Chemistry 9 RO

Chapter 8 · Between moleculesLesson 8.1MI Mathematics–informatics (2 hours) · beyond your profile

Dipole–dipole attraction, hydrogen bond, London (dispersion) forces

Why chlorine is a gas, bromine a liquid and iodine a solid

Chlorine, bromine and iodine are made of similar molecules. Why is one a gas, another a liquid and the third a solid?

Test tomorrowten questions from chapter 8

Before you read: what do you think?

At 20 °C, chlorine (Cl₂) is a gas and bromine (Br₂) is a liquid. Both molecules are non-polar. What explains the difference?

See the answer

Bromine molecules have 70 electrons, chlorine molecules 34. The larger the electron cloud, the greater the attraction between molecules, called a London force. Liquid bromine boils at 59 °C, but the Br–Br bond stays intact.

In a cooking gas cylinder, butane is a liquid. Open the valve and the pressure drops; the liquid boils slowly and comes out as a gas, which burns in the flame. The butane molecules are the same in the liquid and the gas; the only change is that they have moved farther apart.

Three halogens, three states of matterWhat you see

At 20 °C, chlorine is a gas, bromine is a liquid and iodine is a solid. The state at a given temperature follows from the melting and boiling points: bromine melts at −7 °C and boils at 59 °C, so 20 °C lies between the two and bromine is liquid. Iodine melts at 114 °C, so at 20 °C it is solid. Chlorine boils at −34 °C, well below 20 °C, so it is a gas.

The three substances consist of non-polar diatomic molecules, Cl₂, Br₂ and I₂, with the same single covalent bond. The difference in their states comes from the attractions between molecules; the bond within them is the same.

The bond within a molecule and the attraction between moleculesWhat the particles do

Two chlorine atoms in a molecule are held together by a covalent bond. Much weaker attractions, called intermolecular interactions, act between neighbouring molecules. When a liquid boils, the molecules move apart and these attractions break; the bonds within the molecules stay intact.

Gaseous hydrogen chloride, HCl, shows the scale of the difference. Breaking the H–Cl bond takes 432 kJ/mol. Evaporating liquid HCl takes just 16.2 kJ/mol, at its boiling point. The ratio is 432 ÷ 16.2 ≈ 26.7, so the bond within the molecule is about 27 times stronger than the attractions between molecules. The vapour rising from the liquid still consists of HCl molecules.

Dipole–dipole: oppositely charged ends attractWhat the particles do

The HCl molecule is polar: chlorine, the more electronegative element, has a partial negative charge (δ−), and hydrogen a partial positive charge (δ+). In the liquid, polar molecules align with the positive end towards the negative end of a neighbour. The attraction between permanent dipoles is called dipole–dipole attraction (also called a dipole–dipole interaction in textbooks).

HClδ+δ−HClδ+δ−in molecule:covalent bondbetween moleculesdipole–dipole forcebreaking H–Cl bond: 432 kJ/molevaporating HCl: 16.2 kJ/mol≈ 27 times less
Figure 1Breaking the H–Cl bond within the molecule (line) takes 432 kJ/mol; evaporating HCl, which breaks only attractions between molecules (dots), takes 16.2 kJ/mol. The bars are drawn to scale.

London forces: non-polar molecules attract tooWhat the particles do

The electrons in a non-polar molecule are in constant motion. For a fraction of a second, there may be more at one end of the molecule than at the other, creating an instantaneous dipole. This distorts the electron cloud of a neighbouring molecule, turning it into a dipole oriented so that the two attract. The attraction is called a London force or dispersion force; it was explained in 1930 by the physicist Fritz London. It exists between all molecules, polar or non-polar, and between noble gas atoms.

In similar series, the more electrons a molecule has, the more easily its cloud distorts and the stronger the London attraction. Noble gases show the effect without any other force: helium (2 electrons) boils at −269 °C, neon (10) at −246 °C, argon (18) at −186 °C, krypton (36) at −153 °C, xenon (54) at −108 °C. The halogens follow the same trend: F₂ (18 electrons) boils at −188 °C, Cl₂ (34) at −34 °C, Br₂ (70) at 59 °C, I₂ (106) at 184 °C.

For the curious

Molecular shape matters. Butane and isobutane have the same formula, C₄H₁₀, and the same number of electrons, but butane, with its extended chain, boils at −0.5 °C, while the more compact isobutane boils at −11.7 °C. Elongated molecules touch over a larger surface and attract each other more strongly.

1. Electron cloudssymmetricCl₂Cl₂2. Instantaneousdipoleδ+δ−3. Neighbour is a dipole:attraction (London force)δ+δ−δ+δ−
Figure 2A fleeting dipole in one Cl₂ molecule distorts the electron cloud of its neighbour, and the two attract: this is the London force. The drawing is a diagram; the clouds have no sharp edges.

How to write the interaction and compare substancesHow it is written

The attraction between molecules is shown with dots, to distinguish it from the line of a covalent bond:

Hδ+–Clδ− ··· Hδ+–Clδ−

To order boiling points, first count the electrons, because London forces increase with their number, then check polarity. H₂ has 2 electrons, is non-polar and boils at −253 °C. HCl has 18 electrons, is polar and boils at −85 °C. Cl₂ has 34 electrons, is non-polar and boils at −34 °C.

Non-polar chlorine therefore boils at a higher temperature than polar HCl: its 34 electrons produce a stronger London attraction than the attraction added by the dipole in HCl. That is the classic trap. With the same number of electrons and similar shapes, polarity makes the difference: argon and HCl each have 18 electrons, and argon boils at −186 °C, HCl at −85 °C.

Worked example

Order H₂, F₂, HCl and Cl₂ by boiling point

Put the boiling points of H₂, F₂, HCl and Cl₂ in ascending order.

Step 1, electron count: H₂ has 2 · 1 = 2; F₂ has 2 · 9 = 18; HCl has 1 + 17 = 18; Cl₂ has 2 · 17 = 34.

Step 2, polarity: H₂, F₂ and Cl₂ are non-polar; HCl is polar.

Step 3, order: H₂ has the fewest electrons and the lowest boiling point. F₂ and HCl have the same number of electrons, and HCl has the additional dipole–dipole attraction, so it boils at a higher temperature than F₂. Cl₂ has nearly twice as many electrons as HCl and boils at the highest temperature.

Result: H₂ < F₂ < HCl < Cl₂. Measured values confirm the order: −253 °C, −188 °C, −85 °C, −34 °C. Check: all four are below 0 °C, so all are gases at room temperature, as they are in reality.

In Romania

The cooking gas cylinder

A cooking gas cylinder contains liquefied petroleum gas (LPG). The safety data sheet for butane LPG, published by Petrom, gives hydrocarbons with four carbon atoms as at least 90% by mass and those with three carbon atoms as at most 10%. Butane boils at −0.5 °C and propane at −42.1 °C, at normal pressure. The sheet gives a vapour pressure of at most 750 kPa at 50 °C, about 7.4 times normal atmospheric pressure.

The molecules of both hydrocarbons are non-polar, so only London forces act between them. Propane has 26 electrons, butane 34, and propane boils at a lower temperature. When you open the valve, the pressure above the liquid drops, the liquid boils and molecules pass into the gas.

In short

  1. Intermolecular interactions are much weaker than the covalent bonds within a molecule: for HCl, 16.2 kJ/mol for evaporation compared with 432 kJ/mol for the H–Cl bond.
  2. On melting and boiling, attractions between molecules break; bonds within the molecules stay intact.
  3. Dipole–dipole attraction occurs between polar molecules, between the δ+ end of one molecule and the δ− end of another (for example HCl).
  4. London (dispersion) forces exist between all molecules; they increase with the number of electrons: F₂ and Cl₂ are gases, Br₂ is a liquid, I₂ is a solid.
  5. The boiling point order H₂ < HCl < Cl₂ shows that the number of electrons can matter more than polarity.
WorksheetMy notebook

Common mistakes

  • WrongWhen HCl boils, the H–Cl bonds break.

    RightThe attractions between molecules break. The vapour still consists of HCl molecules, with the H–Cl bond intact.

  • WrongLondon forces exist only between non-polar molecules.

    RightThey exist between all molecules. HCl has both dipole–dipole attractions and London forces.

  • WrongHCl is polar, so it boils at a higher temperature than non-polar Cl₂.

    RightCl₂ has 34 electrons and HCl only 18, so the London forces of Cl₂ are stronger. Cl₂ boils at −34 °C, HCl at −85 °C.

Test yourself

8 questions. For the first 7 you see the explanation at once, with the paragraph of the lesson that supports it; for the written ones you compare with a good answer.

  1. What mainly breaks when liquid HCl boils?

    Answer

    b) The attractions between molecules. HCl vapour consists of intact molecules. Only the attractions between molecules break, with energies of the order of 16 kJ/mol.

  2. Which substance has the highest boiling point: H₂, F₂, HCl or Cl₂?

    Answer

    d) Cl₂. Cl₂ has 34 electrons, so it has the strongest London forces. HCl is polar, but has only 18 electrons.

  3. Between which molecules do London forces act?

    Answer

    c) Between all molecules. Instantaneous dipoles arise in any electron cloud, whether or not the molecule has a permanent dipole.

  4. Argon and HCl have the same number of electrons (18). Why does HCl boil at almost 100 °C higher?

    Answer

    b) HCl has dipole–dipole attractions as well as London forces. With the same number of electrons, London forces are comparable, and the polarity of HCl adds dipole–dipole attraction.

  5. Evaporating liquid HCl takes 16.2 kJ per mole, at its boiling point. How many kJ does it take to evaporate 73 g of HCl? Given M(HCl) = 36.5 g/mol. Round to one decimal place.

    kJ
    Answer

    32.4 kJ. n = 73 ÷ 36.5 = 2 mol; Q = 2 · 16.2 = 32.4 kJ. Breaking the H–Cl bonds in the same 2 mol would take 2 · 432 = 864 kJ.

  6. How many electrons does a bromine molecule, Br₂, have? (Z for bromine is 35.)

    electrons
    Answer

    70 electrons. Each bromine atom has 35 electrons; the molecule has 2 · 35 = 70.

  7. Order the noble gases from lowest to highest boiling point.

    Answer

    The correct order:

    1. Helium
    2. Neon
    3. Argon
    4. Krypton
    5. Xenon

    Boiling point rises with the number of electrons: 2, 10, 18, 36, 54.

  8. HCl is polar and Cl₂ is non-polar. Explain why Cl₂ nevertheless boils at a higher temperature.

    A good answer

    Both substances have London forces, and HCl also has dipole–dipole attractions. The Cl₂ molecule has 34 electrons, compared with 18 in HCl, so its cloud distorts more easily and the London forces between Cl₂ molecules are much stronger. The extra attraction from the dipole does not make up for this difference, so Cl₂ (−34 °C) boils at a higher temperature than HCl (−85 °C).

    A complete answer names both types of force, compares electron counts and concludes with the temperature values.

Terms

intermolecular interaction
A weak attraction between molecules, much weaker than the covalent bond within them.
dipole–dipole attraction
The attraction between the positive end of one polar molecule and the negative end of another.
London (dispersion) force
The attraction between instantaneous dipoles that arise in the electron cloud of any molecule or atom.
instantaneous dipole
A fleeting separation of charges in a non-polar molecule, caused by the movement of electrons.
polar molecule
A molecule in which the centre of partial positive charges does not coincide with the centre of partial negative charges.
boiling point
The temperature at which a liquid turns to gas throughout its volume, at a given pressure.
Sources and link to the programme

From the programme: “Dipole–dipole attraction, hydrogen bond, London (dispersion) forces” (MI: Mathematics–informatics (2 hours)). Specific competences followed: 1.4, 2.4, 4.4, 5.4.