Integrated assessment E02 · common core
A single character does not make a classification
Three plants are described only by their characters. Plant A has vascular tissue, reproduces by spores and does not make seeds. Plant B has seeds not enclosed in a fruit and needle-shaped leaves. Plant C has flowers and seeds enclosed in a fruit.
Say which group each plant belongs to and justify it with two characters.
Explain why the bat is not classified among the birds, even though it flies.
A tree of life with four tips is written ((A, B), (C, D)). A classmate draws it as ((D, C), (B, A)). Say whether it is the same tree and which are the sister groups.
All you know about an organism is that it is green and lives in a damp place. Give a correct answer to the question “Which plant is it?”.
Solution and mark scheme, E02
Page for the teacher.
A is a seedless vascular plant, in the school classification a fern: it has vascular tissue and reproduces by spores. B is a gymnosperm: the seed is not enclosed in a fruit, and needle-shaped leaves are typical of conifers. C is an angiosperm: it has flowers, and the seeds are enclosed in a fruit.
The bat has hair and mammary glands, gives birth to live young and has a constant body temperature: it is a mammal. Flight appears in several groups (insects, birds, bats), so it is not a character that defines birds.
It is the same tree: rotating the branches around a branching point does not change the information; what matters is who splits from whom. The sister groups are A with B and C with D.
The information is not enough to identify the plant: green colour and damp places are found in several groups. A correct answer asks for more characters: does it have vascular tissue? does it make seeds? does it have flowers?
Mark scheme
| Criterion | 0 marks | 1 mark | 2 marks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Use of characters | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| Functional similarity is not relatedness | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| Reading the tree | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
| Recognising insufficient information | missing or self-contradictory | correct, with an important omission | coherent explanation |
Maximum 8 marks. The final mark, if one is given, is set by the teacher; the rubric has no official threshold.