Doctrines and legendsROEN

Real texts, names given later

The Monroe Doctrine: the name came 25 to 30 years later

The messages of 1823 and 1904 are real. The words “doctrine” and “corollary” were added later.

The name: Label given by othersThe deed: Official textWhat do the labels mean?

What the documents show

  • In his message of 2 December 1823 Monroe wrote that the American continents are no longer to be subjects for future colonisation by European powers, that the US has not interfered and will not interfere with existing colonies, and that it would regard any extension of the European system in the hemisphere as dangerous to its peace and safety.1

    The source’s words

    With the existing colonies or dependencies of any European power we have not interfered and shall not interfere.

    Monroe Doctrine; December 2, 1823 (message of the President)
  • The name came 25 to 30 years later. The sources opened give three years: 1850, 1852 or 1853. The Council on Foreign Relations writes that no one called it a “doctrine” until 1852; the Oxford Companion says it was only by the 1850s that the messages were regarded as the basis of the so-called Monroe Doctrine. Who coined the name has not been established.234

    The source’s words

    No one called it a “doctrine” until 1852…

    Monroe Doctrine
  • Polk took the principle up in his message of 2 December 1845, saying he wished to “reiterate and reaffirm the principle avowed by Mr. Monroe” regarding European colonies in North America.5

    The source’s words

    reiterate and reaffirm the principle avowed by Mr. Monroe…

    First Annual Message, 2 December 1845
  • Theodore Roosevelt, in his fourth annual message (6 December 1904), wrote that a country that keeps order and pays its obligations need fear no interference from the US. Adherence to the Monroe Doctrine may, however, force the US, “however reluctantly”, to exercise “an international police power” in flagrant cases of wrongdoing or impotence.6

    The source’s words

    in flagrant cases of such wrongdoing or impotence, to the exercise of an international police power…

    Fourth Annual Message, 6 December 1904
  • The 1904 message contains no word “corollary” and does not name Santo Domingo. The application is in the message of 5 December 1905: the Dominican Republic’s customs receipts were divided, 45 per cent to the government and 55 per cent into a safe depository. Roosevelt writes that it is of no consequence whether the aid to Santo Domingo is given “as an incident to the wise development of the Monroe Doctrine” or because the case stands wholly by itself.7

    The source’s words

    as an incident to the wise development of the Monroe Doctrine…

    Fifth Annual Message, 5 December 1905
  • AttributedThe name “Roosevelt Corollary” is also later. The U.S. National Archives write “so-called Roosevelt Corollary”, and the State Department’s Office of the Historian writes that his policy came to be known by it. The first use of the name has not been established.89

    The source’s words

    This so-called Roosevelt Corollary—a corollary is an extension of a previous idea…

    Roosevelt Corollary (Milestone Documents)

What does not follow

  • That Monroe spoke of a “doctrine” in 1823: the word is not in the message and appears about three decades later.
  • That the 1904 message names the “corollary” or Santo Domingo.
  • That the two texts say the same thing: the first rejects European colonisation, the second describes a US police power in the hemisphere.

Who coined the name, and when

  1. 2 December 1823Monroe sends his message to Congress.1
  2. 2 December 1845Polk takes up the principle in his annual message.5
  3. 1850–1853The 1823 message begins to be called the “Monroe Doctrine”; sources give 1850, 1852 or 1853.234
  4. 6 December 1904Roosevelt speaks of “an international police power”.6
  5. 2 more dates
    1. 5 December 1905Roosevelt writes that it does not matter whether aid to Santo Domingo is part of the Monroe Doctrine or a case standing by itself.7
    2. after 1905The policy comes to be called the “Roosevelt Corollary”. The first use has not been established.8

Sources

  1. 1Monroe Doctrine; December 2, 1823 (message of the President)
    James Monroe · 1823 · Avalon Project, Yale Law School · opened 14 November 2026
  2. 2Monroe Doctrine
    Council on Foreign Relations · opened 14 November 2026
  3. 3Monroe Doctrine
    Wikipedia (secondary source) · opened 14 November 2026
  4. 4Monroe Doctrine (Oxford Companion to United States History)
    2018 · Encyclopedia.com · opened 14 November 2026
  5. 5First Annual Message, 2 December 1845
    James K. Polk · 1845 · The American Presidency Project, UCSB · opened 14 November 2026
  6. 6Fourth Annual Message, 6 December 1904
    Theodore Roosevelt · 1904 · The American Presidency Project, UCSB · opened 14 November 2026
  7. 7Fifth Annual Message, 5 December 1905
    Theodore Roosevelt · 1905 · The American Presidency Project, UCSB · opened 14 November 2026
  8. 8Roosevelt Corollary (Milestone Documents)
    U.S. National Archives · opened 14 November 2026
  9. 9Roosevelt Corollary, 1904
    Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State · opened 14 November 2026

See also