Warsaw’s Old Town: from Canaletto’s view to the past the city chose
In 1770 a Venetian painter looked across the Vistula and painted Warsaw’s skyline. In 1944 German forces burned and demolished it. What rose in its place was built from surveys, inventories and choices about which Warsaw to bring back.
Bernardo Bellotto was born in Venice in 1722, learned view painting from his uncle Canaletto, and spent the last 13 years of his life in Warsaw. He sometimes signed himself Bellotto de Canaletto, and in Warsaw the room that held his city views is still the Canaletto Room.
The 1770 view looks west from Praga, the district on the Vistula’s east bank. Between 1767 and 1780 he painted them for King Stanisław August, and the canvases were fitted into the room’s paneling. The Royal Castle says the full set of 22 was taken to Russia in 1832, where 18 canvases were resized. They came back in 1921. In 1984, in the rebuilt Castle, the original hanging order was restored from the compositions and the Castle’s inventories.
In 1944 the city was burned and demolished on purpose
After the Warsaw Uprising of 1944 was crushed, German forces spent October to December burning and demolishing the city. UNESCO’s dossier on the archive of the Warsaw Reconstruction Office (in Polish, Biuro Odbudowy Stolicy, BOS) puts it down to an order from Heinrich Himmler: Warsaw was to be levelled with the earth, as a terrifying example to all Europe. The dossier takes the wording from testimony given at Nuremberg in 1945 by SS General Erich von Bach-Żelewski.
Germany had planned a different Warsaw on paper as well. A scheme approved in Berlin in 1942, the so-called Pabst plan, put a huge Nazi party hall where the Royal Castle stood.
This is the 1944 Warsaw Uprising, a different event from the 1943 Warsaw Ghetto Uprising.
What survived was low: cellars, ground floors, a few houses
UNESCO’s description of the Historic Centre lists what is left of the pre-war buildings: most basements, some ground floors, and sections of wall up to the first floor.
A few houses on the north side of the Old Town Market Square (Rynek), called Dekert’s Side, did better. The Museum of Warsaw says No. 34 burned out but kept its façade, portal and brick vaults, and No. 36 kept its roof timbers, staircase and three painted wooden ceilings from the 17th and 18th centuries, which it credits to the reinforced concrete added in 1939. The other sides of the Square were in much worse condition.
From 1923 to 1939 the Institute of Polish Architecture organized, as part of its training for students, detailed studies of most of the Old Town’s historic buildings: plans, sections, elevations, details. The Institute burned down in 1944, but the documents had been smuggled out of Warsaw. William A. Singleton wrote in 1959 that they formed the basic technical data for the reconstruction.
Planning began almost at once. An office to organize the rebuilding was set up on 22 January 1945 under Professor Jan Zachwatowicz, and on 14 February it became BOS, with Roman Piotrowski as director. An inventory of the Old Town’s rubble began in March.
The rebuilders worked from several kinds of record. Singleton is plain about it: every possible source was used, and among them were Canaletto’s paintings.
Drawings
Student surveys, 1923–1939
Plans, sections, elevations and details of most of the Old Town’s historic buildings. Singleton calls them the basic technical data.
Teams of specialists went through the ruins area by area and marked each building: standing, wrecked but repairable, or gone. An Old Town map is dated 21 March 1945; maps of historic blocks forbade demolition without the office’s consent.
UNESCO says conservation inventories from both periods were used, with the knowledge of art historians, architects and conservators. The rubble inventory began in March 1945.
The BOS archive holds photographs, drawings, plans and technical records from 1945 to 1953. Singleton adds photographs from the 19th and 20th centuries.
Singleton dates them 1767–1779 and counts them with prints, drawings and photographs. The National Gallery in London credits their precision with a crucial role in the rebuilding.
The rebuilders aimed at the late eighteenth century
Rebuilding a city starts with a choice no archive can make: which period to return to. UNESCO states two principles. Use reliable archival documents where they exist. And aim for the city’s late-18th-century appearance, because that was the period with the most detailed pictures and papers.
Singleton describes how that worked building by building. Each was classified by its historical merit. Only authentic, historically important buildings went back to their precise original form, and later additions, above all from the 19th century, were left out of the plan, which, he notes, eased the street line considerably.
Those are also the decades of Bellotto’s Warsaw views. UNESCO, though, explains the choice by how much documentation the period left, and names no painting.
The historians Jerzy Elżanowski and Carmen Enss compare two drawings of Piwna Street in the Old Town: an elevation drawn from surveys made in 1939 and after 1944, and a drawing of the street as built in 1956.
1939 · after 1944
Survey drawing
An elevation drawn from surveys made in 1939 and after 1944.
1956
As-built drawing
The same street, drawn as the rebuilders actually built it.
Changes the two historians list for the Old Town as a whole
courtyard buildings cleared
façades and rooflines altered
corner buildings replaced
church towers redesigned
For the Old Town as a whole, UNESCO describes three deliberate departures. Some buildings were not rebuilt at all, so that the walls and the panorama from the Vistula show; the ground inside the old blocks stayed open as common space for residents; and the flats were reworked to the standards of the time. Singleton says the solution required compromise both on modern housing standards and on absolute fidelity of reconstruction.
The Old Town Market Square on 22 July 1953, the day the Commons record gives for the ceremony handing the rebuilt district over for use. Photographer unknown; the record cites Karol Małcużyński, Szkice warszawskie (1955).Credit: Photographer unknown · 22 July 1953 · Public domain (PD-Polish) · File record on Wikimedia Commons
22 July 1953
On 22 July 1953 the rebuilt Square was handed over for use
A crowd fills the Old Town Market Square. The Commons record dates this photograph to 22 July 1953, the ceremony that handed the rebuilt Old Town over for use. The Museum of Warsaw dates the Square’s official opening to 1953, and Singleton records that all its shops, restaurants and services were finished and open in July.
By Singleton’s account, plans for the Square were ready in 1952 and every building planned there was finished within a single year. The money for the capital’s reconstruction came from a national fund set up in 1948, fed by a levy on wages, taxes on some goods, including vodka, and proceeds from cultural events and public fundraisers. The Museum of Warsaw adds that many people worked as volunteers.
Behind the painted façades the interiors were new. UNESCO says the flats were reworked to the standards of the time; the Museum of Warsaw describes small flats of two and three rooms with running water or central heating. Singleton explains the layout: homes on the upper floors only, and shops, coffee houses, bars and restaurants on the ground floors and in the vaulted cellars, so that nobody lived in poorly lit rooms at street level.
The first residents moved in by 1951. When Singleton wrote in 1959, the Old Town had some 5,000 inhabitants, against 4,000 in the eighteenth century.
Ask when the Old Town was rebuilt and the sources give different answers, because each dates something different. Tap a row to see what.
19451950195519601965
The planning office1945–1951
UNESCO says the reconstruction project for the Old Town was devised at the Warsaw Reconstruction Office in 1945–1951. The UNESCO dossier gives 14 February 1945 as the date BOS was established.
Singleton says the Square’s shops, restaurants and services were open in July 1953. The Museum of Warsaw gives 1953 as the year of the official opening, and the Commons record gives 22 July 1953 for the ceremony.
UNESCO says the rebuilding of the Old Town continued until the mid-1960s. It counts the whole process as complete only with the reconstruction of the Royal Castle, opened to visitors in 1984.
UNESCO inscribed the Historic Centre of Warsaw on the World Heritage List in 1980. Its description sorts the buildings into two kinds. The first survived: most basements, some ground floors, sections of wall up to the first floor. The second was reconstructed: houses recreated from pre-war records, and others, such as the façade of the cathedral and the walls with the Barbican, rebuilt from historical and conservation studies.
UNESCO calls the panorama of the Old Town seen from the Vistula a symbol of Warsaw, and says some buildings were left unbuilt so that the walls and that view would show. It also counts keeping the Old Town a residential quarter as a significant part of its integrity.
Both frames on the table look across the river at the Old Town’s skyline: one painted in 1770, one photographed in 2019. Between them came the drawings, the maps and the choice.
Each chapter ends with its sources. Quotations are short and everything else is paraphrased. The images come from Wikimedia Commons; the credit and licence sit beside each one.