The night Carpathia answered

14–15 April 1912

The night Carpathia answered

One distress call, three ships, three clocks. The night of 14–15 April 1912 as the men who heard it described it under oath: the times they gave, and where they disagree.

10.35 p.m.New York time

Cottam heard the call at 10.35. The 11.20 was withdrawn.

Harold Cottam, Carpathia’s wireless operator, heard Titanic’s call. He told the British inquiry the time was 10.35 p.m. New York time.

He also recalled having given 11.20 in America, and the compiled Marconi record carried that time. In London he withdrew it, tying the call to the moment Cape Cod finished its first round of press messages. The American transcript does not print 11.20.

Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
Come at once. It is a distress message; C. Q. D.

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Day 1, testimony of Harold T. Cottam

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Day 1, testimony of Harold T. Cottam supported by the document

12.35 a.m.Carpathia’s clock

Past midnight, by the ship’s clock.

Captain Arthur Rostron said he was told of the distress at 12.35 a.m., by Carpathia’s apparent time, and ordered her turned.

That clock ran 1 hour 50 minutes ahead of New York’s. In New York terms he was told at 10.45 p.m., ten minutes after Cottam’s corrected time.

Neither man needs to be wrong about his own watch. The trouble starts when the watches are set side by side.

Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
At 12:35 a. m. on Monday I was informed of the urgent distress signal from the Titanic.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; corroborated in British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; corroborated in British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
The New York time at 12:35 was 10:45 p. m. Sunday night.

Clock used in the source: New York time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385-Q25386

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385-Q25386 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
12:35; that was our apparent time.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385 supported by the document

The turn

North 52° west for 58 miles. Where she started is not on record.

Rostron gave Carpathia’s true course as north 52° west, and the distance to the position Titanic had transmitted as 58 miles.

Asked where Carpathia herself was when she turned, he gave no position. A bearing and a distance are all the testimony supports, and the story draws no track across the ocean.

N ? N 52° W58 miles Carpathia’s position when she turned:not given
Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
The course was north 52 degrees west true

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25389

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25389 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
58 miles from my position

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25389

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25389 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
I can not give you our correct position

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 supported by the document

Steaming

About 17½ knots at her best. Fourteen was ordinary.

Rostron put Carpathia’s ordinary speed at 14 knots and her best that night at about 17½. A 1902 launch report had planned 15½ on trial: a target, not a result.

Divide the 58 miles by the 3½ hours he gave and the answer is 16.6 miles an hour, which equals knots only if the miles were nautical. His testimony says “miles”. The slider shows both readings.

15.5 kn
  1. 14.0 kn · Rostron’s ordinary speed · British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25390 supported by the document
  2. 15.5 kn · Planned trial speed in the launch report; not a trial result. · The Engineer, 'A floating dock and a new Cunarder' · 8 August 1902 issue, p. 136 supported by the document
  3. 17.5 kn · Rostron’s approximate top speed that night · British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25390 supported by the document
  4. 16.6 source miles per hour; knots only if the miles were nautical · Reported distance divided by stated time, in miles per hour · Arithmetic from U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 arithmetic calculation

Calculated duration at the selected speed

If Rostron meant nautical miles3.7 hours
If Rostron meant statute miles3.3 hours

Distance Rostron reported: 58 miles; type unspecified

Time Rostron reported: 3.5 hours

Compare each estimate conditionally with Rostron’s reported time: his testimony says “miles” but does not specify the type.

Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
Ordinarily about 14.

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25390

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25390 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
We worked up to about 17 1/2 that night. That was about the highest speed we made that night.

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25390

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25390 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
She is to have a trial speed of about 15 1/2 knots.

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

The Engineer, 'A floating dock and a new Cunarder' · 8 August 1902 issue, p. 136

The Engineer, 'A floating dock and a new Cunarder' · 8 August 1902 issue, p. 136 supported by the document

12.11 a.m.Mount Temple’s clock

A third ship, a third clock.

On the Mount Temple, operator Herbert Durrant logged Titanic’s first distress message at 12.11 a.m. and Carpathia answering it at 12.21 a.m., ship’s time.

How far that clock stood from New York is disputed: 1 hour 46 minutes by his own answer, 1 hour 55 by a later recalculation in court. The choice puts his first entry at 10.25 p.m. or at 10.16 p.m. in New York.

The two conversions differ by nine minutes.

Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
12.11 a.m.

Clock used in the source: Mount Temple time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 8, Q9435-Q9451

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 8, Q9435-Q9451 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
'Titanic' still calling C.Q.D.; is answered by the 'Carpathia'.

Clock used in the source: Mount Temple time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 8, Q9458-Q9459

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 8, Q9458-Q9459 supported by the document

11.55 p.m.New York time

Cottam’s last message.

Cottam put Titanic’s last message to him at 11.55 p.m. New York time: the engine room was filling up to the boilers.

Rostron, asked in London, accepted about a quarter to two by his own clock for the last message to Carpathia. In America he had said about one o’clock, then “25 minutes after”.

The documents show what other ships received. They do not reconstruct what was known aboard Titanic, and Titanic is not drawn here.

Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
Come as quickly as possible; our engine room is filling up to the boilers.

Clock used in the source: New York time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17179 and Q17193-Q17200

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17179 and Q17193-Q17200 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
at about a quarter to two

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25399

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25399 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
That would have been about 1 o'clock. That would be 25 minutes after.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 sources disagree

2.40 a.m.Carpathia’s clock

A green flare.

At 2.40 a.m. by Carpathia’s clock Rostron saw a green flare. He described it as Titanic’s.

Five minutes later, the first ice.

Sources and wording

2.45 a.m.Carpathia’s clock

The first iceberg, a mile and a half to two miles off.

Five minutes after the flare Rostron saw the first iceberg. Between then and four o’clock he counted about half a dozen, and said in fact more.

Asked whether Carpathia had come up to the ice-field in the dark, he said she had not. The bergs drawn here are scenery: the testimony gives no positions.

Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
the first iceberg we saw was at a quarter to 3

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25419-Q25420 and Q25422

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25419-Q25420 and Q25422 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
about a mile and a half to two miles away

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25422

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25422 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
We saw about half a dozen - in fact, more than that.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25419-Q25424 and Q25507-Q25516

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25419-Q25424 and Q25507-Q25516 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
No ice-field. We were not up to the ice-field then.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25421

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25421 supported by the document

4.00 a.m.Carpathia’s clock

She stopped at four. The first boat came at ten past.

The department heads reported ready at 3.45. Rostron gave 4.00 for stopping the engines in America and about five past four in Britain, and said Carpathia was practically at Titanic’s transmitted position at four.

The first boat came alongside at 4.10. By 8.30 he said everyone rescued was aboard. In daylight a junior officer counted 25 large icebergs, and Rostron saw dozens more, in an ice-field running north-west to south-east as far as they could see.

On New York time the engines stopped at 2.10 a.m. That figure is arithmetic from his clock offset, not testimony.

Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
This was at 3:45. That was a quarter of an hour before we got up to the scene of the disaster.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
I stopped my engines at 4 o'clock

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; U.S. report · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 and continuation

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; U.S. report · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 and continuation sources disagree

Read the wording in the document
I stopped, at about five minutes after four.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25401-Q25404

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25401-Q25404 sources disagree

Read the wording in the document
At 10 minutes past four we got alongside.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25401

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25401 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
He counted 25 large ones, 150 to 200 feet high

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25501

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25501 supported by the document

Read the wording in the document
an ice-field extending as far as we could see, N.W. to S.E.

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25501-Q25502

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25501-Q25502 supported by the document

The count

Three documents, three totals.

The British inquiry recorded 711 saved of 2,201 aboard. The American inquiry recorded 706 saved of 2,223. Rostron said 705 had been reported to him.

Each total stays with its source. None is combined into a figure of its own.

One scale for every total, from zero to 2,223 people aboard

711 of 2,201 · British inquiry report

706 of 2,223 · U.S. inquiry report

705 · Number reported to Rostron · No total aboard given

Aboard, the two inquiries differ by 22 people

The same scale, magnified: 700 to 715 people saved

Gap between the lowest and highest total: 6 people

In the British table, 706 is the number of third-class passengers aboard, not the number rescued.

Sources and wording
Read the wording in the document
Total on board saved 711 out of 2,201

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

British Wreck Commissioner's report · Report, 'Numbers Saved'

British Wreck Commissioner's report · Report, 'Numbers Saved' sources disagree

Read the wording in the document
It was reported to me that 705 was the number of survivors

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25485-Q25487

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25485-Q25487 sources disagree

The record

Every time on this page sits on the clock its witness used. Move through the night to see each witness’s latest statement beside its New York equivalent, then open the wording behind it.

01:17 NY

With the slider focused, use the left and right arrow keys to move through the minutes.

Harold Cottam, later British testimony recalling his U.S. answerNew York time
Harold Cottam, British inquiry testimonyNew York time
Compiled Marconi record read at the British inquiryNew York time
Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent time
Clock offset: NY = Carpathia apparent time −1 h 50 min · U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385
no time on the New York axis
Herbert DurrantMount Temple time
Clock offset: NY = Mount Temple time −1 h 46 min · Durrant’s stated offset · British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcripts · Day 8, Durrant Q9435-Q9450; Day 15, Solicitor-General's explanation before Cottam Q17084Clock offset: NY = Mount Temple time −1 h 55 min · Later recalculation read during Cottam’s testimony · British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Solicitor-General's explanation before Cottam Q17084, citing Durrant Q9451 and Q9458
Harold Bride’s letterclock not specified
Clock offset: no documented clock conversion
no time on the New York axis
Cape Race time in the U.S. reportNew York time
Clock offset: New York time is the reference · U.S. Senate inquiry report · Report, 'Pleas for Help'
GMT calculated from New York civil timecalculated GMT

Each witness’s latest mapped statement at or before the selected time

Harold Cottam, later British testimony recalling his U.S. answer Time Cottam later said he had given in New York, recalled at the British inquiry and then withdrawn: 23:20 NYHarold Cottam, British inquiry testimony Time Cottam says he heard Titanic’s last message: 23:55 NYCompiled Marconi record read at the British inquiry Time in the Marconi record’s first entry for the call: 23:20 NYArthur Rostron Rostron says he saw the first iceberg: 00:55 NYHerbert Durrant Durrant records Carpathia answering Titanic’s CQD call: 22:35 NY Using Durrant’s stated offsetHarold Bride’s letter No event is recorded for this witness by the selected time.Cape Race time in the U.S. report Cape Race records receiving Titanic’s distress call: 22:25 NYGMT calculated from New York civil time GMT equivalent calculated from Cottam’s corrected time: 22:35 NY
Times given in testimony, their New York conversions and the cited documents
Times given in testimony, their New York conversions and the cited documents
WitnessEventTime statedTime converted to New YorkDocument
Harold Cottam, later British testimony recalling his U.S. answerNew York timeTime Cottam later said he had given in New York, recalled at the British inquiry and then withdrawnBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17068 and Q17181; Cottam says 23:20 was the time he gave in New York sources disagree
Read the wording in the document
11.20 p.m.

Clock used in the source: New York time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17068 and Q17181; Cottam says 23:20 was the time he gave in New York

Harold Cottam, British inquiry testimonyNew York timeTime Cottam corrected in his London testimonyBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17068, Q17181, Q17181a, Q17182 sources disagree
Read the wording in the document
10.35 exactly.

Clock used in the source: New York time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17068, Q17181, Q17181a, Q17182

Harold Cottam, British inquiry testimonyNew York timeTime Cottam says he heard Titanic’s last messageBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17145-Q17146 and Q17193-Q17200 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
11.55 New York time

Clock used in the source: New York time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17145-Q17146 and Q17193-Q17200

Compiled Marconi record read at the British inquiryNew York timeTime in the Marconi record’s first entry for the callBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17181; compiled procès-verbal read in evidence sources disagree
Read the wording in the document
11.20 p.m. Heard 'Titanic' calling 'S.O.S.' and 'C.Q.D.'

Clock used in the source: New York time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 15, Q17181; compiled procès-verbal read in evidence

Compiled Marconi record read at the British inquiryNew York timeCorrected time in the Marconi record, read to RostronBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25386 sources disagree
Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron says he was told of the distress and ordered Carpathia turnedU.S. Senate inquiry transcript; corroborated in British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
At 12:35 a. m. on Monday I was informed of the urgent distress signal from the Titanic.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; corroborated in British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25385

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron confirms the British inquiry’s time for the last messageBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25399 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
at about a quarter to two

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25399

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron’s U.S. inquiry answer about the engine-room message timeno time on the New York axisU.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 sources disagree
Read the wording in the document
That would have been about 1 o'clock. That would be 25 minutes after.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron sees a green flareU.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry Q25394-Q25396 · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25394-Q25396 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
At 2:40, I saw a flare

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry Q25394-Q25396 · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25394-Q25396

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron says he saw the first icebergBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25419-Q25420 and Q25422 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
the first iceberg we saw was at a quarter to 3

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25419-Q25420 and Q25422

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeDepartment heads report ready; Carpathia has not yet arrivedU.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
This was at 3:45. That was a quarter of an hour before we got up to the scene of the disaster.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Rostron, U.S. Day 1

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron says in the U.S. inquiry that he stopped the enginesU.S. Senate inquiry transcript; U.S. report · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 and continuation sources disagree
Read the wording in the document
I stopped my engines at 4 o'clock

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; U.S. report · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 and continuation

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron says Carpathia was nearly at the transmitted position; he saw no boatBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25401-Q25404 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
At four o'clock I considered I was practically up to the position

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25401-Q25404

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron says in the British inquiry that he stopped the enginesBritish Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25401-Q25404 sources disagree
Read the wording in the document
I stopped, at about five minutes after four.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 28, Q25401-Q25404

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeThe first boat comes alongside CarpathiaU.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25401 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
At 10 minutes past four we got alongside.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript; British inquiry · Rostron, U.S. Day 1; British Q25401

Arthur RostronCarpathia apparent timeRostron says everyone rescued was aboardU.S. Senate inquiry transcript and U.S. report · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 continuation; U.S. report, Captain Rostron supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
By 8:30 all were aboard.

Clock used in the source: Carpathia apparent time

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript and U.S. report · Rostron, U.S. Day 1 continuation; U.S. report, Captain Rostron

Herbert DurrantMount Temple timeDurrant records the first distress message British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 8, Q9435-Q9451 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
12.11 a.m.

Clock used in the source: Mount Temple time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 8, Q9435-Q9451

Herbert DurrantMount Temple timeDurrant records Carpathia answering Titanic’s CQD call British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 8, Q9458-Q9459 supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
'Titanic' still calling C.Q.D.; is answered by the 'Carpathia'.

Clock used in the source: Mount Temple time

British Wreck Commissioner's inquiry transcript · Day 8, Q9458-Q9459

Harold Bride’s letterclock not specifiedBride’s letter records both CQD and SOS callsno time on the New York axisU.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Day 14, Bride letter read into record supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
Again Mr. Phillips called 'C Q D' and 'S O S'

Clock used in the source: clock not specified

U.S. Senate inquiry transcript · Day 14, Bride letter read into record

Cape Race time in the U.S. reportNew York timeCape Race records receiving Titanic’s distress callU.S. Senate inquiry report · Report, 'Pleas for Help' supported by the document
Read the wording in the document
10.25 p.m. New York time

Clock used in the source: New York time

U.S. Senate inquiry report · Report, 'Pleas for Help'

GMT calculated from New York civil timecalculated GMTGMT equivalent calculated from Cottam’s corrected timeArithmetic using Cottam's corrected time and IANA New York zone history · British inquiry Q17181-Q17182; IANA America/New_York rule arithmetic calculation

05

Which distress signal came first?

In his spoken testimony, Bride says Phillips sent CQD first. Bride’s letter records SOS as well, later in the sequence. Both the British and U.S. inquiries found that the Californian saw the distress signals and did not answer.

CQD

Bride says Phillips sent CQD and Titanic’s call sign, MGY. Marconi described CQD as his company’s conventional signal.

SOS

Marconi said SOS was the international danger signal specified by the Berlin Convention. Bride’s letter places SOS after CQD in its account of the calls.

06

Testimony and inquiry reports

Times stay on the clock each witness used; calculations are marked separately, and differing totals remain beside the documents that recorded them.

How emigrants crossed the Atlantic

Wording in the document