Biology IX RO

Integrated assessment E03 · common core

A measure for the school grounds, a conclusion that matches the data

Working time: 40–50 minutes · Lessons 9.3, 9.4, 10.1, 10.3 · 8 marks

Back to the teachers’ page

Full nameClassDate

In the school grounds, pupils sow wild flowers on one plot (the intervention plot) and leave another unchanged (the comparison plot). They count insect visits to the flowers, over 10 minutes each time, on three days. The data are invented for the exercise. Then the school wants to use less paper for the same service: 10,000 sheets a year, of 5 g each, become 4,000 sheets.

PlotBefore (visits in 10 minutes)After (visits in 10 minutes)
With intervention4; 5; 68; 9; 10
Comparison4; 4; 45; 6; 7
  1. Work out the means before and after for each plot, the change in each, and the difference between the two changes.

  2. Explain why visits are not the same as the number of insects and why the observations do not prove the cause on their own.

  3. Work out the mass of paper before and after, the saving in kilograms and the reduction in per cent. Do not turn the result into a reduction in the school’s whole ecological footprint.

  4. Choose a measure for the school grounds and state the indicator, a comparison, when you will review it and one unwanted effect you will watch for.

Solution and mark scheme, E03

Page for the teacher.

  1. Intervention plot: the mean goes from 5 to 9, a change of 4 visits. Comparison plot: from 4 to 6, a change of 2. The difference between the changes is 2 visits in 10 minutes.

  2. The same insect can visit the flowers several times, so the number of visits is not the number of insects. The comparison plot also rose (perhaps because of the weather or the season), and the observations do not isolate a single cause.

  3. Before: 10,000 × 5 g = 50 kg. After: 4,000 × 5 g = 20 kg. The saving is 30 kg, a 60% reduction in the paper used. Paper is only one part of the school’s footprint.

  4. A good plan has a clear indicator and a unit, a comparison with a place or a time without the measure, a review date and an unwanted effect (for example, a play area taken over or an unwanted species spreading). Any well-argued choice receives full marks.

Mark scheme

Criterion0 marks1 mark2 marks
Calculations and unitsmissing or self-contradictorycorrect, with an important omissioncoherent explanation
Interpreting the indicatorsmissing or self-contradictorycorrect, with an important omissioncoherent explanation
Limits of the conclusionmissing or self-contradictorycorrect, with an important omissioncoherent explanation
A plan that can be checkedmissing or self-contradictorycorrect, with an important omissioncoherent explanation

Maximum 8 marks. The final mark, if one is given, is set by the teacher; the rubric has no official threshold.