Doctrines and legendsROEN

A real effect, with limits: where Gromyko’s first rule starts

Anchoring in negotiation: when the first demand helps and when it backfires

An arbitrary number can pull estimates towards it. Very extreme demands can lead to impasse.

The name: Tested modelThe deed: Tested modelWhat do the labels mean?

What the documents show

  • In the 1974 experiment a number between 0 and 100 was determined by spinning a wheel of fortune in the participants’ presence, and different groups were given different starting numbers. The median estimates of the African share of UN members were 25 and 45 for starting numbers of 10 and 65.1

    The source’s words

    were 25 and 45 for groups that received 10 and 65, respectively, as starting points.

    Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, section on adjustment
  • In negotiation, Galinsky and Mussweiler (2001) found that whichever party, buyer or seller, made the first offer obtained a better outcome. The effect disappeared when negotiators thought about the other side’s alternatives or its reservation price.2

    The source’s words

    Thinking about one's opponent's alternatives to the negotiation (Experiment 1), one's opponent's reservation price (Experiment 2)

    First Offers as Anchors: The Role of Perspective-Taking and Negotiator Focus (rezumat), abstract
  • Very extreme offers carry a cost: according to a 2012 study, extreme first offers offend their recipients and cause them to walk away, resulting in an impasse, and it is the low-power negotiators who walk away.3

    The source’s words

    extreme first offers offend their recipients and cause them to walk away, resulting in an impasse.

    Starting high and ending with nothing: the role of anchors and power in negotiations (rezumat), abstract
  • Across 26 million eBay negotiations, the ideal buyer offer lay at about 80 per cent of the seller’s list price across all products, although the value ranges from 33 to 95 per cent, a 2023 PNAS article shows.4

    The source’s words

    the ideal buyer offer lies at 80% of the seller's list price across all products…

    Article on the first offer in 26 million eBay negotiations (abstract)
  • A meta-analysis in preprint (December 2025) finds a large average anchoring effect (g = 0.825), with very large variation between studies (I² = 93.73 per cent).5

    The source’s words

    Hedges' g = 0.825, 95% CI[0.765, 0.884], I2 = 93.73%…

    Meta-analysis of the anchoring effect (preprint, version 2)
  • BATNA (best alternative to a negotiated agreement) was coined by Roger Fisher and William Ury in their 1981 book. James Sebenius writes that if either party prefers its BATNA to any proposed deal, no zone of possible agreement exists.67

    The source’s words

    If either party prefers its BATNA to any proposed deal, then no zone of possible agreement exists.

    BATNAs in negotiation (paper on origin and limits)
  • The other side’s reservation value is often private information: when relevant information is privately held, the parties must learn about each other before they can identify an agreement.8

    The source’s words

    If information relevant to the negotiation is privately held, the parties must learn about each other before they can identify suitable settlement terms.

    Paper on private information in negotiation

Try it: how far can the first demand go

Move the sliders: what each side accepts rather than no deal, what a break costs, how much A asks for at the opening. The numbers are hypothetical.

What does not follow

  • That anchoring always works: the effect depends on conditions, and very extreme demands can lead to impasse.
  • That negotiators know the other side’s reservation value.

Who coined the name, and when

  1. 1974Tversky and Kahneman publish the wheel experiment in Science.1
  2. 1981Fisher and Ury introduce the term BATNA.6
  3. 2001Galinsky and Mussweiler show the first-offer advantage and the conditions where it disappears.2
  4. 2012A study shows that extreme offers can lead to impasse.3
  5. 2 more dates
    1. 2023The PNAS article analyses 26 million eBay negotiations.4
    2. December 2025The meta-analysis preprint gives g = 0.825.5

Sources

  1. 1Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases
    Amos Tversky, Daniel Kahneman · 1974 · Science 185 · opened 14 November 2026
  2. 2First Offers as Anchors: The Role of Perspective-Taking and Negotiator Focus (rezumat)
    Adam D. Galinsky, Thomas Mussweiler · 2001 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81(4) · opened 14 November 2026
  3. 3Starting high and ending with nothing: the role of anchors and power in negotiations (rezumat)
    Schweinsberg și colegii · 2012 · Journal of Experimental Social Psychology · opened 14 November 2026
  4. 4Article on the first offer in 26 million eBay negotiations (abstract)
    Schweinsberg și colegii · 2023 · PNAS · opened 14 November 2026
  5. 5Meta-analysis of the anchoring effect (preprint, version 2)
    Schley, Weingarten · 2025 · OSF/PsyArXiv · opened 14 November 2026
  6. 6BATNA
    Beyond Intractability · opened 14 November 2026
  7. 7BATNAs in negotiation (paper on origin and limits)
    James K. Sebenius · Harvard DASH · opened 14 November 2026
  8. 8Paper on private information in negotiation
    University of Maryland · opened 14 November 2026

See also