Chemistry 9 RO
A block of sodium chloride, 144 ions in four layers: small orange Na⁺ ions and large green Cl⁻ ions alternating in three directions, with a + or − sign on the front face; the top layer is pushed sideways, and a semi-transparent plane marks where it slips.

Chemical bonds

Chapter 6

Ionic and metallic bonds – why salt shatters and copper bends

Why does salt shatter while copper bends?

Table salt breaks between two spoons, while a copper wire bends without cracking. The picture shows why, drawn to scale: first a block of salt, then one of copper, each with its own particles. Start with a prediction, then push a layer.

The same hammer, two materials

A salt crystal and a copper wire are hit with the same hammer. The block in the picture is a fragment of a salt crystal: 144 ions, 72 Na⁺ and 72 Cl⁻.

What happens to each material?

Every ion has six neighbours of opposite sign

The block is drawn to scale: Na⁺ has a radius of 102 pm, Cl⁻ 181 pm (1 pm is a billionth of a millimetre). The edge of the unit cell, measured, is 564 pm.

An ion inside touches six ions of opposite sign: four in the same plane, one above and one below. The distance between the centres of two neighbours is 282 pm, half the cell edge. The radii give an edge of 2 · (102 + 181) = 566 pm: close values, not identical.

Push the top layer by half a cell

The top two layers slide along the marked plane. Drag sideways on the picture or use the buttons. At 282 pm, half the cell edge, each ion in the top half sits above an ion of the same sign.

The number in the corner of the picture shows how far you have pushed. The "Energy between the halves" box shows the electrostatic energy in electronvolts (eV; 1 eV is the energy gained by an electron that passes through a potential difference of one volt): at the start it is −15.3 eV. The ions keep their charges; only who sits next to whom changes.

The energy between the halves goes from negative to positive

A top ion is attracted by ions of opposite sign and repelled by ions of the same sign. For the 144 ions drawn, the energy between the two halves is calculated with Coulomb's law, treating the ions as point charges in a vacuum.

Before the push the energy is −15.3 eV: negative, so the halves are bound. It passes through zero at 166 pm, and at 282 pm it is +3.3 eV: positive, so the repulsion between ions of the same sign beats the attraction. The arrows mark the pairs of the same sign that face each other.

The layer rises slightly as it slides, just enough to keep the spheres from overlapping (78 pm at the end). The values are for the block drawn.

Salt does not bend: it splits along a plane

With the layer displaced, ions of the same sign sit face to face. If the halves move apart, the energy falls: from +3.3 eV to almost zero, when the top half is lifted by a further 423 pm. Ions of the same sign repel each other, so the halves tend to separate.

That is why salt is hard but brittle: the attractions between the ions are strong, yet the crystal does not allow a layer to slide. Real salt splits along planes parallel to the faces of the cube: this is an observed property, which the calculation here, with two rigid halves, illustrates.

In copper, the layer lands in positions just like before

Copper has positive ions in a cloud of electrons: one from each atom, 216 ions and 216 electrons in the block. Two neighbouring ions are 255.6 pm apart.

Push the top layer by one distance between neighbours: the ions end up in the same positions relative to one another, and an ion in the pushed layer again has 12 close neighbours (at half a step, 10). The positive ions repel one another, but the shared electrons hold them together: the metal bends without breaking.

In a real metal, defects slide, not whole layers; the drawing shows the simplest version.

Only free particles carry current

What you see. Two plates, one negative and one positive, and a bulb in the circuit. What the particles do. In solid salt the ions stay in place: 0 of 144 are free, and the bulb stays off. In molten salt at 801 °C (a demonstration done by the teacher only; in the picture it is a drawing) all 144 are free: Na⁺ moves towards the negative plate, Cl⁻ towards the positive one. In copper, 216 electrons move among the fixed ions.

How it is written. NaCl(s) → NaCl(l), with the same ions.

Now you explain

An aluminium can is crushed when you step on it, but it does not fall apart into shards. Aluminium is a metal, like the copper in the picture, with the layer pushed two steps.

Explain in a few sentences why the can deforms and does not break, using what you saw about the layer and the electrons.

Compare with an answer

In a metal, one layer of positive ions slides over another and lands in positions just like the ones before. The electrons belong to the whole block and hold the ions together even after the slide, so the metal deforms. In an ionic crystal, the displaced layer brings ions of the same sign face to face; they repel each other, and the crystal breaks.

Lesson: the sodium chloride crystal · Lesson: metallic bonding

Diagram and calculation. Diagram to scale: the positions of the ions come from the measured cell edges (NaCl 564 pm, Cu 361.5 pm), and the radii of Na⁺ and Cl⁻ are the Shannon ionic radii (102 and 181 pm). The electrostatic energy between the halves is calculated for the 144 ions drawn, as point charges in a vacuum, with no other forces, and the halves are rigid; so that the spheres do not overlap, the top half is lifted as far as it needs to be, a choice of the drawing. The cleavage of salt is an observed property; the calculation illustrates it, it does not prove it. The copper cores are drawn smaller than in reality, so that the electrons show, and the molten salt is a drawing, not a calculation. In a real metal, defects slide, not whole layers. Atoms and ions have no colour: they are drawn enormously enlarged and far fewer than in reality. Salt is melted only as a demonstration done by the teacher.

Sources and credits. NaCl unit cell edge: 564.02 pm, value quoted from Wikipedia, "Sodium chloride", and checked in the Crystallography Open Database (entries 9003308 and 7132177, public domain). Cu unit cell edge: 361.5 pm (Swanson and Tatge, National Bureau of Standards, in the Crystallography Open Database, entry 5000216, public domain). Ionic radii: R. D. Shannon, Acta Crystallographica A32, 751 (1976), Imperial College London database. Vacuum permittivity: CODATA, NIST. Melting point of NaCl: PubChem.

The same data, as a table
QuantityValueHow it is obtained
NaCl unit cell edge564.02 pmmeasured
Edge from the sum of the ionic radii566 pmcalculated: 2 · (102 + 181)
Distance between a Na⁺ and a neighbouring Cl⁻282 pmhalf the measured edge
Radius of Na⁺, radius of Cl⁻102 pm, 181 pmShannon, coordination number 6
The block drawn144 ions: 72 Na⁺, 72 Cl⁻four layers of 6 × 6
Electrostatic energy between the halves of the block, before the push−15.3 eVcalculated: negative, the halves are bound
Push at which the energy passes through zero166 pmcalculated
Energy after a push of 282 pm+3.3 eVcalculated: positive, ions of the same sign face to face
Cu unit cell edge361.5 pmmeasured
Distance between two neighbouring copper ions255.6 pmthe edge divided by √2
Nearest neighbours of a copper ion12, before and after a push of 255.6 pmcounted in the block drawn
Neighbours of a copper ion in the pushed layer, at half a step10counted in the block drawn
Free particles: solid salt, molten salt, copper0 of 144 ions; 144 of 144 ions; 216 electrons of 216 copper ionsdrawing of the motion, numbers from the block
Melting point of NaCl801 °Cmeasured

Lessons of the chapter

Lessons: 3 lessons TC, 2 lessons MI. The badge of each lesson says which profile it belongs to.

Which profile are you on?

  1. 6.1What holds the ions in a salt crystal together TC · beyond your profileClassification of chemical bondsSodium is a metal that reacts violently with water, and chlorine is a poisonous gas. How can they make the salt on your table?
  2. 6.2Why the formulas are NaF, CaF₂ and Na₂O TC · beyond your profileIonic compounds – formation of compounds: sodium fluoride, calcium fluoride, sodium chloride, sodium oxide, calcium oxideA toothpaste label says sodium fluoride, NaF. Calcium fluoride is written CaF₂. Where does the subscript 2 come from?
  3. 6.3Why salt is hard but brittle TC · beyond your profileThe sodium chloride crystal: characterisationA grain of salt breaks without bending, yet salt melts only at 801 °C. How are its ions arranged to make this happen?
  4. 6.4Why magnesium oxide melts above 2,800 °C and salt at 801 °C MI · beyond your profileProperties of ionic substances: state of matter, melting point, variation of melting points for: - sodium fluoride, sodium chloride - sodium fluoride, potassium fluoride - sodium fluoride, magnesium oxide - sodium fluoride, magnesium fluoride, aluminium fluorideTable salt melts at 801 °C, while magnesium oxide melts only above 2,800 °C. What makes their ions hold together so strongly?
  5. 6.5Why copper conducts electricity and bends, while salt breaks MI · beyond your profileMetallic bondingA copper wire bends and conducts electricity when solid. A salt crystal breaks and does not conduct. What is different inside?

Test tomorrowten questions from chapter 6For the class: projector, sheets, shared test