Chemistry 9 RO

Chapter 2 · Chemical reactionsLesson 2.3TC Core curriculum (1 hour a week) · beyond your profile

Reactions without / with a change in oxidation number

How to tell whether a reaction changes oxidation numbers

An iron nail in a blue solution becomes coated with copper, while two colourless solutions produce a white solid. What sets the two reactions apart?

Test tomorrowten questions from chapter 2

Before you read: what do you think?

Three reactions: HCl with NaOH (neutralisation), AgNO₃ with NaCl (precipitation), and iron in CuSO₄ solution. In how many does an element change its oxidation number?

See the answer

Only in the third. Iron goes from 0 to +2, and copper from +2 to 0. In the first two, all elements keep the same oxidation number, although new substances form.

The teacher dips a clean iron nail into a blue copper sulfate solution. After a few minutes, the nail has a reddish coating and the blue solution has faded. In another beaker, two colourless solutions, silver nitrate and sodium chloride, produce a white solid. Both are chemical reactions, but in one of them atoms change their oxidation numbers.

The criterion: does the oxidation number change?

Chemical reactions can be divided by several criteria. One is oxidation number (N.O.). If no element in the equation changes its N.O., the reaction is without a change in oxidation number. If at least one element changes it, the reaction is with a change in oxidation number, or a redox reaction.

An increase in an element’s N.O. is called oxidation; a decrease is called reduction. In a redox reaction they occur together: if one element has a higher N.O. after the reaction, another has a lower one.

Write the balanced equation, find the N.O. of each element, compare the N.O. in the reactants with those in the products, and draw a conclusion.

Without a change in N.O.: neutralisation, precipitation, carbonates

Neutralisation: HCl + NaOH → NaCl + H₂O. HCl: H +1, Cl −1. NaOH: Na +1, O −2, H +1. NaCl: Na +1, Cl −1. H₂O: H +1, O −2. No element has changed its N.O., although the reaction releases heat.

Precipitation: AgNO₃ + NaCl → AgCl + NaNO₃. Silver nitrate solution and sodium chloride solution produce a white solid, silver chloride. Silver stays at +1, chlorine at −1, sodium at +1, and nitrogen and oxygen in NO₃⁻ at +5 and −2. The ions simply exchange partners.

Decomposition of carbonates: CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂. CaCO₃: Ca +2, C +4, O −2. CaO: Ca +2, O −2. CO₂: C +4, O −2. Nothing changes its N.O. Double displacement reactions between ions that form a precipitate, a gas or water are without a change in N.O.

no change in N.O. H Cl + Na O H → Na Cl + H₂ O +1 −1 +1 −2 +1 +1 −1 +1 −2 N.O. unchanged for each element N.O. changes (redox) Fe + Cu S O₄ → Fe S O₄ + Cu 0 +2 +6 −2 +2 +6 −2 0 Fe: 0 → +2, rises: oxidation Cu: +2 → 0, falls: reduction
Figure 1Compare the N.O. on the left and right, element by element. In neutralisation none changes; in displacement iron rises and copper falls, so the reaction is redox.

With a change in N.O.: combustion, metal with acid, displacement

Combustion: C + O₂ → CO₂. Carbon rises from 0 to +4 and is oxidised; oxygen falls from 0 to −2 and is reduced.

Metal with acid: Zn + 2HCl → ZnCl₂ + H₂. Zinc rises from 0 to +2, hydrogen falls from +1 to 0.

Displacement: Fe + CuSO₄ → FeSO₄ + Cu. Iron rises from 0 to +2, copper falls from +2 to 0, and sulfur (+6) and oxygen (−2) stay unchanged. The teacher demonstrates the reaction by dipping a clean iron nail into a blue copper sulfate solution: the nail becomes coated with reddish copper.

Decomposition of some nitrates is redox. In 2NaNO₃ → 2NaNO₂ + O₂ nitrogen falls from +5 to +3, while oxygen in the nitrate rises from −2 to 0 in O₂. In NH₄NO₃ → N₂O + 2H₂O the nitrogen in NH₄⁺ (−3) and that in NO₃⁻ (+5) both reach +1. Sodium nitrate decomposition is described only on paper or seen in a teacher’s demonstration or a film, because it releases gas and requires heat. Ammonium nitrate decomposition remains an equation: it is dangerous when heated.

What you see before iron nail solution blue after reddish layer of copper paler What the particles do Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Fe Cu Fe²⁺ enters solution Cu²⁺ deposits 2 electrons pass through metal Cu²⁺ 2− 2− 2− How it is written Fe + CuSO₄ → FeSO₄ + Cu 2− ions are sulfate ions: unchanged
Figure 2Each iron atom that enters the solution as Fe²⁺ leaves two electrons in the metal; a Cu²⁺ ion takes them and deposits as a copper atom, forming the reddish coating. A demonstration done by the teacher; water is not shown and the particles are not to scale.

The same reaction, several criteria

Reaction type (combination, decomposition, displacement, double displacement) and the N.O. criterion are independent. A combination can be without a change in N.O., as in CaO + H₂O → Ca(OH)₂, or redox, as in 2Mg + O₂ → 2MgO. A decomposition can be without a change in N.O., as in CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂, or redox, as in 2H₂O₂ → 2H₂O + O₂.

Displacement, in which one element takes the place of another in a compound, is always redox. Double displacement between two compounds is without a change in N.O. A reaction can also be classified by other criteria, such as the heat released or absorbed.

For the curious

In 2H₂O₂ → 2H₂O + O₂, the same element rises and falls: oxygen goes from −1 to −2 in water and to 0 in O₂. A process in which a species is both oxidised and reduced is called disproportionation.

Worked example

Classify reactions by all the criteria

The reactions are (a) 2Mg + O₂ → 2MgO and (b) CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂. For each, find the type and apply the N.O. criterion.

(a) The equation is balanced: Mg 2 = 2, O 2 = 2. Magnesium rises from 0 to +2, oxygen falls from 0 to −2. N.O. changes, so the reaction is redox. Two substances produce one: combination.

(b) The equation is balanced: Ca 1 = 1, C 1 = 1, O 3 = 3. CaCO₃: Ca +2, C +4, O −2. CaO: Ca +2, O −2. CO₂: C +4, O −2. No N.O. changes, so the reaction is without a change in N.O. One substance produces two: decomposition.

Conclusion: (a) combination, with a change in N.O.; (b) decomposition, without a change in N.O.

In Romania

Removing copper from mine water with iron

The National Research and Development Institute for Nonferrous and Rare Metals (IMNR) filed a patent application in 2015 for treating acidic mine water. The first step removes copper with iron powder, using the same equation as for the nail in the beaker: Fe + Cu²⁺ → Fe²⁺ + Cu. Iron rises from 0 to +2, copper falls from +2 to 0.

In the patent example, 2 L of mine water containing 0.46 g of copper per litre were mixed with 12 g of iron powder. The water contained 2 · 0.46 = 0.92 g of copper. With M(Cu) = 64 g/mol, the amount of copper is 0.92 ÷ 64 ≈ 0.0144 mol. For the copper alone, 0.0144 · 56 ≈ 0.8 g of iron is needed, with M(Fe) = 56 g/mol, and the patent says the iron powder is added in excess. The mixture yielded 4.4 g of “copper cement”, a copper-rich solid.

In short

  1. A reaction is without a change in oxidation number if no element changes its N.O., and with a change in oxidation number (redox) if at least one element changes it.
  2. An increase in N.O. is oxidation, a decrease is reduction; in a redox reaction they occur together.
  3. Neutralisation, precipitation (AgNO₃ + NaCl → AgCl + NaNO₃), decomposition of carbonates and double displacement reactions between ions are without a change in N.O.
  4. Combustion, metal + acid reactions, displacement reactions (Fe + CuSO₄ → FeSO₄ + Cu) and decomposition of nitrates are with a change in N.O.
  5. A reaction is classified by several independent criteria: its type (combination, decomposition, displacement, double displacement) and N.O.
WorksheetMy notebook

Common mistakes

  • WrongIf a reaction releases heat or a gas, it is redox.

    RightThe criterion is the change in N.O. Neutralisation releases heat and calcium carbonate decomposition releases carbon dioxide, but neither changes an N.O.

  • WrongOxidation always means combining with oxygen.

    RightOxidation is an increase in an element’s N.O. Zinc is also oxidised in copper solution, without oxygen: it goes from 0 to +2.

  • WrongNo reaction occurs in precipitation because no N.O. changes.

    RightA new solid substance forms. The reaction is chemical, but without a change in N.O.

Test yourself

7 questions. For the first 6 you see the explanation at once, with the paragraph of the lesson that supports it; for the written ones you compare with a good answer.

  1. Which reaction is without a change in oxidation number?

    Answer

    c) AgNO₃ + NaCl → AgCl + NaNO₃. In the precipitation of AgCl, silver stays at +1, chlorine at −1 and sodium at +1. In the other three, an N.O. changes.

  2. What happens to iron in the reaction Fe + CuSO₄ → FeSO₄ + Cu?

    Answer

    d) It rises from 0 to +2. Metallic iron has N.O. 0, and in FeSO₄ it has +2: it rises, so iron is oxidised.

  3. Which statement about reaction type and N.O. is true?

    Answer

    c) A decomposition can be redox or without a change in N.O. CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂ changes no N.O., while 2H₂O₂ → 2H₂O + O₂ changes the N.O. of oxygen. Both are decompositions.

  4. How many grams of copper are in 2 L of mine water with 0.46 g of copper per litre? Round to two decimal places.

    g
    Answer

    0.92 g. The mass of copper is the volume multiplied by the concentration: 2 · 0.46 = 0.92 g.

  5. Put the steps for classifying a reaction by N.O. in order.

    Answer

    The correct order:

    1. Write the balanced equation
    2. Find the N.O. of each element in each formula
    3. Compare the N.O. in the reactants with those in the products
    4. Draw a conclusion: without a change or redox

    The balanced equation comes first. You need N.O. to compare them, and the conclusion follows the comparison.

  6. Put each reaction in its category.

    Answer

    Without a change in N.O.: HCl + NaOH → NaCl + H₂O; BaCl₂ + Na₂SO₄ → BaSO₄ + 2NaCl; CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂.

    With a change in N.O. (redox): 2Mg + O₂ → 2MgO; Zn + CuSO₄ → ZnSO₄ + Cu; 2H₂O₂ → 2H₂O + O₂.

    In the first three no element changes its N.O. In the last three, at least one element changes it: Mg, Zn and Cu, O.

  7. A classmate says every decomposition reaction is redox because the substance “breaks down”. Give a counterexample and an example, with N.O.

    A good answer

    Counterexample: CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂, in which Ca is +2, C is +4 and O is −2 in every formula, so no N.O. changes. Redox example: 2H₂O₂ → 2H₂O + O₂, in which oxygen goes from −1 to −2 in water and to 0 in O₂.

    A complete answer gives a counterexample with unchanged N.O., an example with changed N.O., and the conclusion that reaction type does not decide the N.O. criterion.

Terms

reaction without a change in oxidation number
A reaction in which no element changes its oxidation number, such as neutralisation or precipitation.
redox reaction
A reaction with a change in oxidation number, in which at least one element changes its N.O.
oxidation
An increase in the oxidation number of an element in a reaction.
reduction
A decrease in the oxidation number of an element in a reaction.
precipitate
A sparingly soluble solid substance that forms in a solution as a result of a reaction.
cementation
Removal of a metal from a solution as metal using another metal, as with copper removed from mine water using iron.
Sources and link to the programme

From the programme: “Reactions without / with a change in oxidation number”; “For the content area Classification of reactions in inorganic chemistry, reactions will be classified according to the given criteria, and different examples of chemical reactions will be presented for each type. For Exothermic and endothermic reactions, examples will also include the decomposition of some nitrates and carbonates” (TC: Core curriculum (1 hour a week)). Specific competences followed: 1.1, 1.2, 2.1, 2.2, 3.1, 4.1, 6.1.