Integrated assessment E01 · common core
Water, the membrane and explaining a result
A pupil measures how the mass of pieces of potato changes in three solutions. The data are numbers chosen for the exercise, not a real measurement.
| Solution | Initial mass (g) | Mass after 30 minutes (g) |
|---|---|---|
| Water, no salt | 20; 20; 20 | 21.0; 20.7; 20.9 |
| Salt 2% | 20; 20; 20 | 19.6; 19.5; 19.7 |
| Salt 6% | 20; 20; 20 | 18.0; 18.2; 17.8 |
Work out the mean percentage change in mass for each solution, using the formula (final mass − initial mass) ÷ initial mass × 100.
Say in which direction the net movement of water went in each solution and what each solution is called relative to the potato cells. Between which two concentrations does the isotonic concentration lie?
Name the independent variable, the dependent variable, three controlled variables and the control group of the experiment.
Two red blood cells: one ends up in distilled water, the other in saline (0.9% sodium chloride). Describe what happens to each and explain why the volume of the one in saline does not change, even though water keeps crossing the membrane.
A classmate says: “The experiment shows how big the volume of a potato cell is.” Correct the statement with two limits.
Solution and mark scheme, E01
Page for the teacher.
The final means are 20.87 g, 19.6 g and 18.0 g. The changes are +4.33% in water, −2% in 2% salt and −10% in 6% salt.
In water, there was a net movement of water into the piece: the solution is hypotonic. In 2% and 6% salt there was a net movement of water out: the solutions are hypertonic. The mass goes from an increase to a decrease between 0% and 2%, so the isotonic concentration lies between these values.
The independent variable is the salt concentration; the dependent variable is the change in mass. Controlled: the initial mass of the pieces, the time (30 minutes), the volume and temperature of the solution, blotting the pieces the same way before weighing. The control group is the water without salt. Three pieces for each solution, as repeats, is also accepted.
In distilled water (hypotonic) the first cell swells and bursts: haemolysis. In saline (isotonic) the second keeps its volume, because water crosses in both directions in equal amounts; there is no net flow.
First limit: what was measured is the mass of a whole piece on a balance, not the volume of a cell. Second: the data are numbers chosen for the exercise, not the results of a real experiment; a reliable conclusion rests on observations made independently, in repeated series.
Mark scheme
| Criterion | 0 marks | 1 mark | 2 marks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calculation and units | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| Direction of water movement and type of solution, for the potato and for the red blood cell | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| Variables and control | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| Limits of the conclusion | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
Maximum 8 marks. The final mark, if one is given, is set by the teacher; the rubric has no official threshold.