Misconceptions
30 ideas about living things, and how to correct them
Each idea is stated the way pupils often state it, followed by the correction, a question that brings it out and something to try. The ideas are grouped by chapter and link to the lesson that discusses them.
1Investigating lifeChapter
MisconceptionIf two things change together, one of them must be causing the other. (Lesson 1.1)
CorrectTwo things that happen together raise a question; they do not show a cause. A cause is shown by comparison, with a single factor changed and a control group.
Ask yourselfIn summer more ice cream is sold and more people drown. What other factor could change both numbers?
To tryDescribe a comparison in which you change a single factor, to see whether it produces the effect.
MisconceptionTwenty seeds in the same pot means twenty repeats. (Lesson 1.2)
CorrectThe seeds in one pot sit in the same water and the same light, so they count as a single sample. The repeats are the separate pots.
Ask yourselfWas the water condition applied to a pot or to each seed?
To tryPropose three pots for each condition and say how many pots you need in total.
MisconceptionA result that contradicts the hypothesis should be removed from the table. (Lesson 1.2)
CorrectGood data are kept, even if they do not come out as you predicted. You check whether the protocol was followed, and the hypothesis changes. Removing inconvenient data falsifies the analysis.
Ask yourselfHow would you tell the class about a result that does not follow your prediction?
To tryWrite two sentences of conclusion for an experiment in which you found no difference between the groups.
2The molecules that make life possibleChapter
MisconceptionVitamins give you energy, like sugar. (Lesson 2.1)
CorrectVitamins help the reactions in the body to take place, but they are not fuel. The energy in a food comes from carbohydrates, lipids and proteins.
Ask yourselfOn the label of a juice with added vitamins, where do the calories come from?
To tryChoose a label and show the vitamins and the energy value of the product separately.
MisconceptionEvery protein is an enzyme. (Lesson 2.6)
CorrectProteins have different roles: haemoglobin carries oxygen, antibodies defend the body, and enzymes speed up reactions.
Ask yourselfWhat does the haemoglobin in red blood cells do: speed up a reaction or carry a substance?
To tryChoose two proteins with different roles and write the role of each in one sentence.
MisconceptionATP produces energy for the cell. (Lesson 2.3)
CorrectATP takes up the energy released when food is broken down and passes it on to where the cell needs it. It does not make energy out of nothing.
Ask yourselfWhere does the energy carried by ATP come from?
To tryRewrite the sentence “ATP produces energy” using the verb “transfers”.
3Inside the cellChapter
MisconceptionBacteria have no DNA, because they have no nucleus. (Lesson 3.2)
CorrectBacteria have DNA. Only the membrane around the DNA is missing: it sits in the cytoplasm, in a region called the nucleoid.
Ask yourselfWhere is the DNA in a bacterium, if it has no nucleus?
To tryCompare the nucleoid with the nucleus: what do they share, and what does the nucleoid lack?
MisconceptionAll the cells of a plant have chloroplasts. (Lesson 3.4)
CorrectChloroplasts are found in the cells that receive light, such as those in the leaf. Root cells, down in the soil, have no chloroplasts.
Ask yourselfWhat do you expect to find in a carrot root cell, in the dark?
To tryName one organelle that all the cells of a plant have and one that they do not all have.
MisconceptionA virus is a very small cell. (Lesson 3.1)
CorrectA virus is not a cell: it has a nucleic acid inside a protein coat and reproduces only inside a host cell. For this reason it is not considered alive.
Ask yourselfDoes a virus have its own metabolism, and can it reproduce on its own?
To tryWrite two differences between a virus and a bacterium, without using size.
4Boundaries, exchange and new cellsChapter
MisconceptionIn osmosis, salt passes through the membrane until the concentrations become equal. (Lesson 4.2)
CorrectWater passes through the partially permeable membrane, from the more dilute solution to the more concentrated one. The dissolved salt stays on its own side.
Ask yourselfA piece of potato sits in brine and loses mass. What came out of it: salt or water?
To tryExplain, in two sentences, how the concentration inside a cell can rise without the cell taking in any salt.
MisconceptionWater keeps entering the cell only until the concentrations inside and outside are equal. (Lesson 4.2)
CorrectIn a plant cell, the wall stops the swelling: the volume of the turgid cell no longer increases, even though the solution inside it stays more concentrated than the water around it. At any equilibrium, water still crosses the membrane in both directions, in equal amounts.
Ask yourselfWhat stops an onion cell kept in water from swelling until it bursts, the way a red blood cell bursts?
To tryCompare a plant cell and a red blood cell placed in distilled water: what happens to each, and why?
MisconceptionDNA replication doubles the number of chromosomes. (Lesson 4.5)
CorrectAfter replication, each chromosome has two sister chromatids and is still a single chromosome. In G2, a human cell has 46 chromosomes and 92 DNA molecules. The chromosomes become 92 only in anaphase.
Ask yourselfHow many chromosomes and how many DNA molecules does a human cell have in the G2 phase?
To tryCompare G2 with anaphase and say each time whether you are counting the whole cell or one daughter cell.
5From cell to biosphereChapter
MisconceptionAll the living things in a park form a population. (Lesson 5.2)
CorrectA population is made up of the individuals of the same species in one place. The populations of several species living together form the community (biocoenosis).
Ask yourselfAre all the living things in the park of the same species?
To tryClassify the oak trees in the park and all the living things in the park separately: population or community?
MisconceptionIf the population size has stayed the same, no one in the population has been born or died. (Lesson 5.3)
CorrectThe population size can stay the same even when there have been births, deaths, immigration and emigration, because they can cancel out. The balance shows only the difference.
Ask yourselfCan the same number of individuals be born and die in a year?
To tryBuild a balance in which N₀ equals N₁, but all four flows are greater than zero.
MisconceptionA higher diversity index automatically shows a healthier ecosystem. (Lesson 5.4)
CorrectThe index describes data collected with a particular method. It does not say which species they are, whether they are rare or invasive, or how well the ecosystem works.
Ask yourselfWhat does the index not tell you about the species in a place?
To tryName two pieces of data you need, besides the index, before choosing a place to protect.
6The worlds you discover under the microscopeChapter
MisconceptionAll bacteria are dangerous. (Lesson 6.2)
CorrectMost bacteria make no one ill. Some make yoghurt and borș (a fermented bran liquid), others break down remains in the soil or live in the healthy human gut. Diseases are caused by only some species.
Ask yourselfWhich bacteria do you use in the kitchen without falling ill?
To tryDescribe a useful role of bacteria in an ecosystem and one in a food.
MisconceptionArchaea live only in hot springs and salty water. (Lesson 6.2)
CorrectArchaea also live in ordinary environments, including the ocean and the human gut. They differ from bacteria in the structure of their molecules, not in where they live.
Ask yourselfIs the place where an organism lives a criterion for classifying it?
To tryExplain why two prokaryotes that look the same under the microscope can belong to different domains: one to Bacteria and the other to Archaea.
MisconceptionEach group in the school classification (Protozoa, Chromista, worms) is a branch of the tree of life. (Lesson 6.1)
CorrectSchool groups are lists of organisms used for teaching. A tree of life shows relatedness: a branch includes a common ancestor and all its descendants.
Ask yourselfWhat does a tree of life show that a list of groups does not?
To tryDraw a tree with four species and show what it means for two of them to be sister groups.
7Plants: built for lifeChapter
MisconceptionThe brown dots under a fern leaf are seeds. (Lesson 7.2)
CorrectA fern does not make seeds: it reproduces by spores, which form in sori, the clusters on the underside of the leaf. A spore is a single cell, while a seed contains an embryo.
Ask yourselfHow does a fern reproduce, by spores or by seeds?
To tryCompare the fern and the pine using one character of reproduction.
MisconceptionPollination and fertilisation are the same thing. (Lesson 7.3)
CorrectPollination is the arrival of pollen on the stigma (in gymnosperms, on the ovule). Fertilisation is the joining of the gametes. They are two different events, and some time passes between them.
Ask yourselfWhat moves in pollination, and what joins in fertilisation?
To tryPut the two events in order and describe what happens at each one, using one sentence for each.
MisconceptionThe trees in a forest communicate with each other through fungi, like on the internet, and help each other on purpose. (Lesson 7.6)
CorrectRoots can be linked by fungi, and substances do pass through them, but that does not mean the trees “want” to help each other. The results of one experiment cannot be generalised to all forests.
Ask yourselfWhat did the experiment cited in the lesson actually measure?
To tryWrite one sentence that says what was observed and one that says what does not follow from the observation.
8Animals: forms, functions, environmentsChapter
MisconceptionAnything that flies is a bird. (Lesson 8.6)
CorrectFlight appeared in several groups: insects, birds, bats. The bat has hair and mammary glands and gives birth to live young: it is a mammal.
Ask yourselfWhich characters place the bat among the mammals?
To tryCompare the bat, a bird and an insect without using wings as an argument.
MisconceptionAll mammals give birth to live young. (Lesson 8.6)
CorrectMonotremes (the platypus and the echidnas) lay eggs and are still mammals, because they have hair and feed their young on milk. A group is recognised by several characters together.
Ask yourselfWhich egg-laying animal is classed among the mammals?
To tryExplain why the platypus is a mammal, using characters other than the way it is born.
MisconceptionAll worms are parasites. (Lesson 8.2)
CorrectThe groups called worms at school also include free-living species. The earthworm lives in the soil and loosens it, and a long, thin shape does not show that an animal is a parasite.
Ask yourselfWhat does an earthworm feed on, and where does it live?
To tryChoose a free-living worm and say what role it plays in its ecosystem.
9Life, health and conservationChapter
MisconceptionThe mosquito is the agent of malaria. (Lesson 9.2)
CorrectThe agent is the organism that causes the disease, and the vector carries it from one host to another. In malaria, the agent is a protozoan and the mosquito transmits it.
Ask yourselfWhich organism causes the disease, and which one carries it?
To tryFill in a table with the agent, the vector and the host for a disease discussed in the lesson.
MisconceptionBirds bring West Nile virus straight to people. (Lesson 9.2)
CorrectBirds are the reservoir, the hosts in which the virus persists. Humans are infected by the bite of a mosquito, that is, through the vector. The reservoir can be different from the immediate source.
Ask yourselfHow does the virus get from birds to humans?
To tryDraw the chain of agent, reservoir, vector and host for a case from the lesson.
MisconceptionThere are no dots on the map in that area, so the species does not live there. (Lesson 9.4)
CorrectThe dots on the map show only where someone has recorded the species. A place without dots may be a place where no one has looked. Absence can be claimed only after a search made with the same care as in other places.
Ask yourselfHow many people have recorded species in the area without dots?
To tryPropose how you would search for the species in the empty area before saying that it does not live there.
10Humans in living systemsChapter
MisconceptionA tonne of carbon is the same thing as a tonne of CO₂. (Lesson 10.5)
CorrectThe CO₂ molecule also contains oxygen. One tonne of carbon gives 44 ÷ 12 ≈ 3.67 tonnes of CO₂. CO₂e is a different unit, in which other gases are expressed by their effect on the climate.
Ask yourselfHow much does the CO₂ formed from 12 g of carbon weigh?
To tryConvert 12 tonnes of carbon into tonnes of CO₂ and show the calculation.
MisconceptionDigital material has no emissions. (Lesson 10.5)
CorrectThe phone, the servers and the network use energy and had to be manufactured. When you compare a printed sheet with a page read on screen, you count all the components and attribute them correctly.
Ask yourselfWhat parts and what energy use are needed for you to read a page on a phone?
To tryChoose one printed material and one digital material and write what you would count for each.
MisconceptionFossil carbon that has been burnt quickly turns back into coal and oil. (Lesson 10.4)
CorrectCoal and oil formed over millions of years. Burning them moves the carbon into the atmosphere within a few generations, so they are not replaced within a time span useful to humans.
Ask yourselfHow long does a deposit take to form, and how long does it take to burn?
To tryExplain why the carbon cycle has no “back into oil” arrow on the scale of a human lifetime.