Doctrines and legendsROEN

A measured effect, a quotation that is not Goebbels’s

The repeated lie: the effect is small and the quotation is not Goebbels’s

Repetition raises perceived truth a little (g = 0.37). The quotation has no source in Goebbels.

The name: Label given by othersThe deed: Tested modelWhat do the labels mean?

What the documents show

  • The meta-analysis in Nature Communications (27 February 2026) pools 182 studies, 366 effect sizes and 31,184 participants, published from 1977 to 2025. The illusory truth effect is small: g = 0.37, with a 95 per cent confidence interval of 0.30 to 0.44.1

    The source’s words

    we observe a small illusory truth effect (g = 0.37, 95% confidence interval [0.30, 0.44])

    Meta-analysis of the illusory truth effect, abstract
  • Conditions change the effect: false cues not only attenuated but, on average, reversed it. The meta-analysis’s introduction also notes that earlier studies found repetition did not reliably raise the perceived truth of extremely implausible statements.1

    The source’s words

    repetition did not reliably increase the perceived truth for extremely implausible statements…

    Meta-analysis of the illusory truth effect, introduction
  • Knowledge does not fully protect: Fazio and colleagues (2015) found that the effect occurred even when participants knew better.2

    The source’s words

    illusory truth effects occurred even when participants knew better.

    Knowledge does not protect against illusory truth (abstract), abstract
  • The quotation has no source in Goebbels. Randall Bytwerk, a scholar of Nazi propaganda, writes that he knows of no evidence Goebbels said it and that no one gives a citation to the source. The Jewish Virtual Library notes there seems to be no evidence that it was used by Goebbels, though it is often attributed to him.34

    The source’s words

    I know of no evidence that he actually said it.

    False Nazi Quotations
  • Goebbels’s closest sentence, in an article of 12 January 1941, accuses the English: “The English follow the principle that when one lies, one should lie big, and stick to it.” He writes that Churchill repeats his lies until he believes them himself.5

    The source’s words

    The English follow the principle that when one lies, one should lie big, and stick to it.

    Churchills Lügenfabrik („Fabrica de minciuni a lui Churchill”), 12 ianuarie 1941
  • The report prepared during the war for the American Office of Strategic Services on Hitler (Langer) lists Hitler’s rules, among them that if you repeat it frequently enough people will believe it. The sentence is about Hitler’s rules, not Goebbels’s. The Jewish Virtual Library notes that in Mein Kampf the “big lie” is an accusation Hitler levels at his opponents.64

    The source’s words

    if you repeat it frequently enough people will sooner or later believe it.

    Report on Hitler prepared for the Office of Strategic Services

What does not follow

  • That Goebbels said or wrote “if you lie big enough and repeat it often enough people will come to believe it”, or a close variant: no source has been found.
  • That repetition makes any claim believed by everyone: the effect is small, and conditions change it.
  • That an American document of 1944 attributed the line to Goebbels: none was found.

Who coined the name, and when

  1. 1977The oldest study included in the 2026 meta-analysis dates from 1977.1
  2. 12 January 1941Goebbels accuses the English, in an article, of lying big and repeating.5
  3. during the warAn American report on Hitler lists his rules, including repetition.6
  4. 2015Fazio and colleagues show the effect appears even when people know better.2
  5. 1 more dates
    1. 27 February 2026The Nature Communications meta-analysis gives g = 0.37.1

Sources

  1. 1Meta-analysis of the illusory truth effect
    Ye et al. · 2026 · Nature Communications 17:3270, 27 February 2026 · opened 14 November 2026
  2. 2Knowledge does not protect against illusory truth (abstract)
    Lisa K. Fazio și colegii · 2015 · Journal of Experimental Psychology: General · opened 14 November 2026
  3. 3False Nazi Quotations
    Randall Bytwerk · German Propaganda Archive · opened 14 November 2026
  4. 4Hitler on the Big Lie
    Jewish Virtual Library · opened 14 November 2026
  5. 5Churchills Lügenfabrik („Fabrica de minciuni a lui Churchill”), 12 ianuarie 1941
    Joseph Goebbels · 1941 · German Propaganda Archive, Calvin University · opened 14 November 2026
  6. 6Report on Hitler prepared for the Office of Strategic Services
    Walter C. Langer · Internet Archive, document CIA-RDP78-02646 · opened 14 November 2026

See also