Slavic in RomanianROEN

An atlas of the Slavic words in Romanian

The Slavic part of Romanian

Romanian is a Romance language, yet its words for yes (da), to love (a iubi), friend (prieten), wife (nevastă), to read (a citi) and luck (noroc) came from the Slavs. About one basic meaning in eight is expressed with a Slavic word (12.2%, by the WOLD database), and about one word in 20–30 in subtitled dialogue.

On the maps of the 1929–1938 village survey, the words dictionaries give as Serbian were heard near Serbia. The words given as Bulgarian were heard no closer to Bulgaria than a typical regional word.

Sources: Neacșu's letter (1521), the WOLD database, DEX '98 (the standard Romanian dictionary), the Romanian Linguistic Atlas (1929–1938), 332 million words of subtitles.

Neacșu's letter, Câmpulung, 1521, the oldest dated text in Romanian · National Archives, Brașov

Câmpulung, June 1521

The oldest letter in Romanian opens and closes in Slavonic#

Neacșu of Câmpulung, in Wallachia, writes to the mayor of Brașov in Transylvania, Johannes Benkner (Hanăș Begner in the letter), that the sultan's army is moving up the Danube. It is the oldest dated text in Romanian that survives. It is written in Cyrillic letters, and it opens in Slavonic, the language in which princes' charters and church services were then written: «Mudromu i plemenitomu…», 'to the wise and noble…'. Each piece of news begins «I pak», 'and again'. Câmpulung itself appears under its Slavonic name, Dlugopole, 'the long field'.

Of the letter's 245 words, 36 are Slavonic. Of its 192 Romanian words, seven came from Slavic: corăbii 'ships' (three times), boiari 'boyars', voia 'the will', păziți 'guard', slobozie 'leave, freedom'. Nearly all the rest are inherited from Latin: dau știre 'I give word', am auzit 'I have heard', împăratul 'the emperor', oamini 'men'. The Romanian of 1521 already had its Slavic part, and its writing was still framed by Slavonic.

Neacșu's letter from Câmpulung, 1521: a handwritten sheet in Cyrillic letters, 19 lines.
Neacșu's letter, National Archives of Romania, Brașov County Service. Public-domain photograph, Wikimedia Commons.

мⷹдромⷹ и племенитомꙋ и чиститомꙋ и бгѡⷨ дарованномꙋ жꙋпаⷩ ханьⷲ беⷢнеⷬ ѿ брашоⷡ мноⷢ(о)зⷣравїь ѿ нѣⷦшꙋⷧ ѿ длъгополе ипаⷦ даꙋ щире доⷨнїе тале за лꙋкрꙋⷧ тꙋⷬчилоⷬ кꙋⷨ амьаꙋзиⷮ еꙋ къ ꙟпъратꙋⷧ аꙋ ешиⷮ деⷩ софїѧ ши аимиⷩтрѣ нꙋ е ши сѣꙋ дꙋⷭ ꙟ сꙋⷭпре дꙋнъре ипаⷦ съ щїи доⷨнїꙗ та къ аꙋ вениⷮ ꙋⷩ ѡⷨ де ла никопое де мїе мѣⷹспꙋⷭ къ аꙋ възꙋⷮ кꙋ ѡ̈кїи лои къ аꙋ трекꙋⷮ чѣле корабїи че щїи ши доⷨнїꙗ та предꙋнъре ꙟ сꙋⷭ ипаⷦ съ щїи къ багъ ден тоте ѡрашеле къте м҃ де ѡмиⷩ съ ?фїе ꙟн ажꙋтоⷬ ꙟ корабїи ипаⷦ съ щїи кꙋмꙋ сѣꙋ принсъ не ще меⷲщеⷬ деⷩ ц(а)риграⷣ кꙋⷨ ворь трѣче ачѣле корабїи ла локꙋⷧ чела (ст)римтꙋⷧ че щїи ши доⷨниꙗ таипаⷦ спꙋн доⷨнїе тале лꙋкрꙋⷧ лꙋ махамеⷮ беⷢ кꙋⷨ амь аꙋзиⷮ де боѧри че сънть меџїꙗⷲши де џенере мїꙋ негре кꙋмꙋ ѧꙋ даⷮ ꙟпъратꙋⷧ слобозїе лꙋ махамеⷮ беⷢ пре (иꙋ) иѡи вафи воѧ прен цѣра рꙋмънѣскъ ꙗръ ель съ трѣкъ ипаⷦ съ щїи доⷨнїꙗ та къ арефрикъ маре ши бъсърабь де ачеⷧ лотрꙋ де махамеⷮ беⷢ маꙵ въртоⷭ де доⷨнїеле воⷭтреипаⷦ спꙋн доⷨнїе тале ка маꙵ мареле мїꙋ де че амь ꙟцелеⷭ шї еꙋ еꙋ спꙋн доⷨнїе тале ѧръдоⷨнїꙗ та ещи ꙟцелепть ши ачѣсте кꙋвиⷩте съ цїи доⷨниа та ла тине съ нꙋ щїеꙋмиⷩ мулци ши доⷨнїеле ноⷭтре съ въ пъзици кꙋⷨ щици маꙵ бине и б(ог)ь те веⷭ(е)лиⷮ амїⷩъ

Mudromu I plemenitomu, I cistitomu I B(o)gom darovannomu zupan Hanăș Begner ot Brașov mnog(o) zdravie ot Nécșul ot Dlugopole. I pak dau știre domnietale za lucrul turcilor, cum am auzit eu că împăratul au ieșit den Sofiia și aimintrea nu e. Și se-au dus în sus pre Dunăre. I pak să știi domniia-ta că au venit un om de la Nicopoe de mie mi-au spus că au văzut cu ochii lui că au trecut ceale corăbii ce știi și domniia-ta pre Dunăre în sus. I pak să știi că bagă den toate orașele câte de oamini să fie în ajutor în corăbii. I pak să știi cumu se-au prins nește meșteri den Țarigrad cum vor treace aceale corabii la locul cela strimtul ce știi și domniia ta. I pak spui domnietale de lucrul lu Mahamet-Beg, cum am auzit de boiari ce sânt megiiaș(i) și de genere-miu Negre, cumu i-au dat împăratul slobozie lui Mahamet-Beg, pre io-i va fi voia pren Țeara Rumânească, iară el să treacă. I pak să știi domniia ta că are frică mare și Băsărab de acel lotru de Mahamet-Beg, mai vârtos de domniele voastre. I pak spui domnietale ca mai-marele miu de ce am înțeles și eu. Eu spui domnietale, iară domniia ta ești înțelept și aceaste cuvinte să ții domniiata la tine, să nu știe oamini mulți și domniele vostre să vă păziți cum știți mai bine. I B(og)i te ves(e)lit, Aminu.

  • Slavonic (another language, not Romanian)
  • Romanian word of Slavic origin
  • inherited from Latin
  • from Hungarian, Turkish, Greek
  • name

The text in the Cyrillic of the time, after the Wikisource transcription; below, the reading in modern letters. Tap a coloured word to see where it came from.

Three measurements

How much of Romanian is Slavic?#

The answer depends on what is counted, and the differences are large. The three measurements below use open sources and the same rule for every donor language.

12.2%

of basic meanings

Of the 1,454 meanings on the WOLD list (earth, fire, to love, hammer, friend), about one in eight is expressed with a word borrowed from the Slavs, when each meaning counts once and its words share its point. 19.3% of meanings have at least one Slavic word.

2,503

words borrowed directly, in DEX '98

7.5% of the dictionary's loanwords. French gave nearly eight times as many (19,735), nearly all of them book words.

3.5–4.6%

of spoken words

About one word in 20–30, counted in 332 million words of subtitles. Among the most frequent: a trebui ‘must’, nevoie ‘need’, prea ‘too’, prieten ‘friend’, grijă ‘worry, care’, a iubi ‘to love’, drum ‘road’, a primi ‘to receive’, tocmai ‘just’, treabă ‘business, job’, ciudat ‘strange’, a opri ‘to stop’, a plăti ‘to pay’, a omorî ‘to kill’.

The most used words (to be, to have, I, you, and, not, what, which) are Latin, so in speech the Slavic part shrinks. Among the basic things a language names, though, one in eight has a Slavic name. In the dictionary French outnumbers all other donors, through the thousands of school, science and administration terms.

One word cannot be settled by counting: da. As 'yes' it is Slavic; as a form of the verb a da 'to give' it is Latin, and a count of word forms cannot tell them apart. On its own, da is 0.6% of everything said. Without it and without the words DEX '98 only compares with Slavic, the Slavic part is 3.5%; with them and with the forms the dictionary cannot tell apart, 4.6%. Both figures include words made in Romanian with a Slavic suffix, such as fetiță 'little girl'.

What the Slavic words named

To love is Slavic. Brother and sister are Latin.#

Each stitch of the sampler below is one basic meaning from the WOLD list, and each panel is one domain. Red stitches are meanings expressed mostly with Slavic words, black ones with a word inherited from Latin, blue ones with a loan from another language, pale ones with a word made in Romanian.

Red gathers in tools and crafts (a lovi 'to hit', a clădi 'to build', ciocan 'hammer', topor 'axe', nicovală 'anvil'), in the field (grădină 'garden', gard 'fence', lopată 'shovel', coasă 'scythe', a cosi 'to mow'), in people and power (prieten 'friend', stăpân 'master', slugă 'servant', rob 'slave', graniță 'border', obicei 'custom') and in feelings (a iubi 'to love', noroc 'luck', milă 'pity', jale 'grief', grijă 'worry', vină 'guilt'). It is almost absent from close kinship (brother, sister, son and uncle are Latin), from function words and from the words for where things are.

  • from Slavic
  • inherited from Latin
  • from another language
  • made in Romanian
Tap a stitch to see the word.

A stitch is red when Slavic words carry at least half of how the meaning is said. 15.0% of stitches are red, more than the 12.2% above, where each meaning shares its point among its words. The figure in each panel's corner is its share of red stitches.

When, and from whom

First the early Slavs, then the neighbours#

The first words entered between the 6th and 12th centuries, from the Slavs who settled among the ancestors of the Romanians and in time came to speak Romanian. The linguist Alexandru Rosetti shows that these old words carry the features of north-eastern Bulgarian. Of the 309 Slavic entries on the WOLD list, 179 are dated to the 6th–13th centuries, and for none of them does Kim Schulte name a particular Slavic language: a iubi 'to love', prieten 'friend', nevastă 'wife', noroc 'luck', a citi 'to read', glas 'voice', and also sfânt 'holy', iad 'hell', duh 'spirit', a blagoslovi 'to bless', a posti 'to fast'.

Then, until the 17th century, Slavonic was the written language of the church and of the princes of Wallachia and Moldavia. Neacșu's letter shows how it framed writing in Romanian.

After the 13th century, the words come from particular neighbours (Rosetti, p. 283). Of the 115 Slavic entries WOLD dates to the 11th–18th centuries, 81 have a named donor: 60 Bulgarian (grijă 'worry', obicei 'custom', graniță 'border', sărac 'poor', școală 'school', da 'yes'), 10 Ukrainian (ciubotă 'boot', lan 'field', buhai 'bull'), 9 Serbian (zgomot 'noise', pernă 'pillow', haine 'clothes'). DEX '98 gives 353 words from Russian. For another 191 words such as activ or escadron it lists Russian next to French; these are counted apart here because they came mainly from French.

Words borrowed directly from a Slavic language, by the etymology note in DEX '98
Old Slavic1,063Bulgarian459Russian353Serbian / Croatian301Ukrainian256Polish69
DEX writes 'sl.' for both the spoken Old Slavic and the church's Slavonic; the dictionary does not tell them apart.

One would expect each neighbour to have left its words near its own border. The village map below puts that to the test.

Hidden

Latin roots, Slavic pieces#

Slavic also left pieces of words, which Romanian then attached to any root. The prefix ne- makes necunoscut 'unknown' and nesătul 'insatiable', -iță makes fetiță 'little girl' and ploiță 'drizzle', -nic makes puternic 'strong' and dornic 'eager', răs- makes a răsufla 'to breathe', -eală makes fierbințeală 'fever', -ean makes sătean 'villager'. Rosetti and the Romanian Academy's volumes on word formation give them as Slavic; for -eală Rosetti adds a condition, and for răs- Diez and Meyer-Lübke proposed Latin re- instead.

DEX '98 has 1,949 words made in Romanian with such a prefix or suffix, 568 of them only with -eală. At least 407 sit on a root inherited from Latin (341 without the -eală words), such as ne + cunoscut, fet + iță or putere + nic. Another 437 have a Slavic root as well.

  • ne-656
  • -eală568
  • -iță275
  • -că130
  • -ean113
  • -enie58
  • -nic49
  • -iște30
  • răs-30
  • -eț24

And in the grammar

unsprezece

Counting from 11 to 19 as 'one on ten' copies the Slavic pattern jedinŭ na desęte, according to Rosetti. Grigore Brâncuș proposed the pre-Roman substrate instead, citing the Albanian parallel.

Mărioaro!

The vocative in -o of feminine names (soro 'sister!', Ileano) reproduces the Slavic vocative (glavo, ženo), according to Rosetti.

el = 'yel'

Pronouncing initial e as ye (el 'he', este 'is', eu 'I') is attributed by Rosetti to Slavic influence.

lume

Latin lumen 'light' came to mean 'world' on the model of Slavic svĕtŭ, which means both (Rosetti; Schulte, in WOLD).

Loading the map…

The village map, 1929–1938

On the 1930s maps, words given as Serbian sit near Serbia. Words given as Bulgarian do not sit near Bulgaria.#

Between 1929 and 1938, the field workers of the Romanian Linguistic Atlas asked in hundreds of villages what people called maize, an older sister, a cast-iron pot. On 65 of its maps, covering 351 villages, 57 regional words have a Slavic source according to one of the two standard dictionaries (MDA2 or DEX '09); for another 18 the two disagree.

The words the dictionaries give as Serbian: uică ‘uncle’, mormoloc ‘tadpole’, ludaie ‘pumpkin’, crumpene ‘potatoes’, drug ‘maize cob’, căigană ‘scrambled eggs’, uină ‘aunt’. Half of the villages that used them lie less than 86 km from the Serbian border; for a regional word from the same maps taken at random, the median is 260 km. Uică, uină and căigană were heard almost only in Banat, Romania's south-west (24 of 28 villages), where Serbian villages stand among Romanian ones. Mormoloc, by contrast, was heard in the south and east.

The words given as Bulgarian: lele ‘older sister’, pleșuv ‘bald’, raclă ‘coffin’, tete ‘older brother’, zarzără ‘wild apricot’. Half of the villages that used them lie more than 304 km from Bulgaria, farther than for a regional word at random (246 km). They were heard mostly in Transylvania, Bukovina, Maramureș and Moldavia: lele in Bukovina, Transylvania and Bessarabia, raclă around Chernivtsi and Bălți, pleșuv in Maramureș, Transylvania and Banat. (Bukovina and Bessarabia were part of 1930s Romania; today they are partly in Ukraine and Moldova.)

The words given as Ukrainian: borș ‘sour bran liquid’, bubă ‘bump’, harbuz ‘watermelon’, piroște ‘cabbage rolls (locally)’. Ukraine borders Romania on two sides, so nearly any word sits close to it (median: 136 km; for the Ukrainian words, 129 km). Here the test cannot decide.

The old common words the dictionaries give as Old Slavic (cocoș ‘bump on the head’, uliță ‘village lane’, coșciug ‘coffin’, zmeu ‘paper kite’, vadră ‘bucket’, blid ‘dish’, progade ‘cemetery’, noroc ‘hello, cheers’, drum ‘village street’, lipii ‘pancakes’, suliță ‘icicle’) spread like any regional word: a median of 258 km from Bulgaria and 251 km from Serbia.

The test

How far each neighbour's words sit#

For each neighbour, the median distance from the villages that used its words to its present-day border, compared with what comes out when the neighbour labels are shuffled at random among the words, 10,000 times. Each village counts once per word, and a word on several maps is one word.

0 km100 km200 km300 km400 kmSerbian86 kmBulgarian304 kmUkrainian129 km
Line: the villages' median distance to the neighbour's border. Grey band: where 9 in 10 random shuffles fall.

The result: Serbian passes the test (p = 0.010) on the two atlases together, but not on the ALR II atlas alone. Bulgarian and Ukrainian do not pass.

How solid the result is

Serbian passes (p = 0.010) and stays below 0.05 on both atlases together, with either dictionary, with or without the villages now in Serbia and Ukraine, and with one vote per word (p between 0.009 and 0.02). On the ALR II atlas alone, where five words remain, the distance grows to 107–145 km and the test no longer passes (p between 0.05 and 0.12). Bulgarian fails in every variant tested (p above 0.88). Ukrainian fails too (p between 0.06 and 0.37).

What it may mean. Rosetti places the oldest Slavic layer, with the features of north-eastern Bulgarian, before the 13th century. A dictionary's 'bg.' label therefore need not mean a later Bulgarian neighbour. The map cannot tell which, although WOLD dates every word it gives as Bulgarian to the 11th–18th centuries. The words given as Serbian, by contrast, point to one neighbour in particular.

Limits: the 65 maps were chosen for another page because they show many variants; each neighbour has only four to seven words; the borders are today's.

Your village

Which Slavic words were spoken near you, 90 years ago#

Type a town or village in Romania or Moldova, or tap the map. The page finds the nearest village surveyed between 1929 and 1938 and shows the Slavic words noted there.

You can also tap the map.

Your sentence

How much Slavic is in what you write#

Type or paste a text in Romanian. Each word takes the colour of its origin, by DEX '98: red if it came from the Slavs, red underlined if only its prefix or suffix is Slavic.

Try a sentence without Slavic

'Da, te iubesc, prietene' (yes, I love you, friend) has three Slavic words out of four. 'Așa e, te ador, amice' says much the same with none.

Questions#

How many Slavic words are there in Romanian?

It depends on what is counted. DEX '98, the standard one-volume dictionary, has 2,503 words borrowed directly from a Slavic language, plus a few thousand words made in Romanian from them or with Slavic prefixes and suffixes. On the WOLD list of basic meanings, 12.2% are expressed with a Slavic word. In speech, about one word in 20–30 is Slavic.

Which Romanian words of Slavic origin are used most?

In subtitles, the most frequent are: a trebui ‘must’, nevoie ‘need’, prea ‘too’, prieten ‘friend’, grijă ‘worry, care’, a iubi ‘to love’, drum ‘road’, a primi ‘to receive’, tocmai ‘just’, treabă ‘business, job’, ciudat ‘strange’, a opri ‘to stop’, a plăti ‘to pay’, a omorî ‘to kill’. And da 'yes', if it is counted.

Is Romanian a Slavic language?

No. Romanian is a Romance language: its grammar and its most used words come from Latin. Slavic is the largest of the old influences on its vocabulary, and it left traces in the sounds and the grammar too.

When did the Slavic words enter Romanian?

In short: the old words, between the 6th and 12th centuries; Slavonic, the language of the church (from around the 11th–12th centuries) and then of the princes' chanceries, until the 17th; the neighbours' words (Serbian, Bulgarian, Ukrainian, Polish, Russian), after the 13th century (for the neighbours: Rosetti, p. 283).

Why is Romanian 'da' (yes) Slavic?

Because da as 'yes' comes from Bulgarian and Serbian, where it means the same (Rosetti, p. 291; DEX '98). Latin had no single word for yes; each Romance language made its own (sì, oui, sim).

What is Slavonic?

The written language of the Orthodox Church in the Balkans and in the Romanian lands, also called Church Slavonic. It was the language of the princes' charters in Wallachia and Moldavia until the 17th century, which is why Neacșu's letter opens in Slavonic.

Method and limits#

Dictionary. The etymology notes of DEX '98 (the public copy of the dexonline database, GPL licence; for G, H and part of I, where the copy only has DEX '96, the same second edition) were read automatically: 'Din sl. …' is a sure loan, 'Cf. …' an uncertain one, 'După …' a calque, 'X + suf. -y' a word made in Romanian. A word with several donors is shared among them. International words where DEX lists Russian next to French or Latin are counted apart. 40 randomly chosen rows were checked by hand.

Basic meanings. WOLD (Haspelmath and Tadmor, 2009; the Romanian chapter by Kim Schulte), CC BY 4.0. Each meaning counts once; when a meaning has several words, they share its point. On the same files, a count by word gives 41.1% borrowed words, close to the 41.8% Tadmor published on the 2009 edition.

Speech. 332 million words of Romanian subtitles from OpenSubtitles, mostly translations of films and series, linked to their dictionary headword through dexonline's inflected forms. Forms that belong to several headwords (dar, ne, tine) were decided by hand for the first 21; the rest, together with da and the words DEX '98 only compares with Slavic ('Cf.'), make the top of the range. Words made in Romanian with a Slavic suffix count as Slavic.

Map. The answers of the Romanian Linguistic Atlas (ALR I and ALR II), read and checked on the scans for the page 'Where you are from, by your words'. Each word's neighbour comes from the etymology field of MDA2, checked against DEX '09; the rule was written before any distance was computed. The independent check found two binning errors (cucuruz, răsad and gușter should have been 'Bulgarian or Serbian', and fancuri is not Ukrainian), fixed before publication; the Serbian result held. Distances are to today's borders (Natural Earth).

Prefixes and suffixes. The list of Slavic ones comes from Alexandru Rosetti, Istoria limbii române (1986, pp. 294–299) and the Academy's Formarea cuvintelor în limba română, vols. II–III (1978–1989). Suffixes the sources give as both Slavic and Hungarian or Latin (-aș, -uș, -ui, -ac) are not counted.

Sources#

  1. Neacșu's letter (1521): photograph, Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
  2. Neacșu's letter: Cyrillic text, Wikisource; reading, ro.wikipedia after cimec.ro
  3. Haspelmath & Tadmor (eds.), World Loanword Database (2009); Kim Schulte, Romanian vocabulary. CC BY 4.0
  4. Tadmor, Loanwords in the world's languages: findings and results (2009), table of borrowing rates
  5. DEX '98 etymology notes (and DEX '96 for G–I), public copy of the dexonline database (GPL)
  6. MDA2 and DEX '09 entries for the atlas words, dexonline
  7. Al. Rosetti, Istoria limbii române (1986), pp. 19, 269–299, 584; full text on archive.org
  8. Graur & Avram (eds.), Formarea cuvintelor în limba română, vols. II–III (1978–1989)
  9. Atlasul lingvistic român (ALR I 1938–1942; ALR II 1940, 1956–1966), Pușcariu Institute digital library
  10. Village readings of the 65 maps: De unde ești după vorbă (this site)
  11. OpenSubtitles Romanian corpus, word-form counts (via OPUS)
  12. Natural Earth admin-0 countries, 1:10m (public domain)
  13. GeoNames populated places of Romania and Moldova (CC BY 4.0)
  14. Copernicus GLO-90 elevation (relief of the map)

More on this site