Doctrines and legendsROEN

A model, not an excuse

The security dilemma: what the model explains and what it does not

The model describes a spiral of tension. It does not say who is right and does not excuse aggression.

The name: Tested modelThe deed: Tested modelWhat do the labels mean?

What the documents show

  • John Herz formulated the idea in 1950: groups or individuals that seek security are driven to acquire more and more power to escape the impact of the power of others, and the vicious circle of security and power accumulation is on.1

    The source’s words

    they are driven to acquire more and more power in order to escape the impact of the power of others…

    Idealist Internationalism and the Security Dilemma (abstract), abstract
  • Robert Jervis wrote in 1978: many of the means by which a state tries to increase its security decrease the security of others.2

    The source’s words

    many of the means by which a state tries to increase its security decrease the security of others…

    Cooperation under the Security Dilemma, p. 169
  • Jervis shows in his abstract when the dilemma eases: when defence has the advantage over offence and when defensive postures differ from offensive ones.3

    The source’s words

    the security dilemma is ameliorated when the defense has the advantage over the offense and when defensive postures differ from offensive ones…

    Cooperation under the Security Dilemma (abstract), abstract
  • The model does not excuse an aggressor. Jervis himself describes the risk that a state will treat an aggressor as though it were an insecure defender of the status quo.2

    The source’s words

    will treat an aggressor as though it were an insecure defender of the status quo…

    Cooperation under the Security Dilemma, p. 183
  • On 2 March 2022 the UN General Assembly “deplored in the strongest terms the aggression by the Russian Federation against Ukraine”, by 141 votes to five with 35 abstentions (resolution ES-11/1). The resolution reaffirms Ukraine’s territorial integrity within its internationally recognized borders.45

    The source’s words

    Deplores in the strongest terms the aggression by the Russian Federation against Ukraine in violation of Article 2 (4) of the Charter…

    Resolution ES-11/1, Aggression against Ukraine, 2 March 2022, resolution ES-11/1, operative paragraph
  • InterpretationScholars disagree on the causes of the war. John Mearsheimer writes in Foreign Affairs (2014) that the United States and its European allies share most of the responsibility for the crisis; the article does not use the phrase “security dilemma”. James Goldgeier and Brian D. Taylor write in 2025 that the case that NATO’s actions caused the war is difficult to sustain.67

    The source’s words

    The case that NATO’s actions caused the war is difficult to sustain…

    NATO Did Not Cause Putin’s Imperial War (The Washington Quarterly 48(4)), paragraph de deschidere

What does not follow

  • That the model justifies or excuses aggression: Jervis warns precisely against reading an aggressor as an insecure defender.
  • That the model shows who is to blame for a war: it says something about the spiral of tension, not about law or legitimacy.
  • That scholars agree the war in Ukraine is a security-dilemma case: they differ.

Who coined the name, and when

  1. 1950John Herz describes the “security dilemma” in World Politics.1
  2. 1978Robert Jervis publishes “Cooperation under the Security Dilemma”.2
  3. 2 March 2022The UN General Assembly deplores Russia’s aggression against Ukraine (141 for, 5 against, 35 abstentions).45

Sources

  1. 1Idealist Internationalism and the Security Dilemma (abstract)
    John H. Herz · 1950 · World Politics · opened 14 November 2026
  2. 2Cooperation under the Security Dilemma
    Robert Jervis · 1978 · World Politics 30(2) · opened 14 November 2026
  3. 3Cooperation under the Security Dilemma (abstract)
    Robert Jervis · 1978 · World Politics 30(2) · opened 14 November 2026
  4. 4Resolution ES-11/1, Aggression against Ukraine, 2 March 2022
    2022 · UN General Assembly · opened 14 November 2026
  5. 5General Assembly resolution demands end to Russian offensive in Ukraine
    2022 · UN News, 2 March 2022 · opened 14 November 2026
  6. 6Why the Ukraine Crisis Is the West’s Fault
    John J. Mearsheimer · 2014 · Foreign Affairs, September–October 2014 · opened 14 November 2026
  7. 7NATO Did Not Cause Putin’s Imperial War (The Washington Quarterly 48(4))
    James Goldgeier, Brian D. Taylor · 2025 · The Washington Quarterly · opened 14 November 2026

See also