that feed plants and algae, chiefly compounds of nitrogen and phosphorus.
- eutrophication
- The enrichment of water with nutrients, leading to explosive growth of algae and then a decline in oxygen.
- hypoxia
- A shortage of dissolved oxygen in water, at a level at which many organisms can no longer live.
- sediment
- Silt, sand and gravel carried and deposited by flowing water.
- coastal erosion
- The retreat of the shoreline when waves and currents remove more sand than is replaced.
- microplastics
- Pieces of plastic smaller than 5 mm, produced by the breaking up of larger objects or manufactured at that size.
Sources and link to the programme
- Mee, Friedrich, Gomoiu (2005) – Restoring the Black Sea in times of uncertainty, Oceanography 18(2) – dead zone: 3,500 km² in 1973, 30,000 km² in 1978; north-western shelf, about 50,000 km²; Phyllophora red algae field, 11,000 km², with about 118 invertebrate species; nitrogen (444 → 844 kt/year) and phosphorus (50 → 113 kt/year) emissions from the Danube basin, 1960 and 1990; declining inputs after 1990 and signs of recovery
- Capet, Beckers, Grégoire (2013) – Drivers, mechanisms and long-term variability of seasonal hypoxia on the Black Sea northwestern shelf, Biogeosciences 10 – seasonal hypoxia persists; recovery after 1995 was overestimated; organic matter in sediment delays recovery (about 9 years)
- ICPDR – Danube River Basin (pagină arhivată la IW:LEARN) – Danube basin: 801,463 km², 19 countries; the Danube as the main source of nutrients for the Black Sea
- Lechner ș.a. (2014) – The Danube so colourful: a potpourri of plastic litter outnumbers fish larvae in Europe's second largest river, Environmental Pollution 188 (rezumat în FAO AGRIS) – more plastic than fish larvae in samples from the Austrian Danube (2010, 2012); estimate of 4.2 tonnes of plastic per day towards the Black Sea
- NOAA – What are microplastics? – microplastics: pieces of plastic smaller than 5 mm
- Haimann ș.a. (2022) – Sediment and its management: transnational tasks (proiectul DanubeSediment), Danube News 45 – suspended sediment: historically about 60 million t/year towards the Delta and 40 million t/year towards the sea, today about 20 and 15 million t/year (a decline of up to 60%)
- Geo-Eco-Marina, supliment 2008 – studiu despre eroziunea litoralului românesc, sectorul Midia – Vama Veche – after the Iron Gates I and II dams, sediment carried by the Danube into the sea fell by half, and beach erosion intensified
- Banca Europeană de Investiții – Ce este eroziunea costieră și cum o rezolvă România – erosion of beaches on the southern Romanian coast caused by ports and Danube dams; Dobrogea-Litoral Water Basin Administration works: adding sand, protecting cliffs
- Administrația Națională „Apele Române” – Planul de management al riscului la inundații, ciclul II, fluviul Dunărea – average flow rate of the Danube at Ceatal Izmail, 6,437 m³/s, used in the worked example
From the programme: “The relationship between the hydrosphere and the other geospheres” (specialisation curriculum, humanities track). Programme competences covered: 1.4, 2.3, 4.5, 5.3.