Doctrines and legendsROEN

A model of 1960, with its own limits

Brinkmanship: what Schelling actually says

Schelling describes a shared risk no one fully controls. He does not say any leader used it.

The name: Tested modelThe deed: Tested modelWhat do the labels mean?

What the documents show

  • Schelling defines brinkmanship as the deliberate creation of a recognizable risk of war, a risk that one does not completely control.1

    The source’s words

    Brinkmanship is thus the deliberate creation of a recognizable risk of war, a risk that one does not completely control.

    The Strategy of Conflict (1980 paperback printing of the 1960 book), ch. 8, p. 200
  • He notes the credibility problem himself: merely saying that you may turn us both over is unconvincing; you must really put the boat in jeopardy.1

    The source’s words

    just saying that I may turn us both over is unconvincing…

    The Strategy of Conflict (1980 paperback printing of the 1960 book), ch. 8, p. 196
  • In Arms and Influence Schelling writes that the creation of risk, usually a shared risk, is the technique of compellence that probably best deserves the name of “brinkmanship”.2

    The source’s words

    The creation of risk—usually a shared risk—is the technique of compellence that probably best deserves the name of “brinkmanship.”

    Arms and Influence, cap. 2, „The Art of Commitment”, ch. 2, p. 91
  • Also in Arms and Influence Schelling separates deterrence, stopping someone from doing something, from “compellence”, making him do something: the difference is in timing and initiative, in who has to make the first move. For the term, he says, “compellence” is the best he can do.2

    The source’s words

    The distinction is in the timing and in the initiative, in who has to make the first move…

    Arms and Influence, cap. 2, „The Art of Commitment”, ch. 2, p. 69
  • Schelling admits the discomfort: he can see why most people are uneasy about what, in an earlier book, he called “the threat that leaves something to chance”.3

    The source’s words

    I can see why most people are uneasy about what, in an earlier book, I called “the threat that leaves something to chance.”

    Arms and Influence, cap. 3, „The Manipulation of Risk”, ch. 3, note 8, p. 121
  • The image of the climbers: brinkmanship means exploiting the danger that somebody may inadvertently go over the brink, dragging the other with him.3

    The source’s words

    It means exploiting the danger that somebody may inadvertently go over the brink, dragging the other with him.

    Arms and Influence, cap. 3, „The Manipulation of Risk”, ch. 3, p. 99

What does not follow

  • That Schelling says any particular leader used brinkmanship or should use it: he says the method is risky and disliked.
  • That the method works reliably: Schelling himself writes that you must also win the “war of nerves”.
  • That the pages cited are from the original 1960 edition: the text opened is the 1980 paperback printing.

Who coined the name, and when

  1. 1960Schelling publishes The Strategy of Conflict, with “the threat that leaves something to chance”.1
  2. 1966Schelling publishes Arms and Influence, with the deterrence–“compellence” distinction.23

Sources

  1. 1The Strategy of Conflict (1980 paperback printing of the 1960 book)
    Thomas C. Schelling · 1960 · Harvard University Press · opened 14 November 2026
  2. 2Arms and Influence, cap. 2, „The Art of Commitment”
    Thomas C. Schelling · 1966 · Yale University Press · opened 14 November 2026
  3. 3Arms and Influence, cap. 3, „The Manipulation of Risk”
    Thomas C. Schelling · 1966 · Yale University Press · opened 14 November 2026

See also