mariuscomper.ukRomână

A SET TABLE, TWO THOUSAND YEARS

You eat Latin every day

Sit at a Romanian table and the plainest words carry traces of spoken Latin: masă, pâine, sare, vin, lingură and a mânca are inheritances, not late learned borrowings. The forms changed; the filiation is solid. On which bank of the Danube the communities that carried them through the thinly documented centuries lived is a separate historical question.

Set the table

100
denarii — the legal wheat ceiling per double modius, in 301
AD 79
the year that carbonized the bakery loaves
6
inherited words set on the table
masăpâinesarevinlingurăa mâncafurculiță
The table sets itself: six objects, six Latin ancestors.
  • mensa → masă
  • panem → pâine
  • sale → sare
  • vinum → vin
  • lingula → lingură
  • manducare → a mânca

The table

Six inherited words sit at the table; three newcomers wait at the door. Choose a word to see its chain: the Romanian form, the Latin ancestor, the road, the Roman anchor.

How to read the cards

  • INHERITED — continues a spoken-Latin word through historical sound change
  • BORROWED — entered later from another language
  • MADE IN ROMANIAN — created in Romanian from existing elements
  • * — a reconstructed, directly unattested form

Why does sale reach sare? See the sound rules in «Lapte din lactem».

6 inherited · 3 newcomerschains opened: 0/6
masăpâinesarevinlingurăa mâncafurculiță

Framed objects answer to touch and to the Enter key.

masă n. inherited

← mensa

mensa → mesa → masă

The -ns- cluster simplifies: the vulgar form mesa is proscribed by the Latin grammars themselves («mensa non mesa»); final -a becomes -ă.

Roman anchor: the baker's counter in the bread-distribution fresco, MANN 9071 — a merchant's table, painted.

DEX: Lat. mensa.

pâine n. inherited

← panis, acc. panem

panem → *pane → pâine

Final -m falls in late Latin; a becomes â beside a nasal, and the rest belongs to later Romanian development. Pâine keeps its final -e.

Roman anchor: the 81 carbonized loaves from the bakery of Modestus, Pompeii VII.1.36–37, AD 79.

Kin to Aromanian pîne.

DER: Lat. panem.

sare n. inherited

← sale, the vulgar form of sal

sale → sare

L between vowels becomes r: a pattern in inherited Latin words (rhotacism).

Roman anchor: the spiced salt in Diocletian's edict — 8 denarii the sextarius.

Kin to Italian sale and French sel.

DER: Lat. sale, the vulgar form.

vin n. inherited

← vinum

vinum → *vinu → vin

The Latin ending thins and falls: first -m, then -u after a single consonant.

Roman anchor: Conditum paradoxum — the honeyed, spiced wine from the book called Apicius, I.1.

DEX: Lat. vinum.

lingură n. inherited

← lingula, diminutive of lingua

lingula → lingură

Dictionaries trace the Romanian word to Latin lingula; its form changed over time.

Roman anchor: the Romans' table spoons — a cochlear-type one, at the MET, is pictured alongside.

Kin to Megleno-Romanian lingură.

DER: Lat. lĭngŭla, attested in Martial.

a mânca v. inherited

← manducare, via *manucāre

manducare → *manucāre → mânca

The asterisk marks a reconstructed form: spoken Latin had already reduced manducare to *manucāre (DER). In Romanian the unstressed vowel falls, and a becomes â beside a nasal.

Roman anchor: Sala cattabia — the soaked bread from the book called Apicius, IV.1.

DER: Lat. *manucāre, the “reduced form” of manducāre.

furculiță n.

Furcă + -uliță: a home-made Romanian diminutive, parallel to Latin furcilla — parallel, never inherited.

DEX: furcă + suf. -uliță.

Six inheritances, in turn

Each object tells its chain at length: the dictionary, the change, the Roman proof.

THE INHERITANCE · I

Masă: mensa

The table in a Romanian house still carries the Latin table's name.

Lat. mensa
“table” — not a canteen (DEX)
mesa
the vulgar form, proscribed in the Appendix Probi
-a > -ă
the unstressed ending

Mensa meant at Rome the table food goes on — but also the feast, and the offering table. The vulgar form mesa, which the Appendix Probi corrects («mensa non mesa»), went onward and gave, via -a > -ă, our masă. No canteen, no metaphor: the continuity is itself the point.

That the Roman table truly looked like a table stands in frescoes: the baker's counter in MANN 9071, loaves stacked on it, and the still life with bread and figs, set out on a slab.

Bread and figs on a slab, a fresco from Pompeii, MANN.
Bread and figs on a slab, a fresco from Pompeii, MANN. Photo: Carole Raddato from FRANKFURT, Germany, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Worth keeping: masă is the word for the table — the object and the name travelled together.

THE INHERITANCE · II

Pâine: panem

The round loaf, scored in eight, baked at Pompeii — and looks strikingly familiar.

81
carbonized loaves, every one leavened
8 — or 6
sections, most often eight; two famous pieces run six
1861
Fiorelli lifts them from the ash

In the oven of the bakery of Modestus (VII.1.36–37, Pompeii) 81 carbonized loaves waited out AD 79, every one leavened; Giuseppe Fiorelli lifted them from the ash in 1861. “Panis quadratus” means no square loaf: it is bread divided into quadrae — round, slightly flattened, with radial scores, most often in eight.

One Herculaneum loaf still carries its baker's stamp, legible: the loaf of Celer, slave of Quintus Granius Verus. The photograph shows such a fossil loaf, in a museum: black, cracked, scored.

A fossil loaf from Pompeii, AD 76 or 79.
A fossil loaf from Pompeii, AD 76 or 79. Photo: Jebulon, Wikimedia Commons, CC0
The bakery of Popidius Priscus, with its grinding mills, Pompeii.
The bakery of Popidius Priscus, with its grinding mills, Pompeii. Photo: Mary Harrsch, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
The oven of the bakery of Popidius Priscus, Pompeii.
The oven of the bakery of Popidius Priscus, Pompeii. Photo: Mary Harrsch, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Worth keeping: a good way of dividing bread looks the same after two millennia — continuity of form, not of blood.

THE INHERITANCE · III

Sare: sal

The salary comes from salt. Pay in salt is legend.

Lat. sal, salis
DEX; the vulgar form sale (DER)
salarium
“official pay”, derived from sal
8 denarii
spiced salt, the sextarius, in the Edict

The Latin salarium — “official pay” — derives from sal, “salt”: the etymology is solid. The mechanism is not: the idea that Roman soldiers drew their pay in salt “has no basis in ancient sources” (Merriam-Webster). Pliny (NH 31.89) ties salt to pay too, but without detail (the quote, at Merriam-Webster); soldiers were paid mostly in coin, the stipendium in three yearly instalments (Gainsford).

Salt itself fills Diocletian's edict: spiced salt carried a ceiling of 8 denarii the sextarius, the same as ordinary wine.

Salarium ← sal: solid. Pay in salt: legend with no ancient basis.

An ancient salt cellar, Athens, the Louvre: salt sat within reach then too.
An ancient salt cellar, Athens, the Louvre: salt sat within reach then too. Photo: Unknown artist, Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Worth keeping: the salary comes from salt; the soldiers don't.

THE INHERITANCE · IV

Vin: vinum

The Romans drank their wine with honey and with pepper.

Lat. vinum
DEX
8 denarii
ordinary wine (vinum rusticum), the sextarius, in the Edict
24 denarii
spiced wine (conditum), the sextarius, in the Edict

Conditum paradoxum — “the spiced wine, the surprising one” — runs thus: “mellis pondo XV in aeneum vas mittuntur… vini lenis sextaria XVIII”: fifteen pounds of honey into a copper vessel, then eighteen sextarii of light wine. The recipe adds pepper, mastic, saffron and roasted date stones.

In Vehling's translation: the honey and wine warm over a slow fire, stirred throughout, “add 18 sextarii of light wine” — and at the end the wine clears with charcoal.

A glass of red wine on a silver tray, a fresco from Herculaneum, House of the Deer, MANN.
A glass of red wine on a silver tray, a fresco from Herculaneum, House of the Deer, MANN. Photo: Carole Raddato from FRANKFURT, Germany, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Worth keeping: ordinary wine had an edict price — 8 denarii the sextarius; the spiced kind, 24.

THE INHERITANCE · V

Lingură: lingula

Lingură comes from Latin lingula, a diminutive of lingua, ‘tongue’.

Latin lingula
a diminutive of lingua, ‘tongue’
Lingură
a word inherited from Latin

Latin lingula had several meanings, including ‘little tongue’ and ‘spoon’. Dictionaries trace Romanian lingură to this Latin form. This page does not reconstruct the steps by which its pronunciation changed.

Romans used several kinds of spoon; the one pictured is a sharp-handled cochlear, another type of spoon.

A Roman cochlear-type spoon, silver, the MET.
A Roman cochlear-type spoon, silver, the MET. Photo: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Wikimedia Commons, CC0

The Romanian word for spoon preserves a Latin word related to ‘tongue’.

THE INHERITANCE · VI

A mânca: manducare

The chew that ate eating: the verb for “to chew” became the verb for the meal — a shift the whole of old Romania made together.

Lat. manducare
DEX; from mando, “to chew”
“to chew in the mouth”
what DEX says “a mânca” means

Manducare meant “to chew”, and in speech the ns cluster simplified to *manucare, the form “a mânca” starts from (DEX gives manducare, DER reconstructs *manucare). In Romanian, the chewing verb became the eating verb: “a mânca” means, by DEX, “a mesteca în gură și a înghiți” — to chew in the mouth and swallow. Old Romania walked the same road entire.

Roman food itself shows in the Sala cattabia: “panem ex posca maceratum exprimes” — “the bread soaked in posca, press it out” — cheese, cucumbers, pine nuts, then “super frigidam collocabis et sic appones”: “set it on ice and serve it so”.

The opening page of the book called Apicius, De re coquinaria, a NYAM manuscript.
The opening page of the book called Apicius, De re coquinaria, a NYAM manuscript. Photo: unknown (attributed to Apicius), Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Worth keeping: the book called Apicius — late 4th, early 5th century — cooks to this day.

The newcomers

Three arrived late and show it: their names betray their road.

A potato crop: the plant from the New World.
A potato crop: the plant from the New World. Photo: Willem van Aken, CSIRO, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

Cartof: Kartoffel

From German Kartoffel — a borrowing, never an inheritance.

The potato reached Europe late, carried by the Spaniards toward the end of the 16th century. When it reached Romanian speech nobody knows — so the page dates it nowhere.

The dateless newcomer: borrowed, never inherited.

Tomatoes on the vine: “the red one”, after its colour.
Tomatoes on the vine: “the red one”, after its colour. Photo: THOR, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Roșie: “the red one”

From roșu, “red” — a Romanian nickname for a New World fruit.

The tomato kept none of its home name. Romanians called it “roșie”, meaning “the red one”, after its colour — a home-made word for a guest.

The home-christened newcomer: a Romanian name, an American fruit.

Maize cobs: the American plant with a dove's name.
Maize cobs: the American plant with a dove's name. Photo: Sarah Smith, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Porumb: palumbus

From Latin palumbus, “dove” — a Latin word, an American plant.

Porumb is the table's trick: the name comes from Latin — from palumbus, “dove”, after the round grains — and the plant from America. Nicolae Costin names the crop in his chronicle; the exact year and the regional dates (1680–1690) circulate with no firm attestation in the source used here.

The disguised newcomer: Latin dress, American passport.

The Roman receipt

In the summer of 301 (dated after Crawford; posted at Alexandria between 20 November and 10 December), Diocletian capped the prices of nearly 1,400 goods and services. Our table's receipt runs thus:

The Roman receipt, denarii
ItemQuantityPrice
Wheat1 double modius (17.51 l)100
Barley1 double modius60
Ordinary wine1 sextarius (0.547 l)8
Spiced wine1 sextarius24
Pork1 pound (327.45 g)12
Salt pork, first quality1 pound16
Spiced salt1 sextarius8
Honey, best quality1 sextarius40
Vinegar1 sextarius6
Ordinary oil1 sextarius12
Fish sauce, first quality1 sextarius16
Eggs10 pieces1
A baker's day, with keep1 day50

“If anyone should, in his boldness, strive against the form of this statute, he shall undergo a capital penalty.” — the edict's preamble, in Kropff's translation

  • The denarius ran then as a unit of account: payments went in other coins, mostly nummi.
  • Lactantius (De mortibus persecutorum 7:6–7), an enemy of Diocletian, says the edict shed much blood and was withdrawn — Kropff asks whether we can trust him.
  • At Ephesus, the edict's copy promised 200 denarii to whoever informed on a seller asking over the ceiling.
A fragment of the maximum-prices edict, the Pergamon Museum, Berlin.
A fragment of the maximum-prices edict, the Pergamon Museum, Berlin. Photo: User:MatthiasKabel, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
The sale of bread, a fresco from Pompeii, MANN 9071: the counter, prices unspoken.
The sale of bread, a fresco from Pompeii, MANN 9071: the counter, prices unspoken. Photo: Marie-Lan Nguyen, Wikimedia Commons, public domain
The distribution of bread, a Roman fresco: the receipt settled in kind.
The distribution of bread, a Roman fresco: the receipt settled in kind. Photo: Tyler Bell, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Sources

Dictionaries first, then the cookbook and the edict, then the debate. The claims table ties each sentence to its proof.

The claims table

IDClaimEvidence
C01masă ← mensaDEX: Lat. mensa
C02pâine ← panis / panemDEX: Lat. panis; Aromanian pani
C03sare ← sale, from salDEX: Lat. sal, salis
C04vin ← vinumDEX: Lat. vinum
C05lingură ← lingula, “little tongue”DEX: Lat. lingula; diminutive of lingua
C06a mânca ← manducare, “to chew”DEX: Lat. manducare
C07furculița = furcă + -ulițăDEX '09; furcilla only parallel
C08cartof < German Kartoffel, datelessDEX: from German Kartoffel
C09roșie ← roșu, “the red one”NODEX: from roșu
C10porumb ← palumbus; the plant, AmericanN. Costin names it; 1680–1690 unfirm
C11salarium < sal, solid; pay in salt, unsupportedMerriam-Webster; Gainsford
C12Apicius: late 4th – early 5th c.; I.1, IV.1Bibliotheca Augustana; Vehling
C13The edict: summer 301, ca. 1,400 entriesthe Crawford dating; Kropff transl.; Ephesus 200 d.
C14Pompeii: 81 loaves, AD 79; eight, sometimes sixModestus VII.1.36–37; nunc.ch; Fiorelli 1861
C15Speech unbroken, address debatedPop / Schramm, condensed from the survey
C166 inherited · 3 newcomersthe page's own count

Dictionaries

Latin sources

History and debate

Type: Fraunces, Newsreader and Atkinson Hyperlegible, under the SIL Open Font Licence.