Marius Comper RO

Sibiu · Mediaș, Romania · the 1923 book, the 1929 figures

Hermann Oberth's rocket: Model B, from his own numbers

In 1923 Hermann Oberth, a maths teacher from Transylvania, in central Romania, described on paper a two-stage rocket. In the 1929 edition of his book it is 5 metres long with a mass of 544 kilograms, and two airships would have lifted it to 5,500 metres; from there, he reckoned, it would climb more than a thousand kilometres. No built example is known. Here its flight is computed step by step, with his masses, burn times and speeds, and you can put anything in its nose: a phone, a cat, yourself.

Munich, 1923

A teacher from Transylvania and a rocket on paper

Hermann Oberth was born in 1894 in Sibiu, known in German as Hermannstadt, then in Austria-Hungary and now in Romania. His family belonged to the Transylvanian Saxons, a German-speaking community settled there since the Middle Ages. In 1923 he published Die Rakete zu den Planetenräumen ("The Rocket into Planetary Space") in Munich, a book of equations arguing that a liquid-fuel rocket could leave the atmosphere. A whole part of the book describes Model B.

From the 1920s until 1938 he taught mathematics and physics at the secondary school in Mediaș. In 1929 he published a much expanded edition, Wege zur Raumschiffahrt ("Ways to Spaceflight"). The numbers attributed to Oberth on this page are read in the 1929 edition, in the translation NASA published in 1972; the 1923 edition was not compared figure by figure.

544 kg

Five metres long, 55.6 centimetres across, 544 kilograms

Oberth called it "Model B": a research apparatus to measure the height, composition and temperature of the atmosphere. The 544 kg does not include the booster used at launch. The large rocket carries a smaller one in its nose. The large one burns alcohol with liquid oxygen; in its nose sits a small 6.9 kg rocket that burns hydrogen.

The outline drawn here follows only the length and diameter he gave. The inside is not copied from his plates: the bands show what each part weighs.

70% of the propellant

Why Oberth used so much water

The large rocket carries 487.8 kg of propellant: alcohol, water and liquid oxygen. 341.5 kg of it is water, with 45.8 kg of alcohol mixed in. The rest: 98.8 kg of liquid oxygen and 1.67 kg of rectified alcohol.

Oberth chose a dilute mixture on purpose, burning at 1,400–1,500 °C, to show the rocket could be built "under all circumstances", although, he wrote, one could go much higher. Water lowers the flame temperature and with it the exhaust speed, so the same final speed needs more propellant.

His totals imply about 49.3 kg for the large rocket's structure; the parts he lists add up to 51.2 kg.

5,500 m

Launched from a cable between two airships at 5,500 metres

Model B does not start from the ground. In Oberth's design it would hang from a cable slung between two dirigibles, over water, and fire at 5,500 m, where, in his calculation, the air is half as dense as at sea level. Starting at sea level, he wrote, it would have had to be twice as long, which means eight times as large and heavy.

The technical journalist Franz Hoefft, who had "improved" his sketches, proposed a single weather balloon for his own rocket, R.H. I. Oberth replied that his Model C, invented in 1912, would give the same performance, with the same mass and fuel, starting from the ground.

8 seconds

The booster fires for eight seconds

Under the large rocket sits a 220 kg auxiliary rocket, a metre wide, that works for 8 seconds. At ignition the acceleration is 100 m/s², ten times that of gravity. After a climb of 2,200 m the rocket reaches 500 m/s. Oberth wanted the large rocket at that speed quickly, so as not to burn too much propellant merely holding up its own weight.

36–40 s

The alcohol engine burns for 36–40 seconds

The large rocket's engine expels 12.01–13.21 kg of gas a second. Launch mass over the mass left after the burn, with the hydrogen rocket still full, is 544 / 56.2 = 9.7; Oberth rounds it down to 9.

In his calculation he uses an exhaust speed of 1,400 m/s, though theory gave him "somewhat more than 1,800". At burnout, he writes, the rocket is travelling at 2,800–2,900 m/s; a few pages later, adding up the speeds, he starts from 3,000 m/s. On this page the air resistance is set so that his rocket reaches that 3,000 m/s. A step-by-step calculation, with his masses and gravity weakening with height, gives 3,000 m/s at 52 km when the burn ends; Oberth estimated 56.2 km for that moment.

2,210 m/s

The hydrogen rocket and its instruments

When the alcohol runs out, the nose cone opens in segments, like orange peel, and the small rocket fires. It has a mass of 6.90 kg before the burn and 3.60 kg after; the 1.5 kg of instruments is included in both.

Oberth writes: m₀/m₁ = 1.915, natural logarithm 0.650, and 3,400 × 0.650 = 2,210 m/s. The same equation with his masses gives 2,212 m/s. For the hydrogen exhaust speed he had computed 4,400 m/s and deliberately cut it to 3,400.

The stage burns for 8.15 seconds. Oberth adds up: 3,000 + 2,210 − 71.3 = 5,139 m/s.

~1,960 km

How high Model B would have climbed

"With this initial velocity, the rocket would rise roughly 1960 km," Oberth writes. That calculation is not shown in the book. The flight computed here step by step, with gravity decreasing in inverse proportion to the square of the distance from the Earth's centre, climbs to 1,831 km.

It is not known what approximation Oberth used for the climb after the engines stop, and nothing here is adjusted to match the 1,960 km. Both figures are more than ten times the 100 km altitude where space is usually said to begin.

v = c · ln(m₀/m₁)

How much speed a rocket gains from the mass it burns

Without gravity or air, the speed a rocket gains is its exhaust speed times the natural logarithm of full mass over empty mass. Oberth wrote it as v = c · ln(m₀/m₁) and gave a table: with an exhaust speed of 2,000 m/s, to reach 4,000 m/s the initial mass must be 7.39 times the final mass.

At the same exhaust speed, doubling the speed gained means squaring the mass ratio. That is why Oberth put one rocket on top of another: the small one no longer carries the large one's empty tanks.

in place of the instruments

What happens if you put something else in the nose

Type a mass. The rocket stays the one Oberth drew: the same tanks, the same flow rates, the same burn times. Only what sits in the nose changes, in place of the 1.5 kg of instruments.

kg
Exhaust speed

The RL10 hydrogen–oxygen engine, used on the upper stages of American rockets, had reached a specific impulse of about 465 seconds by 2018, according to NASA, which corresponds to an exhaust speed of roughly 4,560 m/s: 4% above the 4,400 m/s Oberth computed in 1929. The RL10 option keeps his masses and changes only the exhaust speed.

Mediaș, Nuremberg

What came next

No Model B built as the book describes it is known. Oberth taught in Mediaș until 1938, then left for Austria and Germany. He died in Nuremberg in 1989. In Mediaș, a Hermann Oberth memorial house opened in 1994, a hundred years after his birth; it is now the branch of Romania’s National Aviation Museum devoted to the history of rocketry and space research.

In the 16th century Conrad Haas had drawn a multi-stage rocket in a manuscript kept in Sibiu: Conrad Haas and his rocket.

Share the page

If you have launched a payload, the link opens the page with it and the exhaust speed you chose.

Sources

Oberth's numbers are read on the scanned pages of the NASA translation; the scan's machine-read text has many errors. Book pages in brackets.

  1. Hermann Oberth, Ways to Spaceflight, NASA TT F-622 (1972), traducerea / translation of Wege zur Raumschiffahrt (1929). Internet Archive · NASA NTRS Model B: pp. 315–340 (dimensions p. 319; propellants p. 322; exhaust speed p. 322 and p. 40 ff.; masses and the 9.7 ratio p. 323; booster pp. 337–338; airships p. 340; hydrogen rocket pp. 332–334; table of the basic equation, ch. 6, pp. 55–59).
  2. Hermann Oberth, Die Rakete zu den Planetenräumen, reeditare / reprint R. Oldenbourg (1984), cuprins / contents. pageplace.de Part II of the 1923 edition: "Beschreibung des Modells B" (pp. 48–61).
  3. NASA Spinoff, „RL10”. spinoff.nasa.gov RL10 specific impulse: 424 seconds originally, "about 465 seconds today"; × 9.80665 m/s² ≈ 4,560 m/s.
  4. Wikipedia, „Hermann Oberth”. en.wikipedia.org Born in Sibiu (1894), teacher at the Stephan Ludwig Roth school in Mediaș until 1938 (start given as 1924 or 1925 by different sources), died in Nuremberg (1989); the 1923 and 1929 editions.
  5. Ghidul muzeelor, cIMeC: Secția „Hermann Oberth”, Mediaș. ghidulmuzeelor.cimec.ro Section opened in 1994. The page gives the wrong year for Oberth's death (1980 instead of 1989).
  6. Wikipedia, „Kármán line”. en.wikipedia.org The 100 km line commonly used as the edge of space.