Geography IX RO

Chapter 3 · Inside the EarthLesson 3.5Humanities track

Mineral resources and the environmental problems of extraction

What remains after a mine’s ore has been extracted and sold?

Before you read: what do you think?

In January 2000, a dam holding back a cyanide pond broke near Baia Mare. How far did the pollution travel?

See the answer

As far as the Black Sea. The cyanide-laced water flowed down the Lăpuș, Someș, Tisza and Danube, through Romania, Hungary and what was then Yugoslavia (now Serbia), to the Black Sea. Damage from a mine can reach hundreds of kilometres away.

On 30 January 2000, near Baia Mare, the dam of a pond holding cyanide-laced water from a gold plant broke along a stretch of about 25 m. Around 100,000 m³ of poisoned water reached the rivers. The pollution travelled down the Someș and the Tisza to the Danube and the Black Sea.

What mining leaves behind

After the ore has been extracted and sold, the open pit, hills of discarded rock and ponds of processing sludge remain. An open pit strips soil and forest from large areas and changes the landforms. Valueless rock removed alongside the ore, known as waste rock, is piled into spoil heaps: artificial hills that can slip and from which rain washes dust and metals.

During processing, ore is crushed and treated with water and chemicals. The sludge left over is stored in tailings ponds, lakes enclosed by dams where particles settle to the bottom. If a dam fails, the contents reach the rivers. Water passing through mine tunnels and spoil heaps can become acidic and carry heavy metals into rivers for many years after the mine closes.

Case study: the Baia Mare accident

The Aurul plant in Baia Mare extracted gold from old waste rock using cyanide, a highly toxic substance. After rain and melting snow, the water level in the pond rose and the dam broke. Cyanide-laced water reached the Lăpuș River, then the Someș, Tisza and Danube, passing through Romania, Hungary and what was then Yugoslavia (now Serbia).

The accident showed that a tailings pond poses a risk to every country downstream and that damage can reach hundreds of kilometres from the mine.

For the curious

The first dead fish were reported at Satu Mare, and eight wells in a village near the pond were contaminated.

Baia Mare 30 January 2000 Someș Tisza Danube HUNGARY ROMANIA SERBIA Black Sea
Figure 1The route of the pollution along the rivers’ actual courses: from the Baia Mare pond along the Lăpuș to the Someș, then down the Tisza and Danube to the Black Sea. The damage crossed three countries.

Three groups of mineral resources

Gold from Baia Mare, coal from the Jiu Valley and salt from Praid are mineral resources: minerals and rocks from the crust that people extract and use. A place where such a substance has accumulated in a quantity large enough to be worth extracting is called a deposit. Mineral resources are non-renewable: they form over millions of years and are consumed in tens or hundreds of years.

By use, they fall into three groups. Energy resources provide heat and electricity: coal, oil, natural gas and uranium. Metallic resources are ores, rocks from which metals are extracted: iron, copper, aluminium (from bauxite), lead, zinc, gold and silver. Non-metallic resources include salt, sulphur and building materials: limestone, marble, granite, clay and sand.

Where Romania’s resources are found

There are two main types of coal. Hard coal, an older coal with a high calorific value, is found in the Jiu Valley, in the Petroșani basin, and is extracted from deep mines. Lignite, a younger coal with a low calorific value, is found in Oltenia, in the Rovinari and Motru basins. These contain 95% of the country’s lignite deposits, and more than 80% of them can be mined at the surface in open pits.

Oil and its associated natural gas are extracted from the Subcarpathians, the Romanian Plain and the Black Sea shelf. Methane is found in the Transylvanian Depression. Salt is mined at Slănic, Praid, Ocna Dej, Târgu Ocna, Cacica and Ocna Mureș. Gold and silver ores are found in the Apuseni Mountains, around Roșia Montană and Brad, and in the Baia Mare area.

For the curious

The hard coal mines in the Jiu Valley are closing one after another.

Jiu Valley Rovinari Motru Slănic Praid Ocna Dej Târgu Ocna Cacica Ocna Mureș Roșia Montană Brad Baia Mare methane oil and gas hard coal lignite salt gold and silver
Figure 2Coal lies in the south-west, gold in the Apuseni Mountains and around Baia Mare, and methane in central Transylvania. Salt occurs on both sides of the Carpathians, while oil and gas follow the arc of the Subcarpathians, the Romanian Plain and the Black Sea shelf. Oil and gas areas are shown approximately.

Worked example

How much is 100,000 m³?

To picture the roughly 100,000 m³ released from the Baia Mare pond, compare it with an Olympic swimming pool.

An Olympic pool is 50 m long and 25 m wide; at a depth of 2 m, its volume is 50 × 25 × 2 = 2,500 m³. Divide the volume released by the volume of one pool: 100,000 ÷ 2,500 = 40.

The water released from the pond would therefore fill 40 Olympic pools. The calculation shows only the amount of water. The danger came from what was dissolved in it: cyanide kills fish at very low concentrations, so the pollution remained dangerous long after it mixed with river water.

In Romania

Roșia Montană, from mine to World Heritage

At Roșia Montană in the Apuseni Mountains, gold was extracted for almost two thousand years. More than 7 km of underground galleries dug in antiquity, in Roman times, have so far been discovered beneath the mountain. At the surface, mining left summits cut away by open pits, spoil heaps and artificial lakes called tăuri, made for washing ore.

A proposal for a modern open pit using cyanide was contested for years. In July 2021, the Roșia Montană mining landscape was inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List. The same place shows both the gain and the cost of a mineral resource: wealth taken from the ground and the marks extraction leaves on landforms, water and community life.

In brief

  1. Mineral resources are minerals and rocks extracted from the crust; they are non-renewable and occur in deposits.
  2. They fall into energy resources (coal, oil, natural gas), metallic resources (iron, copper and gold ores, bauxite) and non-metallic resources (salt, building materials).
  3. In Romania, hard coal is found in the Jiu Valley and lignite in Oltenia; oil and gas in the Subcarpathians, Romanian Plain and Black Sea; methane in Transylvania; salt at Slănic and Praid; gold in the Apuseni Mountains.
  4. Mining leaves open pits, spoil heaps and tailings ponds and can pollute water with heavy metals and toxic substances.
  5. At Baia Mare, on 30 January 2000, a dam breach sent about 100,000 m³ of cyanide-laced water into the Someș, Tisza and Danube.
  6. The Roșia Montană mining landscape was inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in July 2021.
Worksheet

Common mistakes

  • WrongOnce a mine closes, pollution stops.

    RightSpoil heaps, ponds and tunnels remain. Water passing through them can carry heavy metals into rivers for many years after closure.

  • WrongLignite and hard coal are the same coal with two names.

    RightHard coal is an older coal with a high calorific value, extracted from deep mines in the Jiu Valley. Lignite is younger, has a low calorific value and is extracted from open pits in Oltenia.

  • WrongMineral resources grow back if a mine is left to rest.

    RightDeposits form over millions of years. On the scale of a human lifetime, they are non-renewable.

Test yourself

Six questions. For the first five you see the explanation at once, with the paragraph of the lesson that supports it; for the ones with a written answer you compare with a good answer.

  1. Which group of mineral resources does salt belong to?

    Answer

    c) Non-metallic. Salt provides no energy and is not a metal ore; it is a non-metallic resource. No mineral resource is renewable.

  2. Where are Romania’s largest lignite deposits?

    Answer

    a) In Oltenia. The Jiu Valley has hard coal, the Apuseni Mountains have gold ores, and Transylvania has methane. Lignite is found in Oltenia.

  3. What is a tailings pond?

    Answer

    d) A lake enclosed by dams for sludge left from processing. The hill of waste rock is a spoil heap. A tailings pond holds sludge and water from processing while particles settle.

  4. Which toxic substance reached the rivers in the Baia Mare accident on 30 January 2000?

    Answer

    b) Cyanide. The plant used cyanide to extract gold from waste rock, and the pond water contained it.

  5. A swimming pool holds 2,500 m³. How many such pools could be filled with the approximately 100,000 m³ of water released from the Baia Mare pond?

    pools
    Answer

    40 pools. 100,000 m³ ÷ 2,500 m³ = 40.

  6. A copper open pit, with a spoil heap and a tailings pond upstream of a mountain village, is proposed. What three questions should residents ask before agreeing, and why?

    A good answer

    First: where will the heap and pond be placed, and what happens to the village and river if the dam fails? Water and sludge flow downhill. Second: what chemicals will be used in processing, and how will the water be cleaned before it reaches the river? Third: who will pay and take responsibility for closing the pit, covering the spoil heap and treating acidic water after extraction ends? Pollution continues for many years.

    A complete answer links the questions to the three sources of risk: the pond dam, substances in the water and the period after closure.

Terms

mineral resources
Minerals and rocks from the Earth’s crust that people extract and use as energy sources or raw materials.
deposit
A natural accumulation of useful mineral substances large enough to be extracted.
ore
Rock from which a metal can be extracted.
waste rock
Valueless rock removed from a mine or open pit alongside ore or coal.
spoil heap
A pile of waste rock forming an artificial hill beside a mine or open pit.
tailings pond
A lake enclosed by dams where sludge and water left over from ore processing are stored.
Sources and link to the programme

From the programme: “Mineral resources. Environmental problems associated with mineral resource extraction” (specialisation curriculum, humanities track). Programme competences covered: 4.2, 4.3, 5.5.

Your place

Choose your city, commune or village, and the lessons will add the example from home: how long the day lasts, when true noon falls, how far the Vrancea earthquake zone is. The choice stays on this device.