Doctrines and legendsROEN

A name from a critic, real lending practices

The debt trap: researchers find no seizure at Hambantota

Chinese loan contracts do, however, carry confidentiality clauses rare elsewhere.

The name: Label given by othersThe deed: Documented actWhat do the labels mean?

What the documents show

  • AttributedThe oldest text found that uses the phrase is an article by the Indian commentator Brahma Chellaney of January 2017 (24 January in The Strategist, according to Chatham House; 25 January on his blog): countries “are becoming ensnared in a debt trap that leaves them vulnerable to China’s influence”.12

    The source’s words

    countries are becoming ensnared in a debt trap that leaves them vulnerable to China’s influence…

    China’s Debt-Trap Diplomacy, first paragraph
  • Hambantota port was leased for 99 years to China Merchants Port; operations were officially launched on 9 December 2017. The figures differ: 70 per cent of the port (Al Jazeera, 29 July 2017), 85 per cent of the port company’s shares for $973.7 million (Chatham House).342

    The source’s words

    Sri Lanka Ports Authority agreed to sell a 70 percent stake in the Hambantota port to China Merchants Ports Holdings.

    Sri Lanka signs Hambantota port deal with China
  • Chatham House (Jones and Hameiri, 2020) writes that China did not propose the port and that the project was largely driven by Sri Lankan actors for domestic reasons. The Chinese money was used to stabilise foreign reserves and to service debts to other creditors.2

    The source’s words

    China did not propose the port; the project was overwhelmingly driven by Sri Lankan actors for their own domestic purposes…

    Debunking the Myth of “Debt-trap Diplomacy”, conclusion on Hambantota
  • Of the Sri Lankan government’s debt, Chinese loans were only 9 per cent in 2016, excluding borrowing by state-owned enterprises and with the authors’ caveat that data irregularities make the share hard to establish, according to the same paper.2

    The source’s words

    Chinese loans comprised just 9 per cent of Sri Lankan government debt by 2016…

    Debunking the Myth of “Debt-trap Diplomacy”, p. 16
  • AttributedDeborah Brautigam and Meg Rithmire write, in an opinion article, that Chinese banks have never actually seized an asset from any country, much less the port of Hambantota.5

    The source’s words

    have never actually seized an asset from any country, much less the port of Hambantota…

    The Chinese “Debt Trap” Is a Myth (reprint of The Atlantic piece)
  • What stands: a study of 100 Chinese contracts (Gelpern and colleagues, 2022) found unusual confidentiality clauses that restrict what borrowers can say about the terms. Only two of the 142 contracts in the comparison sample have comparable clauses. The authors say the study does not systematically address contract enforcement.6

    The source’s words

    Only 2 of the 142 contracts in the benchmark sample contain potentially comparable confidentiality clauses.

    How China Lends: A Rare Look into 100 Debt Contracts with Foreign Governments, introduction, p. 6
  • Cases of heavy borrowing wrapped in secrecy exist: in Montenegro a highway financed by a Chinese loan of about a billion dollars left a debt hard to repay, and in Zambia hidden loans made it impossible for other creditors to learn their size. Another case shows the opposite: the three published loan contracts for Kenya’s railway did not pledge Mombasa port as collateral; the other contracts have not been released.789

    The source’s words

    Lungu’s secretive borrowing from China made it impossible for other creditors to establish the scale of the loans.

    Zambia on the brink of historic debt relief deal
  • AttributedThe term was taken up by American officials. Mike Pence said on 4 October 2018 that Hambantota “may soon become a forward military base” for China’s navy; Mike Pompeo repeated in 2019 that he wanted “transparent transactions, not debt traps”. In July 2018 China’s foreign ministry called the port the wish of Sri Lanka’s governments and people, and in October 2020, in Colombo, Sri Lankan officials rejected the idea, according to the AP.10111213

    The source’s words

    It may soon become a forward military base for China’s growing blue-water navy.

    Remarks by Vice President Pence on the Administration’s Policy Toward China

What does not follow

  • That China seized Hambantota or another port for unpaid debt: no research source opened documents a seizure, though Pence asserted a handover.
  • That the lease wiped out the debt to China: Chatham House writes that no debt was forgiven.
  • That Chinese lending is harmless: the confidentiality clauses and the cases of Montenegro and Zambia show real risk.
  • That the term was invented in Beijing: the oldest text found is by an Indian commentator.

Who coined the name, and when

  1. 2005 or 2007The first Chinese loan for Hambantota port. The same paper gives 2005 in its table and 2007 in its text.2
  2. 25 January 2017Chellaney publishes “China’s Debt-Trap Diplomacy”.1
  3. 29 July 2017The 99-year lease agreement is signed.3
  4. 9 December 2017Operation of the port officially begins, through a joint venture of the Sri Lanka Ports Authority and China Merchants Port Holdings.4
  5. 3 more dates
    1. 4 October 2018Pence speaks of “China’s debt-trap diplomacy” at the Hudson Institute.10
    2. 19 August 2020Chatham House publishes the Jones–Hameiri paper.2
    3. April 2022The study of 100 Chinese loan contracts is presented.6

Sources

  1. 1China’s Debt-Trap Diplomacy
    Brahma Chellaney · 2017 · the author’s blog, after Project Syndicate, 25 January 2017 · opened 14 November 2026
  2. 2Debunking the Myth of “Debt-trap Diplomacy”
    Lee Jones, Shahar Hameiri · 2020 · Chatham House, 19 August 2020 · opened 14 November 2026
  3. 3Sri Lanka signs Hambantota port deal with China
    2017 · Al Jazeera, 29 July 2017 · opened 14 November 2026
  4. 4Hambantota Port operations launched
    2017 · Xinhua, 27 December 2017 · opened 14 November 2026
  5. 5The Chinese “Debt Trap” Is a Myth (reprint of The Atlantic piece)
    Deborah Brautigam, Meg Rithmire · 2021 · The Daily FT, 8 February 2021 · opened 14 November 2026
  6. 6How China Lends: A Rare Look into 100 Debt Contracts with Foreign Governments
    Anna Gelpern, Sebastian Horn, Scott Morris, Brad Parks, Christoph Trebesch · 2022 · Economic Policy, panel paper, April 2022 · opened 14 November 2026
  7. 7No Clear Option For Montenegro As It Tries To Repay $1 Billion Highway Debt To China
    2021 · RFE/RL, 14 April 2021 · opened 14 November 2026
  8. 8Zambia on the brink of historic debt relief deal
    2022 · ISS Today · opened 14 November 2026
  9. 9Kenya’s standard gauge railway contracts: what released documents say and what they don’t
    echipa CARI · 2022 · The Conversation, 11 November 2022 · opened 14 November 2026
  10. 10Remarks by Vice President Pence on the Administration’s Policy Toward China
    Mike Pence · 2018 · Hudson Institute, 4 October 2018 · opened 14 November 2026
  11. 11US Secretary of State criticizes China’s South China Sea practices (remarks in Houston, 12 March 2019)
    Mike Pompeo · 2019 · IMOA, reprint · opened 14 November 2026
  12. 12Pompeo brings anti-China roadshow to Indian Ocean islands
    2020 · AP, 28 October 2020 · opened 14 November 2026
  13. 13China refutes so-called “debt trap” over Sri Lanka’s Hambantota port project
    2018 · CGTN · opened 14 November 2026

See also