Explained
“The Gromyko doctrine”: what the three rules say, and whether he really said them
Three rules for bargaining with the West, put down to a Soviet foreign minister and quoted today by European officials. This page explains them, shows what research and history say about each, and follows the quotation back to its source.
- 1957–1985Gromyko runs Soviet diplomacy
- 1985–1999No text by Gromyko with the rules
- 1999Mlechin prints them in a book: the oldest text found
- 2022Kallas lists them in Tallinn
- 2025Le Grand Continent: “the Gromyko doctrine”
- 13 Nov 2026Kallas, in Dublin
Andrei Gromyko ran Soviet diplomacy from 1957 to 1985.1 The Western press called him “Mr. Nyet”, Mr. No. A cable of the American embassy about a conversation with him, from 1959, describes him as “completely intransigent” yet amiable throughout.2
His name is back for three negotiating rules. On 13 November 2026 in Dublin, the EU’s foreign-policy chief, Kaja Kallas, was asked why she thinks Russia does not want her as a negotiator. She invoked the rules attributed to Gromyko: first threats and ultimatums, then waiting, because people in the West will always offer something.3 She had already listed Gromyko’s three rules in January 2022, as prime minister of Estonia, to the parliament in Tallinn, in other words.4 The French magazine Le Grand Continent called them “the Gromyko doctrine” in August 2025.5
there will always be people in the West who will offer you something you did not have before…
Two questions remain. What do the rules say, and do they work? And did Gromyko really say them? The first has an answer for each rule, below. The second has a shorter answer than you would expect.
01 · The rules
The three rules, explained
The wordings below are paraphrases after the biography of Yevgeny Primakov, a former Russian foreign minister and prime minister, by Leonid Mlechin, who attributes them to Gromyko. Under each: what the rule says, what research or history shows, and the page to go further.
Demand the maximum, including what never belonged to you.
The idea: the first demand becomes the reference point. After a demand of 100, a compromise at 50 looks reasonable; after a demand of 60, it does not. The numbers are an example, not a measurement.
The effect is real. In 1974 Tversky and Kahneman spun a wheel in front of participants and asked them to estimate the African share of UN members. Those who started from the number 10 gave a median of 25; those who started from 65, a median of 45 (the median: half the answers fall below it, half above).6 In negotiation, the side that makes the first offer often does better.7
It has limits. Very extreme demands offend: in a 2012 study, recipients walked away and the negotiation ended in impasse.8 And in Galinsky and Mussweiler’s experiment, considering the other side’s alternatives removed the first-offer advantage.7
Try it: how much can you ask for?
Move the sliders: what each side accepts rather than no deal, what a break costs, how much A asks at the opening. If B can walk away at little cost, a demand that is too large stops by itself. The numbers are hypothetical.
Issue ultimatums and threaten; offer negotiation as the way out. In the West there will always be people who take the bait.
The idea: after a threat, a discussion looks like a way out, not a concession. Mlechin prints “threaten war” in one wording only; Kallas says just “threats and ultimatums”.
A real ultimatum, with a clock. On 26 June 1940 at 22:00, Vyacheslav Molotov, the Soviet foreign minister, handed the head of the Romanian mission in Moscow a note demanding Bessarabia and northern Bukovina, with a reply during the following day. A second note demanded evacuation within four days, and Soviet troops crossed the border before the reply. Romania accepted on 28 June.910 Gromyko does not appear in the episode: it is an example of an ultimatum, not proof of any rule.
The theory. Thomas Schelling calls “brinkmanship” the deliberate creation of a recognizable risk of war that one does not completely control, and notes that merely saying you may tip the boat is unconvincing.11 He admits the method makes most people uneasy.12
Once talks begin, do not yield a step: you will be offered part of what you asked. Only when you have half or two thirds of what you did not have are you a diplomat.
The idea: patience makes the other side move first. Here Gromyko is best documented, but as a style, not as a written rule.
The style is attested. The American cable of 1959 calls him “completely intransigent”, yet amiable.2 What is not attested is the rule as such, in his words.
A crisis with a partial ending. In October 1962 the Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev publicly proposed that both sides withdraw their missiles: his in Cuba, the Americans’ in Turkey.13 President John F. Kennedy’s public reply said work in Cuba must stop first and did not mention Turkey.14 According to the cable of the Soviet ambassador, Dobrynin, the president’s brother Robert Kennedy said privately that the Americans needed four to five months to remove the missiles from Turkey;15 dismantling began on 15 April 1963, and at the time only nine American officials knew of the understanding.1617 Gromyko was foreign minister, but the episode does not show him applying the rule: it shows what an ending looks like in which each side gets a part.
How to answer it. Before negotiating, it pays to identify your best alternative to an agreement. If either side prefers its alternative to any proposed deal, no zone of agreement exists.18 And in Galinsky and Mussweiler’s experiment, thinking about the other side’s alternatives removed the advantage of the first offer.7 The difficulty: the other side’s reservation value, the point beyond which it prefers no deal, often stays unknown.19
02 · The source
Did Gromyko really say them?
It cannot be shown. The only printed source the texts consulted name is Leonid Mlechin, a Russian biographer whose book on Primakov first appeared in 1999.20 Mlechin writes that one of Gromyko’s young assistants, the diplomat Oleg Grinevsky, wrote down his words.2122 A text by Gromyko or by Grinevsky containing these rules has not been found.
Mlechin prints the rules in three books, in three wordings, and “threaten war” appears in only one.212324 Kallas gave them in 2022 in other words and without a source.4 The word “doctrine” appears, in the texts consulted, only in the Le Grand Continent title of 12 August 2025.5
This does not mean Gromyko did not negotiate hard: the 1959 cable shows him intransigent. It means the rules are an account, not a document, and that the name “doctrine” is much newer than the man.
The same rules, four wordings
| Who recorded it | The threat | The concession | The gain | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1999, text of a later editionMlechin, the Primakov biography | Grinevsky “wrote down” his words | threaten war | do not yield a step | half or two thirds |
| year not establishedMlechin, MID | Grinevsky “recalls” | threats only, without the word “war” | do not yield a step | half or two thirds |
| 2019Mlechin, Secrets of Russian diplomacy | Grinevsky “recalled” | threats only, without the word “war” | do not retreat a step | half or two thirds |
| 19 Jan 2022Kaja Kallas, in the Estonian parliament | no source named | threats only, without the word “war” | do not give one inch | a third or even half |
In columns, the texts where the rules appear in print or in an official statement; in rows, what each says. The later press texts are in the board below.
Follow the quotation back, text by text
Each text below states the rules a little differently. The fixed board shows how each one words them, from the newest to the oldest; amber letters are those changed from the text before. At the end, before 1999, the board goes blank.
ScrollDemand the maximum, even what never belonged to you.
- Who recorded it
- no source named for the rules
- The threat
- threaten warУгрожайте войной
- The bait
- people in the West who take the baitклюнут
- The concession
- do not yield a stepне уступайте ни на шаг
- The gain
- half or two thirdsполовину или две трети
- The name
- a “Gromyko school”, not “doctrine”школа Громыко
amber letters: changed from the previous step · lamp lit: the row changed
12 Nov 2025 · UNIAN
Russian, but not Mlechin’s
A Ukrainian article of November 2025 gives the rules in Russian, but with “Угрожайте войной”, not the “Грозите войной” of Mlechin’s books. It gives them as quotations attributed to Gromyko, with no source for them, and speaks of a “Gromyko school”, not a “doctrine”.25
In the original:
Угрожайте войной
·клюнут
·не уступайте ни на шаг
·половину или две трети
·школа Громыко
- Who recorded it
- no source named for the rules
- The threat
- threaten warУгрожайте войной
- The bait
- people in the West who take the baitклюнут
- The concession
- do not yield a stepне уступайте ни на шаг
- The gain
- half or two thirdsполовину или две трети
- The name
- a “Gromyko school”, not “doctrine”школа Громыко
21 Aug 2025 · Fakti.bg, in English
The same translation, in English
A Bulgarian site publishes the Le Grand Continent text in English, with “Threaten war”, “take the bait” and “Gromyko Doctrine”. The rules are the same as in the French; the word “doctrine” is already in the text.26
In the original:
wrote it down
·Threaten war
·take the bait
·do not give in an inch
·half or two-thirds
·Gromyko Doctrine
- Who recorded it
- Grinevsky, an assistant, wrote it downwrote it down
- The threat
- threaten warThreaten war
- The bait
- people in the West who take the baittake the bait
- The concession
- do not yield a stepdo not give in an inch
- The gain
- half or two thirdshalf or two-thirds
- The name
- “doctrine”Gromyko Doctrine
12 Aug 2025 · Le Grand Continent, in French
Here the word “doctrine” appears
The French magazine publishes an extract from Mlechin under the title “Comprendre la doctrine Gromyko”. In the texts consulted, the word “doctrine” appears here first. The translation keeps “threaten war” and says Grinevsky, an assistant, wrote them down.5
In the original:
les consigna par écrit
·Menacez de guerre
·mordre à l’hameçon
·ne cédez pas d’un pas
·la moitié ou les deux tiers
·la doctrine Gromyko
- Who recorded it
- Oleg Grinevsky, an assistant, wrote them downles consigna par écrit
- The threat
- threaten warMenacez de guerre
- The bait
- people in the West who take the baitmordre à l’hameçon
- The concession
- do not yield a stepne cédez pas d’un pas
- The gain
- half or two thirdsla moitié ou les deux tiers
- The name
- “doctrine”la doctrine Gromyko
16 May 2025 · Pikabu, in Russian
No source, in Russian
A Russian text on Pikabu gives the rules under Gromyko’s name, with no source. Compared with the text above, “war” and the word “doctrine” are missing; the bait is the Russian “клюнут” (bite the bait).27
In the original:
клюнут
·не уступайте ни на шаг
·половину или две трети
·Три правила переговоров
- Who recorded it
- no source; the rules are attributed straight to Gromyko
- The threat
- threats only, without the word “war”
- The bait
- people in the West who take the baitклюнут
- The concession
- do not yield a stepне уступайте ни на шаг
- The gain
- half or two thirdsполовину или две трети
- The name
- three negotiating rulesТри правила переговоров
19 Jan 2022 · Kaja Kallas, in the Estonian parliament
Estonia, in parliament
Estonia’s prime minister gives them to parliament in other words: “a third or even half”, and Westerners are “willing to negotiate” instead of taking the bait. She does not say where she took them from.4
In the original:
do not hold back on threats
·willing to negotiate
·do not give one inch of ground
·a third or even half
·three rules
- Who recorded it
- no source named
- The threat
- threats only, without the word “war”do not hold back on threats
- The bait
- people in the West “willing to negotiate”willing to negotiate
- The concession
- do not give one inchdo not give one inch of ground
- The gain
- a third or even halfa third or even half
- The name
- three rulesthree rules
2019 · Mlechin, Secrets of Russian diplomacy
Mlechin, 2019
In the 2019 book Grinevsky “recalled”. Here the Westerners are no longer “willing to negotiate”, as in Kallas: they take the bait. The gain is “half or two thirds”, the concession is “do not retreat a step”, and the rules are “golden”, rules of superpower diplomacy. The word “war” is missing here too.24
In the original:
вспоминал посол
·Не жалейте угроз
·клюнут на это
·не отступайте ни на шаг
·половину или две трети
·три золотых правила дипломатии сверхдержав
- Who recorded it
- Grinevsky “recalled”вспоминал посол
- The threat
- threats only, without the word “war”Не жалейте угроз
- The bait
- people in the West who take the baitклюнут на это
- The concession
- do not retreat a stepне отступайте ни на шаг
- The gain
- half or two thirdsполовину или две трети
- The name
- three golden rules of superpower diplomacyтри золотых правила дипломатии сверхдержав
year not established · Mlechin, MID
Mlechin, another book
In MID the same author has almost the same wording: “golden rules”, Grinevsky “recalls”, but “do not yield”, as in the biography. The year of the edition has not been established, so its place in the sequence is a reading order only.23
In the original:
вспоминает посол Гриневский
·не уступайте ни на шаг
·три золотых правила дипломатии сверхдержав
- Who recorded it
- Grinevsky “recalls”вспоминает посол Гриневский
- The threat
- threats only, without the word “war”
- The bait
- people in the West who take the bait
- The concession
- do not yield a stepне уступайте ни на шаг
- The gain
- half or two thirds
- The name
- three golden rules of superpower diplomacyтри золотых правила дипломатии сверхдержав
1999, text of a later edition · Mlechin, the Primakov biography
Mlechin, the Primakov biography
Here the rules again carry the threat of war (“Грозите войной”) and a witness who “wrote down” Gromyko’s words; they carry no “doctrine” label. The book appeared in 1999, but the text read is from a newer edition (photo captions carry dates up to 2006). Whether the 1999 edition had the rules is not known.21
In the original:
записал его слова
·Грозите войной
·клюнут на это
·не уступайте ни на шаг
·половину или две трети
- Who recorded it
- Grinevsky “wrote down” his wordsзаписал его слова
- The threat
- threaten warГрозите войной
- The bait
- people in the West who take the baitклюнут на это
- The concession
- do not yield a stepне уступайте ни на шаг
- The gain
- half or two thirdsполовину или две трети
- The name
- no label: just “the rules”
before 1999 · Nothing found
Before Mlechin: nothing
No text by Gromyko (1909–1989) or Grinevsky (1930–2019) containing these rules has been found. Grinevsky’s own books could not be read online; in the texts consulted, the oldest dated copy in Russian outside Mlechin’s books is from 2025.22
- Who recorded it
- not read in this text
- The threat
- not read in this text
- The bait
- not read in this text
- The concession
- not read in this text
- The gain
- not read in this text
- The name
- not read in this text
Two kinds of start
Eight texts consulted. One printed author, in three wordings. Two texts cite him. Three do not say where they took the rules from.
names its sourcesame word, no source
Solid line: the text names its source. Dotted line: the same word, no source named.
Which wording did you see?
Tick what you find in the version you read. The page looks, among the texts consulted, for those that contain it.
03 · Other names
Other names, the same question
The same test for 18 famous names: what text exists, who gave the name, what does not follow from what was found.
Did they really say it?
- The Gerasimov doctrineA newspaper article by Russia’s chief of the General Staff, called a “doctrine” by an analyst who later apologised for the name.
- The Brezhnev doctrineTwo Soviet texts of 1968 are real. The name “Brezhnev doctrine” was given by Western analysts.
- The Monroe Doctrine and the Roosevelt CorollaryMonroe wrote in 1823 about colonisation. Roosevelt wrote in 1904 about an “international police power”. The name “doctrine” came in between.
- The Yoshida DoctrineThe name appeared in the late 1970s, not in Yoshida’s time. No speech states the three pillars.
- Nixon’s madman theoryThe “madman theory” is an aide’s quotation from 1978. The 1969 nuclear alert is in the archives, but with no written reason.
- The Overton windowThe name came after Overton’s death, and the six-degree scale is someone else’s. The model describes; it does not prove a plan.
- The repeated lie (the illusory truth effect)Repetition has a measured effect, but a small one. The “repeat a lie” quotation has no source in Goebbels.
- The cabbage strategyThe “cabbage” phrase is one commentator’s, in one interview. The layers of ships are documented; not every fishing boat is militia.
- Debt-trap diplomacyChina did not seize Hambantota port, but its loan contracts carry confidentiality clauses rare elsewhere.
- “Escalate to de-escalate”Russian doctrine does not contain the phrase. The Russian texts are real, and the 2024 one widens the conditions for nuclear use.
Did it happen that way?
- The Soviet ultimatum of June 1940The note of 26 June 1940 asked for a reply “during 27 June”. The deadlines, on paper.
- The 1944 percentages agreementChurchill’s sheet exists, but it was informal, unsigned and covered five Balkan states, not Eastern Europe.
- Cuba 1962 and the Jupiter missilesThe public letter said nothing about Turkey. In the evening Robert Kennedy told the Soviet ambassador something else.
- Operation Fortitude and the agent GARBOTwenty-seven sub-agents existed only on paper. The Germans kept divisions in the Pas-de-Calais, but no one measures GARBO’s share.
- Curveball: one source, many reportsAlmost a hundred reports, one source. The 2005 commission: corroboration must be told from repetition.
Does it work?
- Anchoring in negotiationThe first demand pulls the result towards it, but extreme demands can lead to impasse, and thinking about the other side’s alternatives removes the effect.
- The threat that leaves something to chance (Schelling)Schelling: saying you may tip the boat is unconvincing; the risk must be real. He does not say any leader used or should use the method.
- The security dilemmaThe security dilemma explains a vicious circle, not who is right. Jervis himself warns against applying it to an aggressor.
Any other name, in five questions
Have you met a “doctrine” or a rule attributed to someone? Answer the five questions: the result says what you can state and what you cannot, and you can send it on.
- Have I opened a dated text from the time (an act, a speech, a document, an archive) that says what the label claims?
- Did the people who did the thing use the name themselves?
- Do I know who coined the name, and when?
- Do I have at least two sources that do not cite each other?
- Can I say what observation would show my explanation to be wrong?
Sources and method
Every statement on these pages has a consulted, dated source. Quotations are short, word for word, in the text’s own language; the translations are Marius Comper’s.
The order in which Mlechin printed the three wordings has not been established, and page 306 and the exact edition of the Primakov biography could not be confirmed. The book appeared in 1999; the text consulted is from a newer edition (photo captions carry dates up to 2006).
Each name gets two labels, one for the name and one for the deed. A name and a deed can be of different kinds: “the Brezhnev doctrine” is a label put by American analysts on real Soviet texts.
The five kinds of evidence
- Official text
- A text signed or spoken by an official or an institution: a law, a declaration, a speech, a document, a commander’s article. Being official does not mean it was adopted as policy.
- Documented act
- Something that happened and left contemporary traces: documents, logs, cables, maps, testimony.
- Tested model
- A mechanism described in a scientific paper or an experiment, with the conditions where it holds and where it does not.
- Recollection
- Something a person wrote or told after the event: memoirs, biographies, interviews, anecdotes.
- Label given by others
- A name coined by people other than those who did the thing, usually later and often by adversaries or analysts.
Sources
- 1Andrei Gromyko (biographical data)
Wikipedia (secondary source) · opened 14 November 2026 - 2Telegram from the American embassy on a conversation with Gromyko, 1959 (doc. 449)
1959 · FRUS 1958–1960, vol. VIII · opened 14 November 2026 - 3Informal meeting of EU Heads of State or Government: press remarks by High Representative Kaja Kallas, 13 November 2026
Kaja Kallas · 2026 · EEAS · opened 14 November 2026 - 4Prime Minister’s political statement on the security situation in Europe, 19 January 2022
Kaja Kallas · 2022 · Guvernul Estoniei · opened 14 November 2026 - 5Comment négocie Poutine ? Comprendre la doctrine Gromyko
2025 · Le Grand Continent, 12 august 2025 · opened 14 November 2026 - 6Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases
Amos Tversky, Daniel Kahneman · 1974 · Science 185 · opened 14 November 2026 - 7First Offers as Anchors: The Role of Perspective-Taking and Negotiator Focus (rezumat)
Adam D. Galinsky, Thomas Mussweiler · 2001 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81(4) · opened 14 November 2026 - 8Starting high and ending with nothing: the role of anchors and power in negotiations (rezumat)
Schweinsberg și colegii · 2012 · Journal of Experimental Social Psychology · opened 14 November 2026 - 9The June/July 1940 Romanian Withdrawal from Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina
report hosted by Yad Vashem · opened 14 November 2026 - 10The Soviet ultimatum notes (texts of the notes, reproduced without naming the archive)
Ionuț Cojocaru · 2020 · history blog · opened 14 November 2026 - 11The Strategy of Conflict (1980 paperback printing of the 1960 book)
Thomas C. Schelling · 1960 · Harvard University Press · opened 14 November 2026 - 12Arms and Influence, cap. 3, „The Manipulation of Risk”
Thomas C. Schelling · 1966 · Yale University Press · opened 14 November 2026 - 13Khrushchev to Kennedy, 27 October 1962 (doc. 66)
1962 · FRUS 1961–1963, vol. VI · opened 14 November 2026 - 14Kennedy to Khrushchev, 27 October 1962 (doc. 67)
1962 · FRUS 1961–1963, vol. VI · opened 14 November 2026 - 15Anatomy of a Controversy: Anatoly F. Dobrynin’s Meeting with Robert F. Kennedy, Saturday, 27 October 1962
James G. Hershberg · 1995 · CWIHP Bulletin 5, Wilson Center · opened 14 November 2026 - 16Jupiter Missiles and the Cuban Missile Crisis Endgame (dismantling timeline)
2023 · National Security Archive · opened 14 November 2026 - 17The Jupiter Missiles and the Endgame of the Cuban Missile Crisis
2023 · National Security Archive · opened 14 November 2026 - 18BATNAs in negotiation (paper on origin and limits)
James K. Sebenius · Harvard DASH · opened 14 November 2026 - 19Paper on private information in negotiation
University of Maryland · opened 14 November 2026 - 20Евгений Примаков: история одной карьеры (bibliographic record: Tsentrpoligraf, 1999, ISBN 5-227-00260-6)
Leonid Mlecin · 1999 · Open Library · opened 14 November 2026 - 21Leonid Mlechin, the Primakov biography, part five (online text of an edition later than 2004)
Leonid Mlecin · Wikireading (online copy) · opened 14 November 2026 - 22Oleg Grinevsky (biographical data)
Wikipedia (secondary source) · opened 14 November 2026 - 23Leonid Mlechin, MID. Foreign ministers. The Kremlin’s secret diplomacy, chapter “Искусство выжимания лимона”
Leonid Mlecin · Wikireading (online copy) · opened 14 November 2026 - 24Leonid Mlechin, Секреты российской дипломатии. От Громыко до Лаврова, page 23 of the online reader
Leonid Mlecin · 2019 · Loveread (online copy) · opened 14 November 2026 - 25Залужный: чего не написал экс-глава в своей статье об Андрее Громыке
2025 · UNIAN, 12 noiembrie 2025 · opened 14 November 2026 - 26Demand everything, threaten war. Someone in the West will always take the bait: How will Putin negotiate?
2025 · Fakti.bg, 21 august 2025 · opened 14 November 2026 - 27Три правила переговоров (Pikabu page, 16 May 2025)
2025 · Pikabu · opened 14 November 2026