Biology IX RO

Chapter 3 · The cellLesson 3.2

Prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells: what sets them apart

The bacteria that sour borș, a fermented wheat-bran liquid, have no nucleus. Where do they keep their DNA, and how do they make their proteins?

Size
from 5 nm to 100 µm
Level
cell
Time
a day in the life of a cell

Test tomorrowten questions from chapter 3

Before you read: what do you think?

A mature human red blood cell has no nucleus. What kind of cell is it?

See the answer

Eukaryotic. A red blood cell forms from a cell with a nucleus, which then gets rid of its nucleus and most of its organelles. The type of a cell is decided by its organisation and by the organism it belongs to, and a specialised cell that lacks a nucleus is not a bacterium.

Home-made borș, a Romanian fermented liquid, starts as wheat bran, warm water and a little borș from an older batch. Two or three days later, the liquid has turned sour. The acidity comes from bacteria much smaller than your cells and built differently: they have no nucleus, and their DNA sits directly in the cytoplasm.

Four things every cell has

Every cell, from the bacterium in borș to a neuron in your brain, has four components. The plasma membrane separates it from its surroundings and controls what goes in and out. The cytoplasm fills the inside and is based on a jelly-like fluid, the cytosol. DNA carries the genetic information. Ribosomes are the small structures where proteins are made.

The two fundamental types of cell differ in how the inside is organised. A prokaryotic cell has no nucleus and no other membrane-bound organelles. A eukaryotic cell has a nucleus and several inner compartments, each enclosed by its own membrane.

Artificially coloured scanning electron micrograph of a cluster of rod-shaped bacteria, with a 1 µm scale bar.
Figure 1Escherichia coli bacteria magnified 10,000 times under the electron microscope; the colour is added artificially. Compare a rod with the 1 µm bar: it is only a few micrometres long, the usual size of a prokaryotic cell.

Photo: Eric Erbe (fotografie), Christopher Pooley (colorare), USDA Agricultural Research Service, Public domain, source. Resized.

The prokaryotic cell: DNA without a nucleus

Prokaryotes are the bacteria and the archaea, nearly all of them organisms made of a single cell. Their main DNA is a circular molecule lying in a region in the middle of the cytoplasm called the nucleoid. The nucleoid is not a small nucleus: there is no membrane around it. Many bacteria also have plasmids, small circular DNA molecules that sometimes carry genes for resistance to antibiotics.

Prokaryotic ribosomes are smaller than those in the cytoplasm of eukaryotes, but they do the same job: they link amino acids into proteins. So a bacterium with no nucleus still makes its own proteins.

On the outside, most bacteria have a cell wall made of murein (peptidoglycan), a substance found only in bacteria. Some have a capsule over the wall, which they use to stick to surfaces. They move with flagella, and short threads called pili help them, among other things, to exchange genetic material.

Prokaryotes usually measure between 0.1 and 5 µm. By shape they are divided into cocci (spheres), bacilli (rods), vibrios (curved rods) and spirilla (spirals).

capsule cell wall (murein) pili plasmids flagellum plasma membrane nucleoid: circular DNA ribosomes cytoplasm 1 µm
Figure 2Diagram: the bacterium’s DNA lies in the nucleoid, with no membrane around it, and the murein wall sits outside the membrane. The 1 µm bar gives the size of the cell; the ribosomes, plasmids and pili are drawn much larger than they are.

The eukaryotic cell: compartments with membranes

Plants, animals, fungi and protists are made of eukaryotic cells. Their DNA is divided into several chromosomes and sits in the nucleus, which is wrapped in a double membrane with pores. The cytoplasm holds membrane-bound organelles such as mitochondria, the endoplasmic reticulum and the Golgi apparatus, and plants also have chloroplasts.

Each compartment keeps substances and reactions inside it that differ from those of the surrounding cytoplasm. Eukaryotic cells usually measure between 10 and 100 µm, which makes them tens of times larger than an ordinary bacterium.

Four traps when you compare them

Size points the way but does not decide. Prokaryotes are usually a few micrometres long, yet there are giant bacteria such as Thiomargarita namibiensis, and some eukaryotic cells are small. To be sure, you look for the nucleus and the membrane-bound organelles.

“Unicellular” does not mean “prokaryotic”. Brewer’s yeast and paramecium are organisms made of a single cell, but their cell has a nucleus, so they are eukaryotes.

Having a cell wall does not decide the type of cell. Bacteria, plants and fungi all have walls, made of different substances. An animal cell has no wall.

A specialised cell that lacks a nucleus is still not prokaryotic. A mature human red blood cell loses its nucleus as it forms, but it remains a eukaryotic cell, belonging to a eukaryotic organism.

Oval yeast cells under the light microscope, on a grey background; a few have a small round bud attached.
Figure 3Brewer’s yeast cells (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) under the light microscope, with the 100× objective; some have a bud. Yeast is an organism made of a single cell, and its cell has a nucleus, so it is a eukaryote.

Photo: Masur, Public domain, source. Cropped and resized.

Worked example

How big is the cell in the photograph

On a photograph taken through a microscope, the scale bar marked “10 µm” measures 40 mm. A rod-shaped cell on the same photograph measures 8 mm, and a round cell with a visible nucleus measures 100 mm. The numbers are chosen for the exercise.

Step 1: work out how many micrometres one millimetre of the photograph stands for. 10 µm ÷ 40 mm = 0.25 µm for each millimetre.

Step 2: the rod is 8 × 0.25 = 2 µm. The round cell is 100 × 0.25 = 25 µm.

Step 3: interpret. The 2 µm rod is the usual size of a bacterium. The 25 µm cell, with a nucleus, is eukaryotic. Size alone points the way; the nucleus settles it.

You can make a similar slide for the school microscope: a drop of water with a little brewer’s yeast, and a drop of borș or of yoghurt diluted with water. The yeast cells look oval, a few micrometres across, some with a bud. The bacteria appear as tiny rods that are easy to make out only with the highest-power objective.

In Romania

The bacteria that sour borș

Borș is made from wheat bran, warm water and a starter kept back from an older batch, called huște. Fermentation takes two or three days, in wooden or glass vessels. Only in 2019 did a team from the Institute of Biology Bucharest of the Romanian Academy publish the first study of the microorganisms in Romanian borș.

The researchers analysed shop-bought borș, home-made borș and borș prepared in the laboratory. They found mostly lactic acid bacteria of the genus Lactobacillus, and the most common species was Lactobacillus amylolyticus. In every sample the pH fell below 4, which means the liquid became acidic.

In the laboratory borș, lactic acid bacteria were plentiful from the very start, about a hundred million in a millilitre, brought in by the huște. Huște passed from household to household carry a population of prokaryotes on from one batch to the next.

In short

  1. Every cell has a plasma membrane, cytoplasm, DNA and ribosomes.
  2. A prokaryotic cell (bacteria and archaea) has no nucleus and no membrane-bound organelles; its circular DNA lies in the nucleoid, and many bacteria also have plasmids.
  3. Most bacteria have a cell wall made of murein; prokaryotes usually measure 0.1–5 µm and can be cocci, bacilli, vibrios or spirilla.
  4. A eukaryotic cell (plants, animals, fungi, protists) has a nucleus with a double membrane and membrane-bound organelles; it usually measures 10–100 µm.
  5. Ribosomes exist in both types of cell, so prokaryotes also make their own proteins.
  6. A single-celled organism can be eukaryotic (yeast, paramecium), and a specialised eukaryotic cell can lack a nucleus (the mature red blood cell).
WorksheetMy notebook

Common mistakes

  • WrongBacteria have no DNA, because they have no nucleus.

    RightBacteria have DNA, lying in a region of the cytoplasm called the nucleoid, with no membrane around it. What is missing is the membrane, not the genetic material.

  • WrongYeast is a bacterium, because it is made of a single cell.

    RightYeast is a single-celled fungus with a nucleus, so it is a eukaryote. The number of cells and the type of cell are separate criteria.

  • WrongThe nucleoid is a very small nucleus.

    RightThe nucleoid is only the area where the DNA sits. A nucleus is surrounded by a double membrane with pores; a nucleoid has no membrane at all.

Check yourself

Six questions. For the first five you see the explanation at once, with the paragraph of the lesson that supports it; for the written ones you compare with a good answer.

  1. Which structure is found in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells?

    Answer

    c) The ribosome. Ribosomes exist in all cells, because every cell makes its own proteins. The nucleus, mitochondria and the Golgi apparatus are absent in prokaryotes.

  2. Where does a bacterium keep its main DNA?

    Answer

    b) In the nucleoid, with no membrane around it. A bacterium has no nucleus. Its circular DNA lies in an area of the cytoplasm called the nucleoid, which no membrane encloses.

  3. An organism has a single cell, with a nucleus and a cell wall. What can you say about it for certain?

    Answer

    d) It is a eukaryote, because it has a nucleus. The nucleus shows that the cell is eukaryotic. Bacteria, plants and fungi all have walls, and a single cell could be, for example, a yeast.

  4. On a photograph, the 5 µm scale bar measures 20 mm. A bacterium on the same photograph measures 12 mm. How long is the bacterium, in micrometres?

    µm
    Answer

    3 µm. 5 µm ÷ 20 mm = 0.25 µm for each millimetre. 12 × 0.25 = 3 µm, an ordinary size for a bacterium.

  5. Choose the type of cell each description fits.

    Answer

    Prokaryotic cell: Lactobacillus from borș; Circular DNA in a nucleoid; Wall made of murein.

    Eukaryotic cell: A brewer’s yeast cell; Nucleus with a double membrane and pores; Mature human red blood cell.

    Bacteria have DNA in a nucleoid and a wall made of murein. Yeast has a nucleus. A mature red blood cell has no nucleus, but it comes from a eukaryotic cell of a eukaryotic organism.

  6. Under the microscope you see a cell 4 µm across, with no visible nucleus. Your classmate says at once that it is a bacterium. Why is that conclusion not reliable, and what else would you check?

    A good answer

    A size of 4 µm fits a bacterium, but on its own it does not prove the type of cell, and a nucleus may not show up without staining. The cell could also be a small eukaryotic cell or a red blood cell that has lost its nucleus. I would stain the slide to look for a nucleus, ask which organism the sample came from and look for other membrane-bound organelles.

    A complete answer says that size only points the way, names the deciding criterion (nucleus and membrane-bound organelles), gives a counter-example (a eukaryotic cell that is small or has no nucleus) and suggests a concrete check.

Terms

prokaryotic cell
A cell with no nucleus and no membrane-bound organelles, with its DNA in a nucleoid; bacteria and archaea have this type of cell.
eukaryotic cell
A cell with a nucleus enclosed by a double membrane and with membrane-bound organelles; plants, animals, fungi and protists have this type of cell.
nucleoid
The region of a prokaryote’s cytoplasm where its main DNA lies, with no membrane around it.
plasmid
A small circular DNA molecule, separate from the main DNA, found mostly in bacteria.
ribosome
A small structure without a membrane in which amino acids are linked into proteins; it exists in all cells.
murein
The substance of the bacterial cell wall, also called peptidoglycan.
cytoplasm
The contents of the cell inside the plasma membrane and outside the nucleus: the cytosol and the structures in it.
Sources and link to the programme

From the programme: “Fundamental cell types - prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Components of the cell – the main structural elements and their functions: membrane/cell wall, cytoplasm, cell organelles (ribosomes, mitochondria, Golgi apparatus, ER, lysosomes, plastids, vacuoles, centrosome), nucleus/nucleoid” (common core). Specific competences addressed: 1.1, 2.1, 2.2.