Integrated assessment E04 · extra, for Natural Sciences (CS)
Two equal totals can hide different systems
Three cases in which the same numbers say different things: the chromosomes and DNA molecules in a cell with 2n = 4, the balance of a population, and two communities with the same number of individuals.
In a cell with 2n = 4, say for G2, for anaphase and for each daughter cell how many chromosomes and how many DNA molecules there are, stating whether the number refers to the whole cell or to one daughter cell.
A population has N₀ = 120 individuals on 3 ha. In one year 30 are born, 18 die, 12 immigrate and 24 emigrate. Work out N₁ and the density. Then redo the calculation for emigration of 6.
Two communities each have 20 individuals from 4 species: A has 5, 5, 5 and 5 individuals per species, and B has 17, 1, 1 and 1. For each, work out the dominance of the most numerous species.
Give two explanations of why an equal total does not prove an identical system, using two of the cases above.
Solution and mark scheme, E04
Page for the teacher.
G2: 4 chromosomes and 8 DNA molecules, in one cell. Anaphase: 8 chromosomes and 8 DNA molecules, in the whole cell. Each daughter cell: 4 chromosomes and 4 DNA molecules.
N₁ = 120 + 30 − 18 + 12 − 24 = 120; the density is 120 ÷ 3 = 40 individuals per hectare. With emigration of 6: N₁ = 120 + 30 − 18 + 12 − 6 = 138, that is 46 individuals per hectare.
Community A: 5 ÷ 20 × 100 = 25%. Community B: 17 ÷ 20 × 100 = 85%. They have the same number of individuals (20) and of species (4), but B is dominated by a single species, so its diversity is lower.
Examples: the same population size (120) can hide large numbers of births and deaths that cancel out, or migration; an equal number of 8 can mean 8 DNA molecules in a cell in G2 or 8 chromosomes in anaphase, because the chromatids become separate chromosomes; the same number of individuals and species can mean communities divided up differently.
Mark scheme
| Criterion | 0 marks | 1 mark | 2 marks |
|---|---|---|---|
| The counting unit in the cell | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| The balance and the density | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| Dominance and diversity | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| The argued comparison | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
Maximum 8 marks. The final mark, if one is given, is set by the teacher; the rubric has no official threshold. The assessment does not require meiosis or Mendelian probabilities.